6 ms·
Equal pay in 1896: The trail-blazing women of Kew Gardens
- nkkollaw 8y agoFrom what I know, women weren't employed not only because sure--they had to take care of the children and they could hardly "escape" that role, but also because before tampons and pain killers were invented menstruations would make it really hard for them to work. As for equal pay/pay gap, as far as I know it's a myth and 0 economists are working on this problem because it just doesn't exist. Women work different jobs that pay less and are not as willing to devote their whole life to working like some men do. The article seems to have a slight tone of criticism, as to remind us that back then women got paid the same, while nowadays they aren't (which of course isn't true). Maybe it's just me, though.
- dstrohmaier 8y agoThis denialism is not compatible with the facts. While part of the gender pay gap can be explained by the factors you describe, not all of it can. This unexplained part is often assumed to be (largely) due to discrimination. This unexplained part has also been shrinking over time, indicating that discrimination has decreased. (See https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13524-014-0320-y https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13524-014-0320-... ) Here are journal articles on the topics, showing that economic researchers are covering the topic: https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/209845 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/209845 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/00779950209544355 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/0077995020954435... https://journals.aom.org/doi/abs/10.5465/AMP.2007.24286161 https://journals.aom.org/doi/abs/10.5465/AMP.2007.24286161 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0730888486013003002 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/073088848601300... https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/001979390606000103 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/001979390606000... https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/344125 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/344125 You can find more publications here: https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=differential+pay+gender&btnG= https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=di... For a start, the Wikipedia article unifies many sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_pay_gap_in_the_United_States#Explaining_the_gender_pay_gap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_pay_gap_in_the_United_S...
- nkkollaw 8y ago"denialism", like it's an irrefutable fact? From Wikipedia I read: "a substantial portion of the pay gap (12%) remained unexplained.". Pretty small, and a lot smaller than what feminists claim the gap to be. Then, at the end of the same section you linked: "In 2018, economists at the University of Chicago and Stanford University, working with Uber analyzing the gender pay gap of Uber drivers demonstrated an average 7% pay gap in a context where gender discrimination was not possible and pay was not negotiated, showing the difference entirely explainable as the difference in average productivity between men and women". Am I mistaken in interpreting this to mean that only 5% is unexplained, and that "unexplained" does not mean evil patriarchy? Any group of people will be discriminated by 5%. For instance, I'm Italian. Are you telling me that in the States I won't find 5% (or even 12% or more) of people that think I'm dishonest, mafioso, lazy, etc..? Give me a break.
- dstrohmaier 8y agoI believe you are willfully misconstruing my position instead of trying to engage in the most charitable interpretation. You original comment which has now been flagged suggested that 0 economists took the issue of the gender gap serious. By "denialism" I meant to refer to your position of denying that this is an issue at all. That it is an issue treated by serious economists is a fact. You have since reneged from that denial, which I consider a step forward. What you are now questioning is how big an issue it is. Nowhere in my comment do I refer to any "evial patriarchy", although I do consider such an issue grave. If around half of the working population is discriminated against by 5% that would be a pretty huge issue overall. That other instances of discrimination exist, for example discrimination against people of Italian descent does not change that. I am afraid you are also incorrect in picking out the end of the Wikipedia section I linked to. As this section I linked to points out, the Uber setting is very special because the pay is set via the Uber company without hiring the drivers in the usual sense.
- nkkollaw 8y ago> I believe you are willfully misconstruing my position instead of trying to engage in the most charitable interpretation. I don't believe so. > You original comment which has now been flagged suggested that 0 economists took the issue of the gender gap serious. By "denialism" I meant to refer to your position of denying that this is an issue at all. That it is an issue treated by serious economists is a fact. You have since reneged from that denial, which I consider a step forward. What you are now questioning is how big an issue it is. I have no idea why it was flagged because it was a normal comment, and not even a very controversial position to hold. You're saying "has now been flagged" like I called for all women to be killed while swearing and offending people (perhaps to discredit me/my opinions?). As for changing my mind (or even "reneging from that denial"), I think you're overestimating yourself: you didn't present anything that made me change my mind. 10% of unaccounted "discrimination" would be proof that this is an issue? Even if it was (which we don't know), like I said you can find 10% of people that will discriminate against anything: Italians, women, attractive vs. unattractive people, blacks, blond people, fat people, skinny people. This whole thing is overblown. There are certain people that want to see injustice everywhere and will use the 10% pay gap that is unaccounted for to prove that there is a problem of women being oppressed, while either there is no problem, or it's so little to be negligible and most importantly similar to other biases. > I am afraid you are also incorrect in picking out the end of the Wikipedia section I linked to. As this section I linked to points out, the Uber setting is very special because the pay is set via the Uber company without hiring the drivers in the usual sense. I think it's a perfect example. Even taking away human bias--so, removing the hiring process, men and women perform differently. That's why it doesn't make sense to compare men and women like they're exactly the same, or why when you do you'll get a 10% discrepancy. You know what we could agree on? That we are human and will naturally be 10% biased towards anything. Not only women, but all groups of people I mentioned and more. Sometimes it's women, sometimes it's Italians, sometimes it's attractive vs. unattractive people. This obsession with equality of outcome creates a lot more problems than that 10%, considering that while you may lose 10% on your workplace because of bias/opinion X, you might gain 10% in other aspects of your life and at the end it just averages out. In first-world and second-world western countries people have equality of opportunity, which is what really counts. EDIT: HN doesn't allow me to reply to your comment below (thread too deep), but it's not worth it anyway.
- black-tea 8y agoWomen have always been paid the same as men for the same work. Why on earth would they not be? This seems completely unremarkable to me. It's almost as if the female author was looking to find evidence of a gender-based imbalance and couldn't, so decided it must have been "trail-blazing" women. Digging dirt for money is trail-blazing. Right.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dstrohmaier 8y agoNo they have not been and they were not paid the same because of sexist discrimination. Here is one article discussing the historical reduction (not eliminiation) of the gender pay gap: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13524-014-0320-y https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13524-014-0320-... As the article argues, the reduction is largely due to a reduction in the "unexplained part", which is usually attributed to discrimination. You can also find other sources on Wikipedia suggesting your claim is wrong: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Male–female_income_disparity_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Male–female_income_disparity_i...
- black-tea 8y agoI just don't understand how any thinking person can argue this. If women were actually taking less money for the same output then why would anyone hire a man? Discrimination surely exists, but do you really think that not one single company ever would take advantage of this fact to become successful?
- GreenToad5 8y agoWhy do comments here suggesting that there are compelling arguments concluding that adjusted wages are nearly identical get flagged and down-voted? There is certainly a debate to be had, silencing the other side suggests weakness of one's own position. I have never seen a good rebuttal against the adjusted wages are very nearly equal position. Things always get shut down, shouted down or otherwise silenced in some way. I would love to see direct claim-rebuttal positions taken with opposing reasoning and data.
- dstrohmaier 8y agoAs far as I can see, the comments did not (just) assert that adjusted wages were nearly identical. They asserted: 1) That this is not a serious issue and 0 economists study it. 2) That at no point in history was the adjusted wage different between men and women. (This was asserted and not argued for.) Comments which just asserted that adjusted wages might be nearly identical can still be seen. I agree that this might be debated. The other two opinions appear more extrem and much less plausible, as far as I am concerned.
- GreenToad5 8y agoI still feel that silencing someone is unhelpful. Why not let their claim stand? if outrageous - let it be handily refuted with logic and data and them made to look foolish. This is far more effective then silencing someone who then becomes a martyr. I also find it interesting that people on the far opposing side, those who come in with raw pay gap numbers whilst shouting "discrimination", they seem to always get a pass? Pay inequality has been well known since WW1, but all except a tiny portion of actual discrimination has been repeatedly dis-proven since the 1980s. Still huge numbers of people still parade the societal discrimination mantra proudly. People and parties run elections on it. Classes in prominent universities are taught preaching it (based on a few personal accounts, court cases and raw un-ajusted statistics). It is almost a religions justice objective for many to fix the unprovable wrongs of a system. Those are the people I often see shouting down the logical thinkers and data analysts.
- nkkollaw 8y agoThe best part is how _you_ are being silenced as well. I guess HN is one-sided. Certain opinions are now allowed.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoWhat a cess pit of bigoted bullshit the comments are. HN is the only place I have encountered in the modern world that still tries to argue against gender equality along with weak justifications for disparity. Arguments I haven't heard expressed at all in the UK since the 1970s or 80s. No one still asserts in good faith that the world is flat, pay inequality is not a serious issue, or reinvents the timeline of actual history or even thinks that there is still debate to be had. It's basically a settled issue, and I see no evidence that any UK or European men are pushing against it. America on the other hand, and I assume it's mostly the US nature of HN that causes this, seems to be still firmly stuck with the views of the 1950s. Still resenting the unfairness 60 years after equal pay laws? get real. FWIW I managed to read the article with interest, without a single thought it was a myth. Or screaming unfair from my wealthy white male, privileged perspective.
- nicc 8y agoWho has argued against gender equality..?
- ralusek 8y agoPeople aren't arguing that women and men should be paid differently on the basis of their sex. The argument is simply that it doesn't make any sense to look at two disparate figures and assume they differ primarily due to discrimination. The pushback so far has actually proven that this is sensible, as the more confounding variables are accounted for, the more the gap decreases. You'll notice that up until a few years ago, and sometimes to this day, pundits, professors, politicians, presidents and the public at large were completely comfortable stating that "women make 77 cents on a man's dollar." People were prepared to legislate for "equality" on the basis of this fact alone. But some people correctly stop and say, "Wait, but why? You're prepared to legislate, but you're just assuming that they're paid differently because of sexism you're attempting to correct." Well, it turns out that the 77 cents on a dollar was arrived at by literally just comparing what women at large make vs men at large. But do men and women do the same jobs? Do they even work in the same fields? Depending on profession, the answer is a resounding no. So then the question becomes "do women doctors at this hospital who see the same amount of patients and work the same amount of hours and have the same track record and went to the same school and have the same seniority etc etc make less than the respective men." The more that is controlled for, the more the gap disappears. What you are saying is that you can't believe sexist Americans stuck in the 1950s aren't prepared to legislate to remedy this issue, and that the pushback offered in this thread is evidence of people uninterested in gender equality. That's just not even close to the conversation that's being had, and I'm personally glad, whatever the topic, to have as much nuance brought forward as possible. Nobody is arguing against equality, it's just that you're mistaken in your assumption that this is what _you_ are arguing for. Also, regarding the UK, please note Carl Benjamin, Paul Joseph Watson, Nigel Farage, Helen Pluckrose, among others, if you insist on the assertion that pushback is limited to those outside your country.