2 ms·
I know it's cliche, what I'm about to do, but your comment is unhelpful enough to merit it. "The store owner agrees to adhere to the Jim Crow laws at the time
by SilasX 8y ago
I know it's cliche, what I'm about to do, but your comment is unhelpful enough to merit it.
"The store owner agrees to adhere to the Jim Crow laws at the time they sign their articles of incorporation, or their business licenses. If they want to serve black and white people in the same space, they're free to talk their political representatives about it, or operate in a different jurisdiction."
Repeating that the law is the law is not a productive contribution to a discussion about the merit of the laws.
- rchaud 8y agoInteresting that you chose to reference Jim Crow to contextualize a law explicitly designed to not restrict access to services because of the form of legal tender you carry. In a city where 26pct live in poverty and may not have access to banking services, such a law is about as no-brainer as it gets. Laws attempt to balance the interests of the individual with those of the community, and can be influenced by the participation of the community. Jim Crow lasted as long as it did because the people that it harmed never got a vote. For such a law to be unjust, you'll have to show some evidence of people being negatively affected by it. The only counterpoints offered by the article are concerns from Amazon, about a store that does not even exist in Philly yet.
- SilasX 8y agoDo you see the difference between the argument you just made and your original comment?
- rchaud 8y agoI don't. This is not some obscure by-law from decades ago that a businessperson wouldn't be reasonably expected to know. I imagine a businessperson would already know what their cash policy would be prior to applying for a business license. Businesses continue to have the right to refuse service to anyone. Just don't tell them it's because they brought cash. I don't recall Jim Crow laws having such loopholes. The upscale cashless places mentioned in the article already have most if not all of their customers using credit cards, so this law won't be losing them any customers. Although as the article says, their cashiers may have to learn how to add and subtract change every now and then.
- SilasX 8y agoReally? You honestly don't see the difference between "you had to agree to that law to operate your business" and "here is a reason that the law is a good idea"? Or the similarity between "you can just do sales online if you don't like the laws, therefore there is no problem here whatsoever" and "you can just operate in a different jurisdiction, therefore there is not problem here whatsoever"? Then ... I don't think there can be any real meeting of the minds on this :-/