4 ms·
Intel and ARM are just approaching the same points from different directions, that's all. We can equally say that you can't extrapolate and assume that your 45
by klodolph 8y ago
Intel and ARM are just approaching the same points from different directions, that's all.
We can equally say that you can't extrapolate and assume that your 45W x86, with lowered clock and voltage, will fit in the power budget of a mobile phone and still give good performance. But all these companies are throwing a lot of engineering effort at it and making solid progress. There's not some reason why x86, the architecture, should be faster than ARM. Intel has been enjoying a process advantage for many years now, and an enviable R&D budget, but that R&D budget is spent fighting against diminishing returns and in the meantime, competitors are catching up. As long as everyone can buy roughly the same node (a big "if", but looks like we're close enough), diminishing returns will bring everyone closer to parity.
But, benchmarks show this a bit better. Geekbench (I'm looking at Single Core):
https://browser.geekbench.com/mac-benchmarks https://browser.geekbench.com/mac-benchmarks
https://browser.geekbench.com/ios-benchmarks https://browser.geekbench.com/ios-benchmarks
iPad Pro 11-inch (iPad8,1) has the A12X at 2.5 GHz, score ~5000.
iMac 27-inch retina (iMac18,3) has the i7-7700K at 4.2 GHz, score ~5700.
This is not a cherry-picked comparison... this is just a comparison of whatever happens to be top of the line in both categories. Note that multi-core benchmarks will paint a slightly different picture, but that's very natural, since you can get a Mac with 18 core Xeons. Presumably, adding more cores to a mobile processor when you switch to desktop and can handle proportionally higher TDP, while not trivial, is not especially difficult either.
I assume that different benchmarks give different results as well. This is just one benchmark I know has results for both platforms.
- MR4D 8y agoYou make a great point. I remember when I got my 12.9" iPad Pro (gen 2), and the graphics were fast as hell - Waaaaaay faster than my poor Mac Mini could do. Based on that (and yes, both devices are now "old"), I'd trade my Mac Mini performance for the performance of my iPad without hesitation. Bring it, ARM !
- HeWhoLurksLate 8y agoI was going to post a text-heavy reply to you about that, but I decided not to. Essentially, my family got an iPad 4 and bluetooth keyboard case. A few years later, when Apple was prepping for their iPad Pro and positioning tablets as desktop replacements, I found that the work that I did was much easier on the iPad than it was on the Mac Mini (quad-core) that we had, including doing text editing and stuff of the sort. Personally, if someone put an ARM laptop in front of me with a workable, non-spyware OS, I would take it in a heartbeat.
- kllrnohj 8y agoJust going to nitpick a bit here and point out that Apple has never used ARM's graphics. They started with imgtec and then Apple took over at some point, using largely the same architecture though. Meanwhile your Mac Mini was using some form of Intel's integrated, which is notoriously trash tier. The very newest ones are OK sort of, but when push came to shove even Intel opted to ship AMD's Vega graphics in their own NUC instead.
- dethac 8y agoGeekbench is, IIRC, a pretty non-representative benchmark. Nowhere is this more clear than looking at Samsung Exynos Geekbench results vs. their real-world performance. It's okay for comparing iterations on an architecture (e.g. A11 vs A12, SD845 vs SD855), but it falls apart a bit otherwise.
- kllrnohj 8y ago> Presumably, adding more cores to a mobile processor when you switch to desktop and can handle proportionally higher TDP, while not trivial, is not especially difficult either. Multi-core scaling past a relatively low number is extremely difficult. AMD & Intel both have complex interconnect fabrics to handle this. You can see an example of this with Intel's shift from a ring bus to a router mesh design: https://www.anandtech.com/show/11550/the-intel-skylakex-review-core-i9-7900x-i7-7820x-and-i7-7800x-tested/5 https://www.anandtech.com/show/11550/the-intel-skylakex-revi... Or AMD's new chiplet design with Epyc 2 of the IO die + core dies connected via InfinityFabric. > iMac 27-inch retina (iMac18,3) has the i7-7700K at 4.2 GHz, score ~5700. Be careful with those clock speeds because the Intel Core i7-8700B @ 3.2 GHz shows a nearly identical score. And just below that supposedly the Intel Core i9-8950HK @ 2.9 GHz comes in just a bit lower at 5348 And the Intel Xeon W-2170B @ 2.5 GHz scored 5100. Higher than the A12X at the same clocks. That'd suggest Intel has an IPC advantage. Of course the reality here is that the clock listed on that page are complete nonsense. It's not the clocks the CPU was running at while running the benchmark, which is a hugely important data point to have here given the variety in boost frequencies at different thermal/power situations. The i7-7700k wasn't running at 4.2ghz, it was probably running at 4.5ghz. And the i7-8700B wasn't running at 3.2ghz, it was probably running at 4.6ghz. So depending on the actual clocks during the run the resulting scores may be more or less impressive. Similarly we don't know the actual power draw during those runs, which since we're talking about power efficiency here matters quite a bit.