4 ms·
I got ruined for regular coffee when I found a local shop that roasts its beans sorted by size. So it doesn't taste scorched. Apparently most commercial coffee
by JoeAltmaier 8y ago
I got ruined for regular coffee when I found a local shop that roasts its beans sorted by size. So it doesn't taste scorched. Apparently most commercial coffee makers roast them in arbitrary batches, which means by the time the big ones are roasted the small ones are burned.
I know there's a lot more that can be done with roasting. But that one small change means you can have strong coffee without having burned coffee. Its at the point I can walk past a coffee shop and say "Yuck they don't sort their beans" just by the smell.
- hvidgaard 8y agoGenerally the beans are roughly the same size, and what you called burned, I believe is simply because it's roasted darker to compensate for the less than ideal quality of the beans. The fact that WBC finalists are using coffee that the roaster haven't sorted based in size tells a lot. Perhaps the farmer does it to some degree.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoTry it before judging! Its definitely a burned taste, and once its gone you would not believe the difference.
- hvidgaard 8y agoI simply cannot explain why they wouldn't do it if it made a difference. A machine that sorts the beans by size is cheaper than the machine that package the coffee, so if it would make a better product, I'm sure the big roasters would do it. It's not like they cannot make great coffee. They can make coffee that's world class, but the market will not pay that much. But regardless, I have tried coffee that isn't burned. I primarily use lighter roasted beans, and there is zero burned taste.
- ABCLAW 8y ago>The fact that WBC finalists are using coffee that the roaster haven't sorted based in size tells a lot. Perhaps the farmer does it to some degree. I'm not sure if you've looked at espresso chemical papers (mostly the Illy ones), but they're pretty cool and they might explain this. The oil extraction curves are non-linear. Lighter roasts that aren't at risk of burning smaller beans can be paired with variable bean size to produce a spectrum of related flavour notes, providing a bit of depth to a varietal that has a very strong and pronounced (but limited) set of notes.
- hvidgaard 8y agoI haven't, but it sounds like something I'd enjoy. Thanks for the pointers.
- earthscienceman 8y agoIt's really funny to me to just how much junk information there is in the coffee world and just how strongly people believe it. Even here on hackernews it seems. This is the exact sort of 'fact' that sounds good, and makes you feel like you know what you're talking about. I'm a roaster. All coffee is sorted by size, or at least all quality coffee. It's necessary, not only for an even roast, but it's also an inherent part of green coffee processing. You have to screen and sort the beans to dry them. The reason grocery coffee is bad is simple. They roast it until the oils come out and then the oils go rancid because it has been sitting on the shelf for the last 6 months getting to you. Even if it hasn't gone rancid (way more common than you'd guess), it's still stale and overroasted. Americans expect coffee to be dark, bitter, and cheap... And so that's what they get. But what you said isn't true. Even the crappiest bulk market roaster/reseller roasts by size and the blends after. They literally don't have a choice. To be fair, a lot of the junk info comes from roasters keen on delineating themselves in any way in a saturated market. Taking words that are true for everyone and making them seem unique to your business is a sales tactic ad old as time. https://espressocoffeeguide.com/gourmet-coffee/arabian-and-african-coffees/kenya-coffee/kenya-coffee-grading/ https://espressocoffeeguide.com/gourmet-coffee/arabian-and-a...
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoWho's talking grocery stores? Coffee shops that roast, do it any way they want. And sure enough some do it badly.
- AdmiralAsshat 8y agoHello! Coffee enthusiast here. I'd like to follow-up on this statement: > They roast it until the oils come out and then the oils go rancid because it has been sitting on the shelf for the last 6 months getting to you. Are you saying that it's bad if my coffee beans are glistening with oil? I usually took that to be an indicator of freshness. Or do you mean that if they're no longer glistening that the bag is probably stale? FWIW, most of what I buy (except for the Costco bag that I take to work) has a roasting date on the back so that I can guarantee a certain degree of freshness.
- 8y ago
- cr1895 8y agoI wonder if that's more to do with the grade of beans than roaster-sorting. Edit: also, could this be related to inconsistent grind? Smaller bits over-extracted.
- clairity 8y ago> ..."you can have strong coffee without having burned coffee" just noting that when people say strong coffee, they usually mean "more caffeine", not "darker roast". and coffee people generally know that darker roasts have less caffeine. i actually like darker roast too, when i want a caramelly coffee (by adding cream and sugar). my theory is that not only does a dark roast better hide lower quality beans, but starbucks knows that most people put cream and sugar in their coffee and darker roasts are better for that, which is why it's so popular. but when i want straight brewed coffee, i seem to prefer a medium roast.
- fossuser 8y agoDarker roasts having less caffeine is another bit of folk wisdom that actually turns out not to be true. https://www.kickinghorsecoffee.com/en/blog/caffeine-myths-dark-vs-light https://www.kickinghorsecoffee.com/en/blog/caffeine-myths-da...
- clairity 8y agointeresting! the weight vs volume point is something that's not obvious on first blush.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoNot what I mean. More coffee flavor. Without tasted scorched.
- floatingatoll 8y agoYou may as well find value in looking up “density sorted” coffee, where they concentrate the high-density beans for roasting to max our flavor per cup.