3 ms·
Are you claiming that everyone out there that claims to be vegan is part of some all-encompassing singular movement? Who is the leader? Where is the movement's
by pyre 16y ago
Are you claiming that everyone out there that claims to be vegan is part of some all-encompassing singular movement? Who is the leader? Where is the movement's webpage?
- jerf 16y agoAre you claiming that nobody ever uses that argument? That rhetorical device cuts both ways, which is why it is useless in actual logic. I don't become paralyzed by the fact that I can't draw absolute boundaries around things, and I reject disingenuous invitations to be so paralyzed for your rhetorical benefit. Yes, this is clearly an argument made for veganism, by a significant proportion of vegan thought leaders. I reject the idea that people should be allowed to make arguments but as soon as they are challenged go hiding behind the claims that "well, not everyone thinks that way so you can't criticize it". That's just flat-out bullshit. The original argument was and is valid.
- pyre 16y ago> Your accusation of strawman doesn't hold. It is a valid point that > if you claim your movement is about health, but you ignore the > biggest health problem there is (because it does not fit the > ideology), the claims to health should be, if not entirely ignored, > certainly not taken at face value. It's perfectly logical. You seem to be arguing against the validity of vegetarianism/veganism as a whole based on the statements of a few vegetarians/vegans. You also seem to be under the impression that vegetarianism/veganism is some sort of singular 'movement' that has extreme solidarity and a singular purpose. None of this is the case though. People decide to become vegetarian/vegan for a variety of personal reasons ranging from health to animal welfare (aka 'animal rights') to religion. There are a number of movements that advocate a vegan diet (e.g. Peta) but that is a lot different than what you seem to want to imply. Your 'strawman' is the idea that vegetarianism/veganism is some sort of 'movement' where everyone believes the same thing and has the exact same goals. [ What are 'vegan thought leaders' anyways? ]