3 ms·
I am frequently asked about that. This is what I tell: ARM feels free to do a complete ISA revision from ground up once or twice a decade, x86 on other hand is
by baybal2 8y ago
I am frequently asked about that. This is what I tell: ARM feels free to do a complete ISA revision from ground up once or twice a decade, x86 on other hand is still bound to incremental improvement on a frail foundation laid in seventies. X86 only had three major revisions 16 bit to 32 bit and to 64 bit (the last one wasn't even done by Intel itself.)
x86 biggest weakness is its dependence on wintel that precludes them from the very needed major isa revisions.
If you look at atom dies, the overcomplicated decoder and other x86 vestiges take more area than the rest of the core.
A12x is remarkable in that it gets close to 15 watt Intel CPUs with LESS die area and lower power consumption. And if you remove the useless things like NPU, DRM stuff, security coprocessor, and other useless peripherals from calculation, the comparison will really begin to look dire for Intel.
Adding to that, even if we take into consideration that Intel is still on 14nm and A12x is a 7nm part, A12x still wins even if Intel will make a die shrink on 7nm. And you also have to consider that Intel has squeezed all and everything in terms of power efficiency from 14nm node after 5 years of active development on it, while Apple really went for the very first baseline revision of TSMC 7nm.
Moreover, what I hear from the scene here in Shenzhen is that in A12x Apple did not really put much into power saving: A12x has nothing comparable to Intel's complex runtime power management, power and clock gating, separate power domains, and on-package smart dc-dc converters. If Apple will commit itself to squeezing more power efficiency from their chips with equal zeal, I believe they add additional 25-35% to their power advantage.
- userbinator 8y agoIf you look at atom dies, the overcomplicated decoder and other x86 vestiges take more area than the rest of the core. The Atom is a bit of an edge-case since it has barely any cache (and the performance is exactly what you'd expect from that), yet it still takes up a significant amount of the die; in all other CPUs, the caches are far bigger.
- Symmetry 8y agoThe difficulty of decoding multiple x86 instructions in a single clock cycle is a small issue in the context of a big out-of-order core. But it's a millstone around Intel's neck when they try to make a simple superscalar in-order core like the Atom.