3 ms·
> So people who die in war don't benefit from the war... and? And therefore your claim that everyone here has benefited from it suffers from significant surviv
by AnimalMuppet 8y ago
> So people who die in war don't benefit from the war... and?
And therefore your claim that everyone here has benefited from it suffers from significant survivor bias.
> It can be entirely negative or partially positive, just like many other things.
Sure. But we've seen way too many examples of people selling how wonderful a war would be (and you're flirting dangerously close to that). War's not wonderful. It's horrible. Only fight it when the alternative is even more horrible (which is not never).
- scottLobster 8y agoStrange, because in this thread the closest thing to calling war "wonderful" I've seen is "Sometimes, as sad as it is to imagine, I think you need a good war to refresh a country..." Things that are wonderful aren't sad to imagine. Nor am I saying anything resembling calling a war "wonderful". I hear a lot of accusations and assumptions of intent with few real arguments other than "war bad". From where I sit the conversation appears to go like: Person 1: War bad. Person 2: War sometimes good in certain contexts... Person 1: NO! WAR ALWAYS BAD YOU FASCIST COWARD!!! Shockingly I remain unmoved.