5 ms·
>we all work more for the same thing No, we work more for more things. If you were to live according to the living standards of the times we associate with ste
by Barrin92 8y ago
>we all work more for the same thing
No, we work more for more things. If you were to live according to the living standards of the times we associate with stereotypical one income households, say 40 years ago, your house would be 1000 sq feet smaller, your electricity consumption would be much lower because you would have no smartphone, a small TV, your car would not have the features it has today, you would likely have no college education, and your healthcare expenditure would be lower because you would receive significantly less care. You also would sweat a lot in the summer, because back then air conditioning was a luxury rather than the rule.
You would also eat significantly less meat, and you would be much less likely to go on holidays, travel abroad, or eat fresh fruit from the other end of the world at all times during the year.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ip26 8y agoYour TV & other appliances all used a lot more electricity to get the same job done, even if the screen or icebox was smaller. Your car got worse fuel economy and didn't last to 100k miles. Your house used a lot more wood/gas/oil/electricity to heat. A big part of why we have more is social & technical progress. We get more for our money. I do think your parent's question is an interesting one- thorny, but it's not ridiculous to wonder if doubling the work force eventually gnaws away at compensation for the same work. (The natural next question is, well did the demand for labor grow to match, stay constant, or somewhere in between? Did the pie grow and we're all wealthier for it, or are twice as many people now fighting over the same pie?)
- Barrin92 8y agoThere seems to be an error in that argument. If you shrink your workforce holding productivity equal, then labour becomes more expensive and wages and prices are going to be pushed, i.e. you just get inflation. A larger labour force means more competition in wages, but it also increases supply so this shouldn't have any effect. If this wasn't true, then you could reduce inequality simply by artificially restricting the supply of labour, which I don't think has ever occurred.
- black-tea 8y ago> your house would be 1000 sq feet smaller You've got to be joking. My grandparents lived in much bigger houses with much more land than I could ever afford despite the fact that they were single earner manual labourers and I'm a highly qualified person with in STEM. In any case, they were at least as happy with their cars then as we are now, and they didn't want smartphones.
- Barrin92 8y agoI'm not joking. That is in fact literally the increase in average house size http://www.aei.org/publication/new-us-homes-today-are-1000-square-feet-larger-than-in-1973-and-living-space-per-person-has-nearly-doubled/ http://www.aei.org/publication/new-us-homes-today-are-1000-s... You happen to be an outlier if you're living in a smaller house than your grandparents. Given that you're saying you're a STEM worker and that your grandparents were manual labourers, my guess is that they owned cheaper property and you live in a very urban area. Which has very different perks.
- black-tea 8y agoWell, I live in the UK, not the US. It's very different for us.
- magduf 8y ago>your electricity consumption would be much lower because you would have no smartphone, a small TV, Smartphones use a ridiculously small amount of power compared to many of the appliances people had in those days. Modern TVs also use less power than old ones. No, electricity consumption would be lower because you wouldn't have air conditioning. That's the big power user in most peoples' homes.