4 ms·
>> Flying a helicopter requires such an intense mental load, he says, that even small things like pushing the “talk” button can put a novice pilot in peril. No
by sandworm101 8y ago
>> Flying a helicopter requires such an intense mental load, he says, that even small things like pushing the “talk” button can put a novice pilot in peril.
No they are not that hard to fly. A bare-bones helicopter with nothing more than the minimum parts to qualify as a helicopter is indeed an unsteady beast. But such helicopters are rare, used mostly for training purposes. Modern machines, even ancient ones, have things like gyroscopes to take much of the load off the pilot. And autopilots really do work (auto, not autonomous). They can hold a steady heading/alt. Feed them data from a radar altimeter and they can hover like a rock.
The computers can fly the aircraft, they can literally make it move as needed, but that is a totally different problem than deciding where to move the aircraft. The pilot's job is making the judgement calls necessary to keep the aircraft safe. Show me a computer than can determine whether an approach is safe enough to execute, whether the weather en route is acceptable. Show me a computer than an judge which path to take to avoid carrying an unsteady slung load over someone's head.
- hirundo 8y ago> Feed them data from a radar altimeter and they can hover like a rock. That's not good, right?
- sandworm101 8y agoWell, "rock" as in solid-as-as. Watch any of the new rescue helos hovering over a ship. There are legends in AF helo communities about entire crews falling asleep during long hovers. (The anti-submarine helicopters have to hover in place while dipping their sonar into the water.)
- aidenn0 8y agoYeah, that immediately made me think of Hitchikers: > The ships hung in the sky in much the same way that bricks don't.
- tome 8y agoThis is really interesting and surprising to me. Can any helicopter pilot explain why hovering is not as easy as just taking your hands off the controls? That's how I always imagined a helicopter would work!
- starpilot 8y agoIt's like standing on a basketball, any perturbation in the wrong direction causes it to accelerate in that direction. The whole thing is vibrating in multiple planes, so it requires constant control inputs to keep it from veering off.
- yutyut 8y agoIdeally you can trim a modern helicopter out much like you would an airplane however it's still a dynamically (?) unstable platform. I'm far removed from aero and nobody really thinks about the details of that stuff when they're flying. Here's a good summary: https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/35764/are-helicopters-aerodynamically-stable https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/35764/are-helic...
- sandworm101 8y agoA hover isn't as dynamic as forward flight. A fixed-wing aircraft like a glider can self-regulate using aerodynamic forces. For instance: If the nose tips up, the plane slows. The wings generate less lift and the nose tips back down. Plane then speeds up ... etc. But a hovering helicopter doesn't experience any significant airflow changes. If it's nose tips up it just keeps tipping up. The helo then starts sliding backwards until the tail catches the wind, spinning everything 180 like a weather vain and very quickly you aren't flying any more. The pilot/computer/gyro needs to keep ahead of these forces.
- yutyut 8y agoI'm pretty sure everything in your last paragraph could be done with enough good input (sensors, approach mins, DTED, Digital Wx updates, etc) and the correct application of 1's and 0's. Not really that hard of a problem to solve unless you're operating somewhere very data-austere. To your first point-and I think you hit it but I wanted to emphasize-some helicopters are hard to fly, some mission sets are more difficult than others; hovering with a 30 knot tailwind in a $32 million dollar aircraft with SCAS and AFCS is still a pain in the ass especially when it's low light and you're on goggles...but I guess the AI wouldn't need to be aided, so call that a win.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> ... everything in your last paragraph could be done with enough good input Lol. Helicopters are not 747s. They operate very locally and do things that are not as generic as approaching SFO in marginal weather. A helicopter has to change its operations in reaction not to measured weather, but to the specifics of individual trees. Show me a computer that can take the input: "That tree looks like it is about to fall over" and decide whether to continue a rescue or give up and negotiate a new approach. SAR pilots do that daily.
- yutyut 8y agoSee above, RE: “sensors”
- yutyut 8y agoSorry just being short on a comment that starts with lol. Look at for instance SAR mapping. I can have a “certain curr gen aircraft” SAR map a zone or AO for me and tell me A LOT (UNCLAS/open source).
- sandworm101 8y agoSAR = search and rescue. It is pulling wounded people off cliffs or burning boats.
- pps43 8y ago> No they are not that hard to fly. I suspect you have not tried hovering in a helicopter. > autopilots really do work There are actually very few autopilots that can hover. Not just because it's technically hard (the soviet Kamov helicopters could maintain hover back in 1980's), but also because of the certification requirements. If a DJI drone hits a tree it's not a big deal. The story is very different when a helicopter does it.