6 ms·
This kind of bullshit is why I’m solidly in the “fuck Tesla” camp. The battles over auto repair and nonsense “safety” excuses were fought 100 years ago and shou
by Spooky23 8y ago
This kind of bullshit is why I’m solidly in the “fuck Tesla” camp. The battles over auto repair and nonsense “safety” excuses were fought 100 years ago and shouldn’t need to be fought again, only in this dysfunctional era of American government is it possible for Tesla to even exist.
Like any big company, they demonstrate every day why it’s so important to have independent service. As a company, they are too incompetent to run retail outlets, unable to supply spare parts for cars that are mostly unchanged year to to year, and unable to actually repair cars in the handful of service centers that exist.
Hopefully the successor company that buys them out doesn’t go down this path.
- linuxftw 8y agoWorse yet, their latest announcement regarding shuttering retail stores also indicates that their solution to their service problem is to deploy a fleet of 'come to you' trucks. EG, they're going to want to dispatch and repair/replace components in your driveway or on the street, which is prohibited in many places.
- martin_a 8y agoI would expect that this is mostly limited to software-related problems or really small stuff (wipers and window washing fluid) and for everything else they will just tow your car away.
- linuxftw 8y agoTow it to where, precisely? Additionally, are you going to get a free loaner that pretty much every other major brand gives you for warranty work? If you break down on the side of the highway, what then? Where does the car get towed?
- martin_a 8y agoI don't know and frankly I'm not sure that Tesla does either yet. But what are they going to do? Carry around whole drivetrains in their "Service Car Model X" that comes to your house? Even if so, you need specialized equipment, hydraulic lifts etc. to repair things like that. So what will their options be if they do not have their own (service) shops anymore except than picking up your car, bringing it to _whereever_ and fixing it there? I don't see any and I think this can and will probably fire back on them.
- linuxftw 8y agoExactly, I agree. It's going to be a boondoggle.
- martin_a 8y ago> boondoggle Learned a new word today. Thanks. :-D
- northwest65 8y agoI hope that hornswoggle makes your day even better :)
- martin_a 8y agoAmazing! :-D
- zaroth 8y agoYou just assume Tesla has no way to provide service to hundreds of thousands of cars they have on the road? This is just FUD... They are not closing their service centers. They are closing the showrooms. They are totally separate locations. The showrooms are usually located in malls.
- linuxftw 8y agoWhere's the proof the have the capacity to service 100's of thousands of cars? Do they have a service center in every state? Every major metro area? Currently, they don't have a facility in every state. I think people are right to be skeptical, buying an automobile is a major financial decision for most folks, and warranty/repair is a very important part of that story.
- zaroth 8y agoThere are service centers completely separate from the retail locations. They have never done service at their showrooms. They absolutely have ways to book appointments at their service centers and provide loaner cars.
- martin_a 8y ago> They absolutely have ways to book appointments at their service centers and provide loaner cars. I can barely put 100k € in cash on the table and leave their place with a car and you tell me they have loaners like nothing standing around? And for the whole of Germany there are 10 service centers listed on their website. That will be a long trip for a repair.
- thebluehawk 8y agoThis is incorrect. They are closing retail stores, but those are usually not the same as the service centers, even if they share a building. An analogy would be a dealership shuttering their sales department but keeping the service department.
- decebalus1 8y agoI think it's more than repairs. The model to which this is converging is the abandonment of ownership. You do want to get YOUR car repaired but if it's not your car in the first place, you can't. I think the narrative is slowly building towards that. You're licensed to drive the car, you bought the license, not the car. It doesn't matter if you are in physical possession of the metal parts as long as the software running them is updated automatically and you're not allowed to repair them. https://www.teslarati.com/do-you-own-a-tesla-or-does-a-tesla-own-you/ https://www.teslarati.com/do-you-own-a-tesla-or-does-a-tesla... John Deere managed to do this https://www.wired.com/2015/04/dmca-ownership-john-deere/ https://www.wired.com/2015/04/dmca-ownership-john-deere/ so it's all the history repeating. And I agree with you, the dysfunctional anticonsumer regulatory environment enabled this.
- rchaud 8y agoThis recently happened to a Kobo e-reader I bought in 2013 and have been using happily. On March 1, the company announced some firmware upgrade that I was required to install to continue even using the device. This was not a security patch and wasn't related to the ereader's core functionality. We're talking about a $50 ereader that only connects to my laptop once in a blue moon to transfer EPUB files. Can't use it anymore without installing a firmware upgrade now. Turns out, I have a license to use the device, just not to own it.
- cheeko1234 8y agoHow did they stop you from using the device? Does it connect to the internet? This seems like they preplanned this "feature". Slightly offtopic, but I recently bought a kindle paperwhite and jailbroke it. The process was a bit challenging but definitely worth it and makes it impossible for Amazon to mess with it.
- Gibbon1 8y agoMy opinion is a company that does that should be if you so desire, required to buy the device back from you at retail and pay for shipping.
- 8y ago
- the_gastropod 8y agoI'm inclined to agree with you. But I do think Teslas are different from cars of yesteryear in a few important ways: 1. They have massive 375 volt batteries that could absolutely kill you if you're a little bit careless. 2. They have that "autopilot" mode. And that feature receives OTA updates from Tesla. I could see improper service causing problems with autopilot that would put other people (drivers and pedestrians) at risk. Maybe a solution is to separate some of the software features of a car (like autopilot) from the mechanical aspects. If you repair your car yourself, maybe losing out on autopilot and the like is a fair deal.
- jhallenworld 8y agoSo on the 375V battery: the car already should be designed so that Tesla mechanics can work on it. It already needs to be safe to work on, or their own employees are going to sue them. Anyway, so at the very least connectors and modules with high voltage have to be designed so that the high voltage is not exposed. On autopilot mode: if it doesn't have a self test of the sensors it depends on, there is a big problem already. Actually conventional cars have electric power steering which you could argue has similar risks. There are more dangerous consumer goods. For example, microwave ovens have 3000 V power supplies at significant current: this is the voltage level used for executions. One mistake and you're dead.
- linuxftw 8y ago> 1. They have massive 375 volt batteries that could absolutely kill you if you're a little bit careless. Homes have electricity. It can easily kill you if you're careless. > 2. They have that "autopilot" mode. And that feature receives OTA updates from Tesla. I could see improper service causing problems with autopilot that would put other people (drivers and pedestrians) at risk. Then the autopilot system is inadequate. Not tightening your lug nuts could cause your tire to come off at highway speeds. What's you're point?
- grecy 8y ago> Homes have electricity. It can easily kill you if you're careless Unless you're playing on the input side of the meter-box, it's extremely unlikely you'll be killed in any kind of modern building with a mandated-by-law earth leakage device.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]