3 ms·
It is challenging to construct a realistic long-run scenario of a happy future that is sophisticated and meaningful. It's simple enough: Pick a reference p
by michaelt 8y ago
It is challenging to construct a realistic long-run
scenario of a happy future that is sophisticated and
meaningful.
It's simple enough: Pick a reference point in the past that makes most things look pretty good, and extrapolate from there.
Compared to the 1800s, everything seems to be going in the right direction. Medical technology? Much better! Childhood mortality? Lower than ever! Science? Much more advanced - and much better funded! Democracy? Many fewer limits on who can vote or serve in government! Women's rights? LGBT rights? Much improved! War? Fewer and smaller wars than ever! Long distance communication? Faster and cheaper than ever! Average education levels? Higher than ever! Prices of books? Lower than they've ever been. Availability of food? We literally have an obesity epidemic! Quality of food? More people have access to salt and spices than ever! The average westerner today eats better than a king would have in 1800! Access to education? More university lectures than you could ever watch, on a screen in your pocket.
Then just gloss over any negative changes as temporary blips, and you've got a pretty positive outlook!
- roenxi 8y agoThat type of extrapolation form the past is extremely simplistic though. And a bit like saying that you feel pretty good at 50 years old so it'll be easy to make it to 100. Everything winds down and dies eventually; we should resist entropy as best we can but realistically one day humanity is going to fall over and not get back up. The question is how long until then, and the order of magnitude number of years probably doesn't have 5 zeros on the end. And anyone who extrapolated 2019 from 1800 was correct but also undeniably delusional; there was no evidence it would turn out as it has, and the journey was largely uncontrolled. Anything could have happened.