3 ms·
An economy of scale has value measured in trillions. A trillion is 1000 billion. If I succeed in stealing 0.01% of something in trillions, I have x times 100 mi
by ggm 8y ago
An economy of scale has value measured in trillions. A trillion is 1000 billion. If I succeed in stealing 0.01% of something in trillions, I have x times 100 millions.
I think we can assume that inside this economy, theft significantly north of 0.01% is taking place. For reference my partner ran a small independent bookshop and she worked on 1% theft of stock as a rough model. For "theft" read "oh I dropped it in a puddle, the book is now filthy and unsellable, I shall keep it and use it for .. nevermind"
Tax compliance in Greece was figured at below 50%. Tax -avoidance- [edit: wrong. evasion] (not tax minimisation) is theft from the state. If a modern western economy inside the EU has less than 50% compliance on tax, what do you think the post SU states have?
What is the value of an illegally exported tank? Barrel of oil? A Tonne of industrial diamonds? Cobalt? If you lived in an economy which was so physically large most of its visible ocean borders were probably un visited 99% of the time, and you had a megatonne of industrial diamonds.. what would you do?
- robocat 8y ago> Tax avoidance (not tax minimisation) is theft from the state. Tax avoidance is OK. It's tax evasion that's illegal. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_avoidance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_avoidance
- ggm 8y agoSigh. Sorry. fixed. Wish we had -markdown- for corrections.
- vkou 8y agoWas tax compliance in Greece below 50% across the board, or was it below 50% for <particular segments of the population>? How incompliant were those 50%? I can believe that 50% of, say independent handymen contractors may have been swindling the government of some part of their taxes. I have a much harder time to believe that 50% of the entire population was. (Especially given that ~50% of the population - children, pensioners, and the unemployed, aren't even supposed to pay much in the way of taxes.)
- ggm 8y agoI think I indulged in hyperbole but the wiki links on systemic corruption in Greece are still pretty scary. Almost 50% of companies investigated by tax authorities in Greece were found to have falsified returns in 2005. It has a large cash economy,a higher than normal avoidance of VAT (an EU wide sales tax designed to replace a lot of other fees and chargs in an open market) and historically low tax compliance. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_Greece https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_Greece
- vkou 8y agoIt seems that, if the shadow economy metrics in that article are correct (20% of Greek commerce happened off the books, compared to 10% of German commerce), then the tax fraud, while prevalent, may not have been as extensive in scope. 20% of your economy operating untaxed is a big problem - but is not an order of magnitude off from 10% (Which seems to be the baseline for a highly tax-compliant nation.) Either way, it's a far cry from what one might assume from an uncritical reading of a "Half of Greece isn't paying taxes" headline.