3 ms·
Having been through chronic suicidal depression, the idea that we're now going to be treating it with yet another psychoactive medication, this time way more po
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago
Having been through chronic suicidal depression, the idea that we're now going to be treating it with yet another psychoactive medication, this time way more powerful and costing significantly more money, doesn't sit right.
- loeg 8y agoIt's just one more option on the market; theoretically supported as safe and effective by scientific evidence. If you have some personal grudge with the chemical, you're free to tell your doctor you don't want to try it.
- RyanUnited 8y agoYup, "science" gave us pharmaceutical Heroin, MDMA, Xanax, Fentanyl, Valium, Vicodin, Methamphetamine, Rohypnol (date rape drug), ketamine (also rapey), phencyclidine (PCP); just to name a few of the many "scientific" ways of addressing depression, anxiety, lethargy and pain. But, as long as we can tell our doctor's we don't want it...
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoIt is my experience that if you tell a doctor they can't just throw a drug at a problem they get very upset.
- RankingMember 8y agoIf you said it that way with a hostile inflection, maybe, but why wouldn't you just say "I want to try [therapy/a non-drug alternative] first."? If your doctor would react negatively to that, it might be time to find a new doctor.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoHere's the thing, the doctor is supposedly the expert, so why am I the one recommending a course of treatment? If I were confident in my own diagnosis and treatment, why do I need the doctor? They're just useless red tape at that point. I explain the reasons I don't want to do the drugs again, and I just get arguments. Because this is the US we're talking about, I've had to change doctors pretty frequently in my life and there are only a small handful I would say wouldn't react negatively. I'm pretty sure the proliferation of Epic has made it worse too.
- RankingMember 8y agoIf it's your GP, they're really not the expert though when it comes to psychological issues. If you're expecting your GP to do more for that than offer medication or a specialist, you're probably asking too much.
- cocochanel 8y agoWhat other types of treatment do you find more suitable for depression?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoI honestly don't know. I found my way out through a path that may or may not work for others. I have a pet theory of how and why depression works, and what can be done about it, but I'm not deluded enough to believe I must be right just because I seem to be from my own perspective. However, years of experience have led me to believe that throwing drugs at this problem does nothing but mask some of the symptoms temporarily, while often having somewhat undesirable side effects. I think we just keep doing it because depression is not well understood, doctors (like the rest of us) are lazy and incentivized to get you out of their office as quickly as possible, and phrama is big business.
- cwkoss 8y agoFrom what I've read, one of the most exciting properties of ketamine treatment of depression is it's rapid onset. Ketamine seems to become effective in hours and retain benefit for days. If there is a negative reaction, stopping can similarly rapidly cease effect. Conversely, SSRIs or Tricyclics can take weeks to begin taking effect, and if a negative reaction occurs, it can similarly take weeks for effects to extinguish after ceasing dosage.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoBut is that really an effective long term solution? Ketamine is addictive after all, you can't keep doing that every few days.
- cwkoss 8y agoSSRI withdrawal symptoms can be pretty rough, seems chronic high-dose ketamine withdrawal is also quite bad. However, ketamine therapeutic dose is ~ 1/4th low recreational dose, so I think withdrawal is likely to be minimal with this dosage regime. Certainly something to be concerned about. I've read ketamine abusers can often end up with kidney issues (presumably proportional to dosage as its related to elimination), but I'd also think monitoring kidney health with chronic dosing, even at low levels, could be prudent - especially in individuals with pre-existing kidney issues.
- samcodes 8y agoHaving been through the same, I'm of the opposite opinion. We're just computers made of meat. Some of us weren't optimized to function in society. Any help that works, chemical or not, is welcome.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoI'm not convinced it works, other than in the short term. That's my problem with it. It feels too much like we're just throwing a drug at the symptoms because that's the lazy way to get you out of the doctor's office and of course pharma inc. prefers those solutions.
- RankingMember 8y agoI'd rather have more potential treatments than less. Different people will respond to different things.
- johnisgood 8y ago> costing significantly more money It does not have to be the case. In some European countries it is ridiculously cheap, as cheap as any other basic/necessary medications, medications that are super expensive to the Americans.