4 ms·
For people downvoting this, consider that it can (and should IMHO) be possible for citilife to live in a system where this is the case, and for you to live in a
by freedomben 8y ago
For people downvoting this, consider that it can (and should IMHO) be possible for citilife to live in a system where this is the case, and for you to live in a system that meets your needs as well. I don't understand why so many people are convinced that a giant state imposing one-size-fits-all on a hugely diverse population is a good idea. The United States particularly was founded on the idea of a tiny federal government where most things were decided by States, so people could freely move to the government that best fit their needs.
Some further reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntaryism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntaryism
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panarchy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panarchy
- anoncake 8y agoIf it's possible to live in a system where the rich aren't properly taxed, the rich will choose to live in that system. Thus no one can live in a system that does tax them fairly, because the system that tries to does not have any rich people to tax.
- arcticbull 8y agoI respectfully disagree. People aren't simply motivated by taxes -- there's other things like friendship, society, sense of purpose, opportunities, their place of business and the country they live in as a whole. Further, perceived value of money operates on a logarithmic scale so for someone with $2M in income $1M is a lot of money to take, but for someone with $100M $1M just isn't. I don't think you've factored in a whole lot of aspects. For instance, the top tax rate in Denmark is 62.5% and yet they have wealthy people -- why aren't they all in Hong Kong or Singapore or Malta or Gibraltar? The hyperbolic example is "the only place that won't tax me is this deserted island, so peace boys, it's just me and my money over here." Feels a bit unlikely doesn't it? There are places with truly nominal taxes already (Saudi Arabia for one), so why aren't all our rich people ... there in one big pile already?
- anoncake 8y agoYou're right, I simplified way too much. Of course taxes are not the only factor in play. Indeed, I hope that I overestimated their inpact. Also I didn't expect the top taxes in Denmark to be that high.
- mcphage 8y ago> the system that tries to does not have any rich people to tax Ah, I've always wondered why there aren't any rich people in New York or California. I guess this explains it.
- rosser 8y agoAnd Xeno's arrow never hits its target, either... This is a purely a priori argument, and ignores the manifest reality of the distribution of fantastically wealthy individuals in some of the highest-tax jurisdictions in the world.
- citilife 8y ago> For people downvoting this, consider that it can (and should IMHO) be possible for citilife to live in a system where this is the case, and for you to live in a system that meets your needs as well. I don't understand why so many people are convinced that a giant state imposing one-size-fits-all on a hugely diverse population is a good idea. The United States particularly was founded on the idea of a tiny federal government where most things were decided by States, so people could freely move to the government that best fit their needs. I totally agree with this BTW. That's in part why I made my comment in the first place. I don't want to see massive taxes federally and I actually left California because of the crazy laws / taxes.
- dfilppi 8y agoThese polling questions don't typically distinguish between federal and state governments. They ask whether some policy is approved of (usually with the implicit understanding that it will be free to the voter). The author's proposition that if 2/3 of the voters want something, they should get it is the road to chaos, because "it" is never precisely defined, and the concrete consequences are never made clear. Democracy is good for picking representatives, and not great at that but better than a monarchy.
- eropple 8y ago"Fifty states, fifty laboratories" falls over when the foolish ones come with their hand out. See Kansas and their Sam Brownback disaster. This is, ultimately, why I expect that most federal systems beyond a certain scale will fail: because the federated, without counterbalancing factors like "national unity" or "the barest sense of shame," will use, and then abuse, the federal safety net at the expense of everybody else. (See yesterday's arguments of "well, why should SALT be deductible?"--where states more impacted by SALT deductible reductions generally pay in more despite their increased state and local taxes.) At that point, I expect that the collapse of the federated will necessitate federal and state conglomeration. I don't have a good idea on what timeline we will collectively realize this, though.
- freedomben 8y agoI agree with you, but I'd say that's more a defect in the US Constitution that permits one state to plunder another. If the federal government were not allowed to redistribute wealth from California to Kansas (or vice-versa depending on your politics) then the issue would be moot because foolish people with their hands out would be there all day with no power to act on it. Actually, are you saying that doing away with the federal system altogether is the only sane approach (or letting it fail and not re-instantiating it)? If so, I think I agree
- eropple 8y agoI don't know about "only sane", but I expect it to happen. Conglomeration is probably inevitable, in fact if not name, with the federal government assuming more and more of those roles just because of the economies of scale.
- pdonis 8y ago> I don't understand why so many people are convinced that a giant state imposing one-size-fits-all on a hugely diverse population is a good idea. The people who are convinced of this are the people who stand to benefit from it. People who rely on benefits that require a large population to support them (for example, Social Security and Medicare) will want to have a large population supporting them. But that means one-size-fits-all has to be imposed on that large population. If people could choose whether or not to contribute to those benefit programs, many would choose not to, which would decrease the available benefits.
- mcphage 8y ago> so people could freely move to the government that best fit their needs. That requires a certain level of callousness. If New York State got universal health care (for instance), I'd be happy—but I would still push for it to be supported at a national level, so that people in other states could benefit.
- freedomben 8y agoI think your heart is in the right place, but this is the same mentality that has the US trying to "export democracy" all over the world, and it's causing tremendous damage and suffering. I think we need to accept that we Americans don't know what's better for everybody else. Different culture, different values. Why not instead work toward universal health care in New York, and then invite people to move there? Then you get to help people, but you aren't being tyrannical against the people that don't want universal healthcare.
- mcphage 8y ago> Why not instead work toward universal health care in New York, and then invite people to move there? Like I said, that requires a certain level of callousness.
- freedomben 8y agoWould you support having New York State work toward forcing all other states and countries to adopt universal healthcare that meets your standards? If so, then I think you're being consistent but I would also suggest that you look into the history of colonialism and how many of the residents of the countries under rule felt about it (Gandhi did a lot of writing on this for example). If not, how do you avoid being labeled "callous" using your own standard? Do you not care about the people in other countries as well?
- mcphage 8y ago> If so, then I think you're being consistent but I would also suggest that you look into the history of colonialism and how many of the residents of the countries under rule felt about it (Gandhi did a lot of writing on this for example). Colonialism and health care aren't the same thing, though—colonialism was an attempt to exploit other people for your own profit, the point of spreading universal health care would be to let people have better medical treatment at more affordable prices. There is actually a difference between good things and bad things. > If not, how do you avoid being labeled "callous" using your own standard? Do you not care about the people in other countries as well? Well, the simplest metric would be this: that there's no political body that someone in another country and I both belong to.