9 ms·
Enforcing one's trademark does not constitute "discrimination". Facebook is in the right here. Lamebook is clearly an attempt to cash in on the Facebook name,
by jerf 16y ago
Enforcing one's trademark does not constitute "discrimination".
Facebook is in the right here. Lamebook is clearly an attempt to cash in on the Facebook name, trademark law does not permit that, trademark law is correct here. Merely being "the little guy" doesn't make you right or give you carte blanche to ignore whatever laws you want.
- scotus69 16y ago...and you are a lawyer and this is your professional opinion?
- ugh 16y agoYou could make the case that it’s a free speech issue. (Which has obviously nothing to do with whether Facebook is a monopoly or not.)
- generalk 16y agoIf you're making reference to the Freedom of Speech guaranteed by the US Bill of Rights, you absolutely can't. Facebook isn't the government, the First Amendment doesn't apply to them.
- ugh 16y agoI’m very skeptical about that claim. It’s of course true that the first amendment and basic rights in general (usually?) only apply to the government. I know too little about US law to say with certainty whether there are exceptions in the USA. (I know with certainty that in certain, very limited circumstances some basic rights apply even between private entities in Germany.) The submitted article, however, quotes a law professor who explicitly portrays this as a first amendment issue which doesn’t support your hypothesis that the first amendment only applies to the government in this case. I’m relatively certain that Facebook is free to block Lamebook on their own site all they want. Freedom of speech doesn’t come into play. I’m not so sure about that when it comes to the trademark.
- generalk 16y agoWould the Fair Use doctrine apply here, or does that not apply to trademarks?
- CPops 16y agoParody and commenting about something and humor and so forth is protected as fair use even under our horrendously fucked up "intellectual property" system. Now, I think Facebook has the right to block whatever links they want to block on their own website. It's their website and they should do what they want that they feel is in their own self-interest. Casting this as Lamebook doing something that violates Facebook's trademark is incorrect without any actual evidence that they are indeed violating Facebook's trademark. Merely having a name that rhymes with Facebook isn't enough to call that a violation of Facebook's trademark.
- jerf 16y agoYou cited defenses against copyright infringement. There is no parody exemption that I have ever heard of that applies to the active use of a trademark. You can certainly create yourself a "Lamebook" to use in, say, a web comic, and make it even look exactly like the actual Lamebook page, and nobody would blink, just like nobody blinks at a Sorny in a web comic. But you're not allowed to actually do business as Sorny! I have evidence that Lamebook is violating Facebook's trademark. There's the name. There's the fact that their logo is clearly a Facebook hand, only reversed. There's the fact they're in the same basic industry and a realistic chance that Lamebook could be reasonably confused to be connected to Facebook by a normal person. I'm not sure what other evidence you're expecting, a signed affidavit from John Roberts?
- _delirium 16y agoThere's some recognition of a parody defense in U.S. trademark law, though it isn't that clear, and I don't think there are any definitive Supreme Court cases on it. There are a number of law-review articles trying to make sense of the subject, though: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&sciodt=2000&q=%22trademark+parody%22 http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&sciodt=2000&...
- noglorp 16y ago>There's the fact they're in the same basic industry and a realistic chance that Lamebook could be reasonably confused to be connected to Facebook by a normal person. The basic industry is the web? That is a stretch. Does that mean anything else is in the basic industry of "physical things"? Facebook is in the industry of social networking, while Lamebook is a 'lolpics' site targeted at funny things FROM Facebook. It seems like they are clearly doing what Facebook says they are (attempting to piggyback on brand recognition), using satire as a hook to get away with it. Whether they will succeed I think depends on Facebook's ability to show that this use will harm their name / confuse their customers, and that seems doubtful. In a similar instance, Toys `R' Us successfully forced Guns `R' Us to change names; the case was made that parents would think that Toys `R' Us had a chain of gun stores!