4 ms·
The study [1] didn't "show" what you say. It claimed there was a bias towards female applicants. To support this claim the study pointed out that the percentag
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
The study [1] didn't "show" what you say. It claimed there was a bias towards female
applicants.
To support this claim the study pointed out that the percentage of male
applicants _out of all male_ applicants that were granted admission was lower
than the percentage for female applicants, for all (examined) departments.
However, according to the study, there were 8442 male applicants and 4321
female applicants. So while a larger proportion of female applicants were
granted admission, it still meant that many fewer women were addmitted.
To clarify, a higher proportion of a smaller number can still be a smaller
number. 5% of 1000 is 50, 10% of 100 is 10.
Imagine we split a pie in 10 pieces, you keep 8 and I keep 2. I eat my 2, you
eat 4 of your 8 and then you accuse me of hogging the pie because I ate 100%
of my share while you ate only half of yours.
That is what the study actually showed happenned with admissions in Berkeley.
_________________________
[1] Sex Bias in Graduate Admissions: Data from Berkeley
https://homepage.stat.uiowa.edu/~mbognar/1030/Bickel-Berkeley.pdf https://homepage.stat.uiowa.edu/~mbognar/1030/Bickel-Berkele...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 8y ago> the study pointed out that the percentage of male applicants _out of all male_ applicants that were granted admission was lower than the percentage for female applicants, for all (examined) departments. Where does the study say that? I find it saying that 44 percent of male applicants and 35 percent of female applicants were admitted, when totaled over all 101 departments.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoIt's on section "Pooling", on page 7 of the pdf (400 in the original), second column, last parargraph starting with "We reanalyze Table 1, ...". In that paragraph, the authors state that they estimate the probability of admission of a female applicant "by multiplying the estimated probability of admission of any applicant (regardless of sex) to that department by the number of women applying to it", which I find reasonable. However, immediately afterwards they compare that probability with the probability of an applicant being admitted given that the applicant is female. I quote from the end of the second column and the start of the third one: "Thus, if the chances of getting into a department were one-half for all applicants to it, and 100 women applied, we would expect 50 women to be admitted if they were being treated just like the men". In other words, bias depends on whether the proportion of applicants of one sex, out of all applicants of _that_ sex, was higher than the expectation formed for applicants of any sex. It's a little confusing and the language in the article is not very precise. But that's what's up.
- pdonis 8y ago> It's on section "Pooling", on page 7 of the pdf Ah, I see; I was misunderstanding which part of the study you were referring to.