5 ms·
Do you have an example of a lasting empire that... did not do all of that stuff? I mean, honestly that statement seems kind of laughably wrong.
by ajross 8y ago
Do you have an example of a lasting empire that... did not do all of that stuff? I mean, honestly that statement seems kind of laughably wrong.
- raverbashing 8y agoCompare the evolution of the big empires of the past with the evolution in the last 500 years or even the last 250 years. The Roman Empire had a water system and concrete to make the Coliseum. Relied on slave labour up until the end. Made a plant that was used as contraception extinct. Given the time they stood, I'd say their scientific/mathematical progress was nimble. Egyptian empire: invented geometry, still had slaves pushing stones up to form pyramids. The Portuguese and the Spanish conquered half the world, but still relied on manual labour and got behind when the English started using machine labour.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoHave you ever seen Connections[0]? Do watch it if you haven't[1]. They communicate well what's IMO a crucial point: almost never a single person had invented the "whole solution". The story of civilization is one of individual inventions being made over time, and then coming together to click into place and create something pushing us forward even further. It did happen in the past like it is happening today; both then and now it seems to work better under a stable governance - hence big empires do in fact contribute to scientific progress by their very existence. It's happening faster today than it was then because we're further along the exponential curve - but it's the same curve, the same process, we've been following for thousands of years. Like it often is with wealth, we're not special - our current empires just had richer parents and bigger accumulated base of inventions. We can build cooler stuff now than our ancestors - but let's never forget that "what makes one step a giant leap is all the steps before"[2]. -- [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(TV_series)#Connections_(1978) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(TV_series)#Connec... [1] - I think I've seen them on dailymotion; of course I don't encourage copyright infringement, it's very important to keep our most important works unaccessible until everyone who might be interested in them dies off and only archaeologists will care. [2] - http://www.ovff.org/pegasus/songs/toast-for-unknown-heroes.html http://www.ovff.org/pegasus/songs/toast-for-unknown-heroes.h... / https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6zotaRLROtw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6zotaRLROtw
- raverbashing 8y agoOh I loved Connections > Like it often is with wealth, we're not special - our current empires just had richer parents and bigger accumulated base of inventions. We can build cooler stuff now than our ancestors Yes, totally agree. But what I'm saying is that those old empires didn't have technological evolution as a goal (maybe the latter ones) hence they didn't really think of it. Sure, evolution and ideas take time, but it seems it took much less time once the right mindset was in place.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Sure, evolution and ideas take time, but it seems it took much less time once the right mindset was in place. Right. But come to think of it, that mindset is, too, a technology. It took a while to develop, and its evolution seems to be intertwined with the inventions humans made over time, and the shape societies took.
- dredmorbius 8y agomindset is, too, a technology Hrm... Would you consider that independent of technical or causal (scientific) knowledge? Is it values, or more than just that?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI don't think it's just values. Knowledge and technology plays into this too. I don't have a fully fleshed out model in my head just yet, but I imagine it like this: humans seem to have a pretty fixed emotional and cognitive makeup. What changes is the landscape in which we operate - what technologies are available, what customs exist in our times, what are the core "cultural memes". Kind of like water flowing downhill - a simple process in itself, but where it goes and what shape it takes depends on the landscape it's flowing through, and the flow itself shapes that landscape over time. Another way of viewing this: we humans are like somewhat fixed neurons, but it's the connections we make with each other that change. Connections both to our contemporaries through complex social structures, as well as to the past, through knowledge accumulated in books and traditions, and other artifacts of past cultures.
- benj111 8y ago"and got behind when the English started using machine labour" What do you mean by machine labour here? If you're referring to steam engines I think you're drawing a causal link that isn't justified. The dates at best line up to early steam engines. They were massively inefficient and used for pumping out mines, they weren't exactly transformative to the nation.
- dredmorbius 8y agoWhat were those mines producing?
- benj111 8y agoTin and copper in Cornish mines, was the main driver early on. That isn't really the point, yes it was the 'age of steam' but in reality it made a few marginal mines profitable. There were no steam trains, no steam ships, no wide spread mechanisation. Britain wasn't some backwater that was propelled ahead of spain due to accidentally discovering steam power. It was already a power in it own right, with trading networks and markets for these raw materials, that was the impetus for the development of steam.
- dredmorbius 8y agoCoal, actually. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_power_during_the_Industrial_Revolution#Thomas_Newcomen's_steam_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_power_during_the_Industr... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Savery#Application_of_the_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Savery#Application_of_t... Coal mining was a thosand times greater than metal mining by the late 18th / early 19th century: Coal was so abundant in Britain that the supply could be stepped up to meet the rapidly rising demand. About 1770-1780 the annual output of coal was some 6.25 million long tons. Versus: Despite the collapse of the copper mining industry in 1866, the tin industry was still riding high producing 10,000 tons of tin a year - about half the world's production. http://www.miningartifacts.org/English-Mines.html http://www.miningartifacts.org/English-Mines.html Coal production 1700 - 1900: 1700 : 2.7 million tonnes 1750 : 4.7 million tonnes 1800 : 10 million tonnes 1850 : 50 million tonnes 1900 : 250 million tonnes http://historylearning.com/great-britain-1700-to-1900/indrevo/coal-mines-industrial-revolution/ http://historylearning.com/great-britain-1700-to-1900/indrev... More on copper: During the middle of the 18th Century the quantity of British copper sold was over 700,000 tons. https://www.copper.org/education/history/60centuries/raw_material/thepeak.html https://www.copper.org/education/history/60centuries/raw_mat...