3 ms·
The real tragedy is that a lot of people feel this way. And his insubstantial opinions, spliced with invectives, will persuade many more.
by mattmaroon 19y ago
The real tragedy is that a lot of people feel this way. And his insubstantial opinions, spliced with invectives, will persuade many more.
- DTrejo 19y agoI'd appreciate it if you elaborated. You seem to say that his take on suburbia is incorrect, but you do not say why.
- scorxn 19y agoThough I find this comment a bit trollish, I have to ask, which parts do you disagree with? For my own two cents, I grew up in Metro Detroit, which largely resembles the concrete wasteland Kunstler criticizes. And the most accessible, generally enjoyable place I've inhabited was The Loop in St. Louis -- a well-defined, fairly small example of "a place worth caring about."
- mattmaroon 19y agoI didn't really mean that original comment to come off as trollish, though I can see how it was taken as such. My problem with his speech as the same one you probably had with my comment. It's not so much correct or incorrect as it is one-sided and incomplete. He calls suburbia ugly. I call cracked cement as far as the eye can see, decrepit buildings, urine stench, and steam rising from manhole covers far more aesthetically offensive than any Target. (I might take it over some Wal-Marts though.) He totally glosses over the apparent values of suburbia. Our population is shifting to it in huge numbers, people must find it worth it. There's clearly something to suburban living. Maybe people like to own land and drive their own car to work, rather than sit on a smelly bus or subway next to smelly people. Maybe they still like to derive the economies of scale that Target and Wal-Mart afford them (which they cannot in an agrarian society) without either farming their own food or paying $3k a month for a tiny one bedroom apartment in a smog-ridden city. He doesn't mention the fact that with a good environmental policy we could (and I think in 25 years will) have Targets and still coexist peacefully with the Earth. His entire speech is just one-sided opinion with lots of invective and no apparent reasoning or factual basis. He calls the area that a very large portion of Americans choose to live in "not worth defending". That's pretty unusual for a TED talk. I'd consider his entire speech trolling. Maybe that's why his Wikipedia bio makes such conspicuous mention of his total lack of credibility.
- demallien 19y ago"He calls suburbia ugly. I call cracked cement as far as the eye can see, decrepit buildings, urine stench, and steam rising from manhole covers far more aesthetically offensive than any Target. (I might take it over some Wal-Marts though.)" There's no doubt that urbanism can be done badly. But when it is done well, it is an absolute pleasure. For example, I live in Paris, which is a highly urbanised city (obviously). Paris has very few parks, and very few private gardens (frontyards). But it is far and away more pleasurable to walk around Paris than to walk around, say, London. They have put a lot of effort into making tree-lined boulevards the defining feature of the city's streets. The very inner city lacks this, but makes up for it with a rich tapistry of shops, bars, cafés and restaurants. It took me about 3 years of walking around Paris (yes, you do wlk here, which is kind of the point!) before I got blasé about the whole experience. i mean, it's still brilliant,it's just that today it's what I expect of a city, and if I don't get that expeience when walking about another city, I tend to write that city off as an option for where I should live.
- mattmaroon 19y agoWell, Paris is a statistical outlier in that respect. Even still, I still have that primal human urge to look out my window and see trees. I think suburbanism can be done badly too, but is also very pleasurable done well.
- hugh 19y agoI agree, Paris is a great place to walk around. But in practical terms, what's it like to try and raise three children in a place where only the super-rich can afford to have a back yard? If the folks in Clichy-sous-Bois lived in ugly low-density suburbs would they still feel the need to riot every two months?
- demallien 19y agoWell, I don't have any kids, but I do have lots of friends that are raising their children whilst living in Paris. The first thing to note is that there is generally a park somewhere nearby where the children can play. Not always, but most of the time. I imagine there aren't many families living in the areas without parks. Secondly, for families with kids under the age of about 10 (when they can start to navigate streets on foot all by themselves), there's always the suburbs. But once kids are old enough to get around by themselves, I would think that they appreciate living in the city as much as I do. Thirdly, places like Clichy Sous Bois are pretty much the exact worst solution to providing living space. It's like they've taken the worst bits of suburbia, and the worst bits of urban living, and mashed them together, taking great care that none of the good parts are included.
- waldrews 19y agoEven people who don't happen to like suburbs should be turned off by the speaker's arrogant central-planner community-before-individual attitude.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]