3 ms·
Isn't that blatant copyright infringement? I mean, that cannot be legal.
by mattmaroon 19y ago
Isn't that blatant copyright infringement? I mean, that cannot be legal.
- keating 19y agoDon't worry, the particular porn genres they selected are also illegal so it all cancels out.
- gwc 19y agoFrom the article: "One of our clients runs a network of very large adult oriented sites, who has agreed to "donate" several of their most popular videos from one of their sites for this experiment." Assuming you believe that statement it seems they're on the up-and-up as far as copyright goes.
- mattmaroon 19y agoI missed that part.
- LPTS 19y agoI don't exactly see the US attorney stepping up to defend the copyright of whatever porn they are using. I just can't see the US Attorney releasing a statement like: "Copyright laws exist to ensure the creators of content are motivated, and are integral to our economy. So that people aren't dissuaded from making more hot XXX porn, we are aggressively pursuing anyone who violated the copyrights on Anal Squirting MILF's. We assure you that many senior personal at the department have taken an intense personal interest in this case. We must seek out all infringing porn and restore the economic incentives to create and distribute this hot hot pornography at all costs."
- jrockway 19y agoWell, if they don't enforce this, it will look bad when they try to enforce something else. And the government has a lot of money pouring into it for the sole purpose of enforcing copyright.
- LPTS 19y agoI realize this is irrelevant because the content was donated (which I didn't realize when I posted). But still: "Well, if they don't enforce this, it will look bad when they try to enforce something else." Because the US government and the fourth tier Pat Robertson law school grads and Bush's Youth alums running the justice department would never selectively enforce laws so the effects of that enforcement would conform to their irrational religious bigotries. The whole purpose of the system of laws in this country is that everyone is always breaking some law. This allows the people in power to have a lever they can use against anybody, at their discretion. Although not applicable to this case, selectively enforcing laws (and being hypocritical about it) is part of the foundation of the US legal system. Right wing fascist states always depend partially on sexual repression (and the associated fear/hatred of the feminine other that come with it) to create the psychological preconditions in the collective unconsciousness to allow authoritarianism to thrive. They would never side with porn producers that relieve sexual frustration. They would only side with porn producers when the pornography was titillating (like American Idol or beer commercials) instead of overtly erotic. When they do go after pornography, they go after pornography that contradicts the masculine objectification of females. This is why the last DOJ cases concerned squirting fetish movies (which are all about female orgasm, and deemed so dangerous that we must be protected from it) but the DOJ never goes after porn where the male orgasm is fetishized. Until people stop confusing titillation with eroticism, and eroticism with sex, the government will not stop being aggressively hypocritical in it's reaction to all three.
- mattmaroon 19y agoIt wouldn't matter, the porn companies would pursue action the same way the RIAA does. Doesn't matter though, apparently the content was donated.