5 ms·
If I'm a bail bondsman, I'm probably already sending text messages to my clients to make sure they show up in court, because if they don't, I'm the one out the
by philwelch 8y ago
If I'm a bail bondsman, I'm probably already sending text messages to my clients to make sure they show up in court, because if they don't, I'm the one out the money unless I go pick them up and take them to the county jail myself. I'm not sure about ankle bracelets, but there's no reason they couldn't be part of the current bail system, either--if I'm a bail bondsman, I'd give a discount to any client that wears an ankle bracelet that I can track.
The thing is, there's only one county court. If the county court has a program of ankle bracelets and text messages and supervised release and that program doesn't work, there's no incentive for it to change. And there's no alternative for the suspect, either--the judge has final say. With cash bail, there might be a dozen bail bondsmen in the county all in competition, each with the incentive to provide competitive terms to the suspect while guaranteeing their presence at court.
- Hello71 8y agoI don't think private bondsmen in the US can legally contract to require people to wear ankle bracelets. More fundamentally though, these sorts of "free market" theories tend to assume an unreasonable amount of options and knowledge of potential clients. See: payday loans. Sure, in theory all the details of the loans are pre-agreed, and customers sure do have a lot of options. In practice, the most ethical providers tend not to be the most successful.
- scottlocklin 8y agoI bet they have apps they could require people to stick in their phone which do the same thing. If not, and you feel like contributing to the dystopian hellscape we live in: business oppos!
- fgonzag 8y agoUnless you plan on surgically implanting the phone, I don't think that's a bulletproof plan
- scottlocklin 8y agoI dunno have you seen human beings lately? Most people seem to be surgically attached to their nerd dild^H^H^H phones. Assuming the bailee is a rational and well intentioned actor (the article does seem to imply many people miss court because they forget), this is probably a reasonable thing to do.
- simonh 8y agoPhone aren't always on, aren't always in coverage and the app would have to be actually active when the phone is switched on anyway. How do you think it would work?
- scottlocklin 8y agoIt would be a reminder app, and otherwise work exactly the same way as those creepy "spouse tracking apps" people use to catch cheating housewives.
- philwelch 8y ago> I don't think private bondsmen in the US can legally contract to require people to wear ankle bracelets. Well, that's something to think about, then. It wouldn't even necessarily just have to be between the suspect and the bondsman; you might also allow judges to allow bail contingent on the suspect wearing a locating device.
- mikeash 8y agoHow much competition is there going to be the bail bondsman for the homeless guy who gets picked up for vagrancy, or a poor person working paycheck to paycheck who already owes his soul to the local payday lenders? Your proposal sounds like a great way to get excellent bail services for people who have money, but that’s not how the courts are supposed to work.
- crankylinuxuser 8y ago> Your proposal sounds like a great way to get excellent bail services for people who have money, but that’s not how the courts are supposed to work. Sure about that? The way this country is heading is "One dollar = One vote". And once a sector gets accustomed to a stream of cash, there's no way to stop that flow of money.. No matter how dirty that money is.
- mikeash 8y agoI am sure that’s not how they’re supposed to work. How they actually work is another matter.
- perfmode 8y agoAre you being descriptive or normative?
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoI'm afraid I don't understand.
- taejo 8y agoAre you describing the world as you see it (that's descriptive; obviously you are, not sure why GP is asking) or as you think it should be (that's normative).
- philwelch 8y agoI'm not opposed to judges from releasing people of their own recognizance or under a different form of community supervision if that would be appropriate in that particular situation.
- pjc50 8y agoThis is the fully privatized "justice" system that Neal Stephenson parodied in Snow Crash. Private bail bonds are an almost uniquely US phenomenon. Most other countries either go harsher and keep everyone awaiting trial in jail, or more humane and allow bail on conditions not money. Only America sees it as an opportunity for economic exploitation. The best way to wither the system would be to speed up court proceedings.