4 ms·
If you actually attribute the tax dollars going to red states, the assertion that blue states fund red states is highly misleading. The bulk of what determines
by jandrewrogers 8y ago
If you actually attribute the tax dollars going to red states, the assertion that blue states fund red states is highly misleading. The bulk of what determines Federal dollars go outside of DC is:
- Where people retire. Social Security, Medicare, etc is a large part of this cash flow. In the US, many people move to the sunbelt States (often from blue States), which are almost all red. We can't prevent people in New York from retiring to Florida.
- Where military bases are located, which tend to be in rural red States where the land is cheap and environmental impact will be minimal. There used to be many more blue State military bases but many were closed in the 1990s to save taxpayer money. The greater San Francisco region is littered with former military bases. Military base expenditures and employment are another big chunk of the cash flow to red States.
- Where Federal offices are located. Outside of Washington DC, a large percentage of Federal employees are involved in things like agriculture, land management, national forests, national laboratories, border protection, etc which predominantly and often inherently involve red rural States. The Federal government operations are literally tied to geography, the location of these offices are not arbitrary nor charity.
Of these, only the first is welfare by any ordinary definition, and while it is a large portion of the net tax flow I don't think most people are suggesting that we eliminate it or prevent retirees from moving. The military to the extent it exists need to be put somewhere, preferably somewhere cheap and uninteresting. The rest of the Federal spending disparity can be largely eliminated overnight by eliminating all Federal employment related to managing geography but I don't think many people would support that either. It isn't the fault of the red States that many of the most popular national parks and natural resources are within their borders.
- taurath 8y agoBy making your point, its interesting that you point out just how dependent those red state's economies are dependent on the government. I guess that's one reason the golden cows of conservative fiscal policy is military spending and not touching social security (though they sometimes try for the latter in a way that makes it seem like they're not)
- cafard 8y agoI would point out that the seniority often enjoyed by southern Democrats before about 1968 meant that a lot of southerners headed important committees, and had a good deal of say in where bases and offices should be located.