3 ms·
> At the physical layer, is it the materials in the cables are getting better? Yes, and more expensive on that. Laptop makers totally hate usb 3.0+ for that.
by baybal2 8y ago
> At the physical layer, is it the materials in the cables are getting better?
Yes, and more expensive on that. Laptop makers totally hate usb 3.0+ for that.
The industry standard for internal digital connectivity was the FPC - flexible printed circuit board, a very economical and ergonomic solution, but then came USB 3.0.
Regular polyimide FPC can't reliably handle the high frequency signalling. Still, many laptop makers still use it, to regrettable results.
The few solutions left are the micro coax cable, running twisted pair inside the case, or passing it over a hard pcb bridge. All are very expensive, and hard on assembly lines.
This is why in most budget laptops manufacturers do a following trick – they put all usb 3.0 ports on one side, and 2.0 on the opposite. This way they only have to run the low frequency, low lane count usb 2.0 to other side of the laptop.
Only very recently, there came an FPC maker that makes custom cabling with some proprietary dielectric that can handle 3.0. And they charge more for it than for hard pcb bridge.
Even if the cable material issue is solved, you still have to find way to connect it to PCB. High frequency connectors are not cheap either.
- metaphor 8y agoThanks for sharing and interesting industry perspective. Color me unconvinced on one point though: > Only very recently, there came an FPC maker that makes custom cabling with some proprietary dielectric that can handle 3.0. A brief glance at IPC-4203A (which has been around since 2013) tells me this is a consequence of market cost sensitivity, not one driven by the inherent performance limitations of available material. The latest IPC-4203B was just published circa March 2018 last year. Is there something new worth looking into here, or is this "recent advancement" just a manufacturing process-driven one which has made high-performance FPC more viable in the throwaway consumer electronics market?
- baybal2 8y agoIt's more to finding FPC factories dealing with anything amounting to a "specialty product," and finding somebody who can engineer that FPC with all attention needed to signal integrity and fickleness of high frequency circuits.
- baybal2 8y agohttps://neoconix.com/products/standard-products/usb-3-1-type-c-high-speed-power-independent-fpc-assembly/ https://neoconix.com/products/standard-products/usb-3-1-type...