7 ms·
Ars Technica just wrote an article about the confusing names of USB versions https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/02/usb-3-2-is-going-to-make-the-current-usb-br
by sp332 8y ago
Ars Technica just wrote an article about the confusing names of USB versions https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/02/usb-3-2-is-going-to-make-the-current-usb-branding-even-worse/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/02/usb-3-2-is-going-to-... and now they have another one about this name. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/03/thunderbolt-3-becomes-usb4-as-intels-interconnect-goes-royalty-free https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/03/thunderbolt-3-become...
- izacus 8y agoI feel like hand-wringing around that is a bit overexaggerated - at the end of the day the differences really matter for only really tiny subset of devices that need those 10GBit+ transfers and in that case you can guide yourself by the "SuperSpeed 10Gbit" "Superspeed 20Gbit" logos on the actual box. For everything else the protocols are forward and backward compatible, so you just plug in the cable and it works.
- gambiting 8y agoSo remind me, why can you walk into any apple store, pick up a new MacBook and a 5K LG monitor, and when you plug in the monitor using the USB-C cable that was bundled with the MacBook it just won't work at all? My point is - the standards might be back and forward compatible. But the cables and ports definitely aren't - and your average consumer has absolutely no way of knowing. They look absolutely identical on the outside and when they don't work it's for completely non-obvious reasons.
- bazooka_penguin 8y agoThe cables should have a ss or ss 10 or ss 20 label on them. The end devices should too I believe.
- gambiting 8y agoApple cables and ports have no logos on them whatsoever. Just plain white/silver if metal.
- colejohnson66 8y agoNot true. See their thunderbolt cables: https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MD861LL/A/apple-thunderbolt-cable-20-m https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MD861LL/A/apple-thunderbo...
- gambiting 8y agoFair enough. But their USB-C cables and chargers do not: https://www.apple.com/uk/shop/product/MLL82ZM/A/usb-c-charge-cable-2m https://www.apple.com/uk/shop/product/MLL82ZM/A/usb-c-charge...
- tuscen 8y agoThat's because it's a USB Type-C cable that can handle only USB protocol. Thunderbolt 3 ones do have a logo on them [1]. Though, I do agree, having clear information directly on a USB Type-C cable on which features are supported would be much appreciated. [1] https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MQ4H2AM/A/thunderbolt-3-usb%E2%80%91c-cable-08-m?fnode=8b https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MQ4H2AM/A/thunderbolt-3-u...
- sjwright 8y agoThat's not a USB-C cable.
- colejohnson66 8y agoAll OP said was that their cables don’t have icons. He/She didn’t specify just USB
- j16sdiz 8y ago"should" The USB logo on usb1.0 cable should be printed on the "upper" side. How many times did you inserted it the wrong way?
- derefr 8y agoNo wiring issues necessary; the MacBook just isn't powerful enough to drive a 5K display. (I think the question you meant to ask is why the MacBook can't drive an external 4K Thunderbolt display using its included cable, which is more interesting—IIRC, it can do so through an HDMI adapter plugged into the USB-C port, but it cannot do so over a USB-C cable. This still isn't about the cable, though; you can take the MacBook's cable and use it to connect an MBP to a Thunderbolt display just fine. Instead, it's about the MacBook's combined Thunderbolt/USB-C controller not supporting the recent-enough version of Thunderbolt to have the bandwidth over the wire required to feed a 4K@60Hz display. When an HDMI dongle is plugged into the USB-C port, you're taking a direct GPU->controller->HDMI path, which avoids the anemic old-Thunderbolt bottleneck path.)
- gambiting 8y agoUhm....you can definitely connect the LG 5K UltraFine display to the latest MacBook using the USB-C(TB3) cable included with the monitor and it will work(and even charge the MacBook at the same time). So the MacBook definitely has enough power to drive it. But if you use the cable that was bundled with the MacBook it won't work even though externally it looks the same and will fit ports on each side. Less extreme example is how the OnePlus USB-C charger won't charge the Nintendo Switch, even though they are both USB-C certified devices. Edit: sorry, I just realized that I could have been misunderstood. I forgot that "MacBook" is a device that exists. Obviously(to me) by MacBook I mean the MacBook Pro.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rtkwe 8y agoThe cable problem with USB-C I think might be the largest annoyance when it comes to the promise of USB-C. For the highest speed stuff you can only really count on the cable that came with the device because for the extreme speeds you need a good cable with the right length. (The monitor should have a compatible cable bundled with it though. There's some major cable length limits and shielding when it comes to the highest speed stuff like monitors and eGPUs with USB-C.)
- mjevans 8y agoThis absolutely does need to be way more clear. There should be distinct and visibly obvious branding from the standards group. I should be able to tell by looking at a connector: * If it's claiming to be a certified cable/device or not. * The USB standard it conforms to (version) * The speed of data transfer it supports * The maximum wattage it supports * The maximum voltage it supports * (the connector type, but this is obvious based on shape)
- sneak 8y agoWhy is that? You can't do that from looking at a file with an unknown extension. Physical connector technology and signaling protocol are entirely different things. I'd be fine with literally everything using the same physical connector, but knowing that I can't and shouldn't plug my 5VDC battery-charger into a 110VAC outlet. I still have speakers that are connected by stripping a lampcord pair with my teeth, pushing a little button, jamming bare copper strands into a hole, and releasing a little button. I think you're asking for too much. Everything using one reversible connector that almost always guarantees 5VDC in a fallback mode is better than what we have today.
- mjevans 8y agoPick any random USB-C cable. Can you tell by looking at it what speeds it supports? Is it USB-3 or USB-2? How about the power delivery aspect, how much power is it cable of transferring? You might be able to tell some of those things from modern cables, if they're bragging about a speed factor, but otherwise it isn't clear.
- baroffoos 8y agoI got a new laptop this year and I couldn't even work out what protocols it supported. No where on the laptop spec sheet did it say that supports hdmi and displayport over usb c but when I use the plug for it it works. When I use the same adapter/plug on my phone it doesn't work.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 8y agoThere are two problems: 1. the same connector is used for a wide variety of capabilities, and it can get confusing knowing what you can use together. 2. the names of these connectors is confusing. You're complaining about the first, and that's a very hard problem. There are huge advantages to using the same connector and cables that can support 100W of power, 5K displays and also support peripherals that retail for less than $1 and be backwards compatible with peripherals over 20 years old. The disadvantage is the confusion you mention. The complaint in the article is about the second, the stupid naming. There's no good excuse for that. It really exacerbates the confusion from the first issue. But now it's on us and journalists just to not use the stupid naming. They've provide "marketing" names that aren't silly, so everybody should just use them, even if it's awkward. IOW "Superspeed USB 10Gbps", not "USB 3.2 gen 2".
- ksec 8y ago>You're complaining about the first, and that's a very hard problem. There are huge advantages to using the same connector and cables that can support 100W of power, 5K displays and also support peripherals that retail for less than $1 and be backwards compatible with peripherals over 20 years old. The disadvantage is the confusion you mention. Well In your example the Connector and Cable, specifically cable will have to be an expensive PD 100W Cable for it to correct, if the cable were designed for the $1 peripherals it wouldn't work with the 100W and 5K Display. The sentence would have been correct without the word cable, but without it the argument wouldn't stand. Because you just can't find a Cable with the same Connector and expect it to work with 5 / 10 / 20 years peripherals because the cable didn't support it.
- Mirioron 8y ago>There are huge advantages to using the same connector and cables that can support 100W of power, 5K displays and also support peripherals that retail for less than $1 and be backwards compatible with peripherals over 20 years old. This, quite honestly, sounds wasteful. I am fairly certain that manufacturing these connectors that are much better is more expensive than either the old, less sophisticated, connectors or simply new lower performance connectors.
- cesarb 8y agoI had this happen to me once with an HDMI cable I bought for my monitor, which I thought was defective until I found out that it worked on my TV. It was then that I remembered that HDMI has several speed grades, and my monitor happened to have a high enough resolution that not all HDMI cables would work with it. Happily, the HDMI cable I had been using on my TV worked on the monitor, so I just swapped the cables and all was fine. So this issue is not exclusive to USB. In fact, with USB the situation should be better, since all cables except the slowest ones are supposed to have a built-in chip describing how fast they can go. So in the MacBook example, in theory it should be able to detect the issue, switch to a lower resolution, and present an on-screen warning telling you what happened and why.
- abrowne 8y agoA lot (most?) charge cables are USB 2.0 — just enough data to negotiate the higher power. If they supported faster data too, they'd be more expensive. But it definitely should be more clear! Apple's minimalism doesn't help in this case, either.
- stephenr 8y ago> Apple's minimalism doesn't help in this case, either. Apple don't make a "USB-C data" cable - they make a USB-C charge cable, or a TB3 cable, and the TB3 one has the thunderbolt logo on each end. They also refer to it specifically as "USB-C Charge Cable", everywhere.
- abrowne 8y agoYes, if you buy it standalone. But what about in the computer box? I've opened a lot of MacBook Pros, and I can't remember seeing any labeling.
- protomyth 8y agoI’ve gotten into the habit of taking the supplied cable on all Mac portables and replacing it with a Thunderbolt 3 40gbs 100w cable from Monoprice before handing it over to the staff person. It cuts down on “why won’t this work” questions surrounding monitors and such.
- stephenr 8y agoApple and most TB vendors at least make the distinction of putting the TB logo/name on the cable ends (similar to USB3.0 cables that have "SuperSpeed" on them to indicate... something higher than 480Mbit).
- benj111 8y agoThat sounds like '10Gbit ought to be more than enough for anybody' to me. Plus the good thing about USB is it just works, you don't have to worry about any tiny subset (well that's the theory anyway). I've had enough of my monitor, mouse, keyboard and printer all using different connectors thank you very much. Edit: Making make sense.
- sandworm101 8y ago>>> I've had enough of my monitor, mouse, keyboard and printer all using different connectors thank you very much. Personally, I've had enough with my 1yo laptop, my 3yo desktop, my 5yo peripheral and that funny dongle I need for work all having different USB cables. USB was meant to save us from having multiple connectors but has done the opposite: every year there is a new USB cable/hole design. I cannot be the only one here who has to inspect every online purchase for high-rez pictures of the USB ports. I really don't care that my laptop has 10+Gb/w potential. I just need to know that my current equipment is physically compatible.
- rtkwe 8y agoThe issue is with USB-C you can run into limitations at the cable level where the cable is too long or poorly shielded to provide devices with the right data speeds/power requirements and some companies (cough apple cough though it's bleeding more into other places as the aesthetic gets copied) refuse to properly label things. And some of the differences are not spelled out anywhere, for example to get the top thunderbolt 3 data rate of 40Gb/s on a passive cord you cannot have a cord longer than .5m. To get a longer cable to pass the full speed (to drive say an eGPU or high res monitor) you have to get a more expensive active cable (that may not work because companies online are unscrupulous and will try to rip you off). All of this is extremely opaque to users who just want to have a slightly longer cable to arrange their desk as they prefer. At least with the different connectors and cables I didn't have to worry so much and things generally worked when plugged into the right place. [0] https://www.cnet.com/how-to/usb-type-c-thunderbolt-3-one-cable-to-connect-them-all/ https://www.cnet.com/how-to/usb-type-c-thunderbolt-3-one-cab...
- cletus 8y agoThis issue is neither new nor irrelevant. When USB 2.0 was introduced, it was a huge increase in speed. USB 1.1 is 11 Mbps whereas 2.0 is 480 MBps (theoretical). When this happened some camera manufacturers (Nikon I believe was one of them?) were identified as changing the marketing on their cameras to "USB 2.0". What this actually meant though was "USB 2.0 Full Speed", which is USB 1.1 speeds. USB 2.0 Hi-speed is 480. Consumers don't need this or want it. Manufacturers just don't want to say "USB <not latest version>". You see the same thing with AT&T deciding its LTE iPhones are 5G because they want their network to sound more impressive than it is. It's also why the strength bars on your phone show the strongest signal (2G/3G/4G) that your phone is getting, not the one its actually using. The truth matters. False advertising matters. Markets only work with a minimum level of trust. All of this legerdemain erodes that trust. I'm Australian and this is one place where I think the ACCC (equivalent to the FTC/FCC rolled into one) has way more teeth than their US equivalents. The ACCC, for example, ended ISPs advertising "unlimited" ISP plans that weren't truly unlimited (which was basically all of them). This also covered ISPs with hard or soft data caps where throttling would come into play. The ACCC also took ISPs to task on the truth in advertised speeds for services (which matters are lot for xDSL). A more sensible standard would've been something like: USB <version><plug> eg USB 3.1C, USB 3.0A. Or put the letter first. But this whole USB 3.2 Gen 1 = USB 3.1 Gen 2 or whatever is just pure nonsense.
- skykooler 8y agoThis is almost as bad as SpaceX's rocket naming scheme: https://external-preview.redd.it/yQJH1H8y7ypKanxgZKwIaJom5h4N9cu4WWX5D7wboNU.jpg?auto=webp&s=07f7d5c9ba0721e9ddf2c1e9299a3e00f21fc1d0 https://external-preview.redd.it/yQJH1H8y7ypKanxgZKwIaJom5h4...