4 ms·
Will it be possible to connect a Thunderbolt 3 Macbook or Intel Ice Lake PC via USB-C cable to a USB 4.0 device and obtain 40Gbps throughput?
by walterbell 8y ago
Will it be possible to connect a Thunderbolt 3 Macbook or Intel Ice Lake PC via USB-C cable to a USB 4.0 device and obtain 40Gbps throughput?
- wlesieutre 8y agoArticle says "The USB4 specification will be based on the Thunderbolt protocol that Intel has contributed to the USB Promoter Group. The new interface will use USB Type-C connectors and will maintain backwards compatibility with USB 2.0, USB 3.2, and Thunderbolt 3 interfaces", so bet on probably. But maybe not, they might only mean that a USB4 computer can use a TB3 device. I expect they'll continue the trend of inscrutable capability differences in USB-C ports, cables, and devices. To get the USB4 40GBps mode (effectively TB3) it's still going to be a more expensive active Thunderbolt-style cable, not a vanilla USB cable. Which means that standard markings for those cables will (hopefully?) be part of the USB4 spec. Unfortunately, knowing USB-IF the major change from the TB3 to USB4 spec will be to drop the current Thunderbolt symbol on the ports and cables and replace it with a new variation of USB-super-hyper-mega-speed symbol to make cables as confusing as possible.
- jsgo 8y agoor port color. We've used blue and red at least, guess it is time for green (in which case, confusion for the Razer Blade users).
- walterbell 8y agowe use yellow for power/charging
- wlesieutre 8y agoYellow IIRC means "provides power even when the computer is sleeping." It'd be harder to do markings like this on USB-C ports though. They don't have a big visible chunk of plastic in the middle.
- jsgo 8y agoI was being a bit facetious with the initial suggestion, honestly. Mostly poking at color being used as a universal indicator, and then you have a case like Razer where they introduce green to be complementary to their laptop's color scheme. Beyond just switching to brand + version number (ie [USB logo] 4, [thunderbolt logo] 3, etc.), I don't know of a great way to really go about this. Otherwise you end up with the super speed championship edition thing you posted, which isn't going to help anyone really. I think the color one was a great idea on their part in that you didn't have to look too close to see which port you were plugging into, but all it takes is one detractor to deviate from it (say if MSI came out with a gaming laptop with red USB2 ports), and then the whole idea is shot.
- DaiPlusPlus 8y agoApple will never use coloured ports.
- jsgo 8y agopulling my MacBook Pro out of my backpack to look, it looks like they aren't fans of iconography to say what a port is capable of either. Can't remember if my old 2013 MBP had the icons or not, but my current one for sure doesn't.
- wlesieutre 8y agoAll ports on Apple's laptops behave the same for charging - they'll continue to provide power while sleeping, but won't start providing power. If you want to use it as a battery in your backpack while it's closed you have to plug your phone in, wake the computer up, then put it back to sleep. At least that was the case last time I tested it. For the most part they don't need colors because all of the ports are the same. One recent exception was that the 2016/2017 MBPs had inconsistent Thunderbolt bandwidth because they didn't have enough PCIe lanes. IIRC left side had full 40Gbps ports but the right side had 20Gbps. The 2018 version has full speed on all four. EDIT - another potential point of confusion, they don't mark Thunderbolt ports vs USB-C ports. On any given device they're all the same, but they expect you to know that the 12"-mini-macbook is just USB-C while the Pro and Air are all Thunderbolt. So yeah, it'd be helpful to have some symbols on the laptops. They do label ports on their desktops. I assume this comes down to Ive not wanting labels on his beautiful chunk of aluminum where someone might accidentally see them while using it.
- sambroner 8y agoWow, "only starts charging while awake" really explains some confusing mornings waking up to a dead laptop.
- wlesieutre 8y agoTo clarify, I'm talking about using the laptop as a power source to charge other devices (phones, tablets, etc) off your laptop's USB ports. If you plug them in while the laptop is asleep they won't start charging. If you plug them in while the laptop is awake they'll start to charge, and they'll keep going if the computer goes to sleep later. If you laptop isn't charging itself while plugged in to the wall you have other problems.
- klodolph 8y agoProbably depends on the specs of the cable, and other factors like which port you plug into, cable length, etc. Some people are complaining about how this doesn't match expectations, which are that you get the same speed just by using the right shape of cable (and don't care about cable specs). I think that the reality is that this is really pushing the envelope, and 40 Gbit/s isn't that far from typical memory bandwidth (order of magnitude). There are only so many lanes of PCIe to go around, and you're going to end up with some ports getting more than others. We already have problems in Ethernet land with the different cat 5e / cat 6 / cat 7 cables, where bandwidth autonegotiation is mandatory. Most people just want it to work, and if you want your full bandwidth you have to pay attention to the exact specs of every device in the signal path because you can't be sloppy the way you could with 100BASE-T or even 1000BASE-T. That's a bit of a rant, but I just think that some of the problems with user experience in this area are just down to the fact that this really is a lot of bandwidth to try and push through an external cable, and you end up with the simultaneous goals of having high bandwidth, lots of ports, having all ports be the same, and not charging an arm and a leg for a laptop. Sacrificing bandwidth on a couple ports makes sense to me, in this context. Seems like the user experience pays, cause I'm not sure how I'm supposed to know which ports have bandwidth.