4 ms·
I thought that most people with a mortgage itemized last year, because that mortgage interest deduction is huge until you're close to paying off your house. Th
by jandrese 8y ago
I thought that most people with a mortgage itemized last year, because that mortgage interest deduction is huge until you're close to paying off your house. This isn't just high earners, it's the middle class. The GOP tax bill squeezed the middle class to give that huge absolute percentage reduction to people at the very top.
From a macroeconomic standpoint this is madness. We're taking money away from the people who really drive the economy and giving it to the ones who are already struggling to find a place to stash all of the money that 30 years of supply side economics have burdened them with. A middle class family would have bought goods and services, a billionaire is looking for any investment opportunity that hasn't been completely diluted by the enormous amount of capital floating around and is going to have to stick it in some "financial instrument" that we're only going to learn about when it causes the next financial catastrophe.
- gok 8y ago> I thought that most people with a mortgage itemized last year Not sure if you're referring to 2018 or 2017, but most mortgage holders won't itemize for 2018.
- jandrese 8y agoFor 2017. And yes, that $10k cap is below the standard deduction for most people so it won't make sense to itemize. The problem of course is that even the new (temporarily raised) standard deduction is still less than the itemized deductions from previous years, meaning people who own a home or have dependants or give to charity got reamed in the butthole this year. The tax code is now optimized for selfish assholes, exactly as Ryan wanted.
- gok 8y agoHuh? The $10K cap applies only to state and local taxes. Mortgage interest, dependent exemptions and charity giving is unaffected by the cap.
- jandrese 8y agoIt totally hit me this year. I was maxed out before the mortgage interest deduction was even finished and the charitable contributions mattered exactly diddly squat. Ended up taking the standard deduction instead because it was higher.
- gok 8y agoAre...you sure you did your taxes right? Just because you maxed out your SALT deduction doesn't mean you don't also qualify for other itemized deductions. Unless you're affected by AMT or something?
- jandrese 8y agoThat's what TurboTax told me. SALT wasn't huge for me, and I'm nowhere near the AMT. I put in the mortgage interest deduction after the dependents and it popped up a window saying that I've hit the $10k limit on deductions and any further deductions won't be counted. True to its word all further deductions (mostly charitable contributions) made no difference.
- smileysteve 8y agoI got bad news for you.... It seems you did your taxes incorrectly.
- gok 8y agoAny chance that was a limit of your version of TurboTax and they were trying to sell you a fancier copy?
- jandrese 8y agoSame version we use every year. Same procedure we go through every year. If I did it wrong I'm not alone. Roughly: Enter all W2 info that they should already have. Enter all interest income. Enter dividends (which are small) then we move on to deductions Enter Dependants Enter Mortgage Interest (at this point the software tells us that we've maxed out deductions for the year) Now a note about the interface on this software. In the corner they included a current tally of your tax owed/refund which updates every time you enter a new value. At this point we start putting in the deductions anyway, because some things aren't counted until later steps, although it had been counted in the past. We note that the value in the corner is not changing despite putting in a significant amount of deductions. Once we finish with the deductions the software tells us that the cap on deductions ($10k) is less than our standard deduction and suggests we take the standard deduction instead, which we do. I don't know how we could have gotten it wrong.