5 ms·
You got too distracted by the Simpson's Paradox reference to see the actual Simpson's Paradox in play. As sokoloff [1] pointed out in a below thread, Google ha
by slg 8y ago
You got too distracted by the Simpson's Paradox reference to see the actual Simpson's Paradox in play. As sokoloff [1] pointed out in a below thread, Google having an overwhelming male workforce means that there could still be a large bias against women at the same time that more man are being underpaid.
There is simply not enough information presented in this article to know whether there is truly a gender bias (in either direction) regarding how Google pays their employees.
[1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19303989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19303989
- mpweiher 8y ago> There is simply not enough information... Hmm... "Men account for about 69 percent of the company’s work force, but they received a disproportionately higher percentage of the money. " So, yes, we do have that information.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoI think we're moving the goalposts here: are we talking an abstract man, on average, in general earning more than an abstract, average women or we're talking about a different pay for the same work? My understanding is that we're talking about the latter.
- cronix 8y agoDoes "same work" also include the hours worked? Usually not. If someone completes x projects in y hours, and someone else completes the same x projects in z hours, are they the same? Both did "the same work," but one was more efficient and did it faster (presuming the quality of the work by both parties was equal).
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoI assume most of Google employees are exempt, so the exact number of hours spent on a job is hard to calculate.
- hellisothers 8y agoAgreed, “hours worked” is starting to look like a dog whistle in these threads
- cronix 8y agoHow is it a dog whistle? How can you accurately compare unless you take such factors into account? Are you saying it's statistically insignificant?
- hellisothers 8y agoI’m saying “hours worked” is a straw man to some extent since everybody is exempt so what does it matter?
- slg 8y agoYet we don't know what jobs women and men do at Google. There can be bias elsewhere in the system. For example women might be disproportionately hired as administrative assistants and men might be disproportionately hired as senior engineers. Both groups could then be compensated fairly and it would result in men receiving a disproportionately higher percentage of the money.
- skywhopper 8y agoYou've missed the point entirely. The comparisons are among peers in the same jobs. But it sounds like Google can't get its own data together in a sensible way, so you can't really trust any numbers in this article.
- skywhopper 8y agoThis is a good hint, but it's not enough information. Specifically, the jobs where the pay imbalance is likely greatest also would also likely have a more skewed gender ratio. But we can't know, because the article doesn't say, and just trusts Google's word on everything.
- tomschlick 8y agoTotaling up all money men make vs all money women make regardless of the job is not a valid argument for pay discrimination.
- frogpelt 8y agoI think you're right. E.g.: Google is 70% men. At 100,000 employees: 70,000 Male 30,000 Female If 5% of men are underpaid that's 3,500 men. If 10% of women are underpaid that's 3,000 women. More men are underpaid (3,500 > 3,000). But women are twice as likely to be underpaid (10% > 5%).
- haberman 8y agoThe article said disproportionately more underpayment was to men. Therefore your hypothetical scenario (which posits that the difference was measured in absolute terms) is not what Google found.
- Traster 8y agoIt wouldn't be the first time a news article had a poor understanding of statistics. But more importantly, you may find men occupy high salary roles in engineering whilst women work in HR - resulting in the salary changes going disproportionately to men, because a % increase in their salary is far higher than the women on lower salaries.
- haberman 8y ago> But more importantly, you may find men occupy high salary roles in engineering whilst women work in HR - resulting in the salary changes going disproportionately to men, because a % increase in their salary is far higher than the women on lower salaries. The article says the opposite with regard to where the salary adjustments went: > One effect of the adjustments was to create a pronounced imbalance in compensation among lower-level software engineers, one of Google’s largest job groups, with a large number of men identified as being underpaid compared with their female peers. To offset that, further adjustments were made. Google said it saw no pattern in the reasons women were receiving more discretionary pay.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoThe passage you quote makes it clear the disparity is in absolute numbers, not proportions, as your earlier comment suggests. Btw, note that this passage (that I also quoted yesterday for a comment of my own) is now nowhere to be found in the article, that has been heaviy edited since it was posted on HN.