5 ms·
That's because it's not merely a cultural issue, it's a biological one. By necessity, all women that have children need to take time off, at least in the pregn
by fastball 8y ago
That's because it's not merely a cultural issue, it's a biological one.
By necessity, all women that have children need to take time off, at least in the pregnancy/birth stage. The productivity lost is generally less if you only need to coordinate one person taking maternal/paternal leave. So the obvious choice is to extend the leave of the person that absolutely must take it.
- aaomidi 8y agoIt's both actually. Different cultures have had different approaches to raising a child. Painting it as black and white doesn't help.
- Pfhreak 8y agoThe phrase 'not merely' implies 'both'.
- aaomidi 8y agoSorry missed this.
- dpratt 8y agoPraytell, which culture has the approach that designates men give birth and recover in a hospital?
- rad_gruchalski 8y agoWell, it’s not back and white. It is common in the EU to have a man take parental leave. Just because “The United States, Suriname, Papua New Guinea, and a few island countries in the Pacific Ocean are the only countries in the United Nations that do not require employers to provide paid time off for new parents.” (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parental_leave https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parental_leave) does not mean anything.
- m_eiman 8y agoOf course the mother doesn't HAVE to take time off - just do a planned c section on a Saturday and she can be back to work on Monday. But it'd be a bad idea, of course. Copy Sweden instead, that'd be a lot better. 480 paid days off (390 of those at ~75% of normal pay, the rest at a low rate). Of those 480 days, each parent has half but all but 90 days per parent can be transferred to the other parent. Also you have a legal right to work 75% until your kid is seven if you want to.
- mattbeckman 8y ago"Of course the mother doesn't HAVE to take time off - just do a planned c section on a Saturday and she can be back to work on Monday." This isn't based on reality. Recovery time for a c-section is a week or two at least (planned or emergency). I would think 5-6 weeks before anyone would be talking about going back to work. It's a major surgery. Only way you could do a Saturday delivery and back to work on Monday is if you were a superhero and dropped the baby the classic way early AM Saturday.
- 19870213 8y agoOne way I heard it described (from a medical student, years back), a c-section is like cutting up your thigh muscle (or other major muscle), you ain't gonna move for a while.
- Joe-Z 8y ago>Only way you could do a Saturday delivery and back to work on Monday is if you were a superhero and dropped the baby the classic way early AM Saturday. Superheroes aren't based in reality. The only way humans could fly is if they weighed 80% less and had big wings. Seriously have you ever heard of satire? This whole thread seems like a bunch of people just waiting for a chance to tout their in-depth knowledge of c-sections. And that it's flagged now is a shame, considering GP was clearly being hyperbolic to make a point about corporate/work culture.
- jedrek 8y agoConsider going back to school and taking some health classes. Not uni level, just elementary.
- User23 8y agoBreastfeeding is also a major issue. For the first six months of life it's far and away the preferred food source. And breastfeeding infants need to eat every 1-3 hours. Sure, women can pump, but then they have to do that every 1-3 hours to maintain their supply. Also while pumped human milk is better than formula, it's still not as good as direct. Biologically speaking pregnancy, birth, and raising children makes serious demands on women that it doesn't on men. Treating people justly requires recognizing these differences.
- rabboRubble 8y agoAnd by necessity, some men take over primary parental responsibilities when their child's birth mother die in child birth or decide wifehood and mommyhood isn't for them and run off.