4 ms·
> State government's revenue collection shouldn't funge against the federal government's revenue collection. At an aggregate level, this argument makes some se
by gnicholas 8y ago
> State government's revenue collection shouldn't funge against the federal government's revenue collection.
At an aggregate level, this argument makes some sense. But when you look at individuals who pay lots of tax, there actually is a good reason to allow a deduction from a tax policy perspective.
States like CA and NYC have progressive income tax rates, so the people paying a lot (and whose deductions are being capped) are high-earners. If their incremental tax dollars were being used to essentially fund consumption-like services for high-earners, then it would be proper to deny a federal deduction. The argument would be: well, your state took taxes from rich people in order to fund fancy museums/opera houses, so we shouldn't allow a deduction for this sort of state-intermediated consumption.
But CA and NY's high-earner taxes aren't used for this, for the most part. For example, CA's "millionaire's tax" (Prop 63) is specifically used to fund state-provided mental health services. Presumably none of the rich people who fund this actually receive these services because they already have their own doctors.
Of course, these taxpayers do see an indirect benefit from the provision of social services, insofar as they help keep crime rates lower and such. But in general, the income taxes paid by high earners are not akin to consumption, which would be the tax policy argument that one would make if trying to get rid of the federal deduction.
- darawk 8y agoI'm not sure how this makes the case that these things should come out of the federal government's pocket. If CA/NY want to levy a tax for mental health...then they should do that. They shouldn't get to arbitrarily take part of the federal government's revenue to accomplish it. At least, I don't see how you're making the case that they should be able to.
- gnicholas 8y agoThe point is that at an aggregate level, your argument makes some sense. The fed govt didn't choose to enact this plan, vis a vis the state govt. However, if you look at the fed govt versus the taxpayer, the calculus shifts. What if every rich person who pays the millionaire's tax voted against it and derives no pleasure from it? Why should they be forbidden a deduction from a tax policy perspective? Companies get unlimited SALT deduction, and until this law, people did too. We can even get tax credits for foreign taxes paid. The general rule is that if some govt took your money, you get to deduct it on your federal return. So if there's going to be an exception to this general rule, there should be a good tax policy reason for it.
- jrs235 8y ago>Companies get unlimited SALT deduction, and until this law, people did too. Exactly! Yup! The new limits to SALT don't hurt landlords...
- zaroth 8y agoThis is because it would drive up rents, the costs would accrue fully to the [lower-income] people renting the property not to the landlord. It would be great to see renters get to deduct the property tax (up to $10k) that they pay intrinsically as part of their rent, but I doubt it will ever happen. The Fed is already not losing out when renters pay the property tax through their rent, rent is not deductible, so the Fed is getting all the income tax. The rental income is netted against expenses on the landlord side and any excess is taxed again at the landlords marginal rate. A dollar can be taxed again and again every time it changes hands. Usually every other time it changes hands there’s an opportunity to net out expenses before being taxed, otherwise taxes would completely swamp the economy. Company A sells Product A, proceeds of which pays Employee B, who pays rent to Landlord C, who buys Product D from Company D. In just that short sequence what percentage of the money flow went to taxes? Almost certainly well over 50%, perhaps approaching 70%, mostly borne by Employee B through payroll and income taxes, second by the Landlord C paying high marginal taxes on any rental profit, and lastly by the Employee and Landlord in the form of sales taxes. The Companies in this example do hand some dollars to the IRS and their States, but the dollars all actually come from B and C.
- klipt 8y agoThink of it in terms of incentives. Under the new tax law: * Paying state taxes to fund public schools: not deductible. * Paying private school fees: deductible. So the new tax law incentivizes private schools over public. * Paying state taxes to help poor people: not deductible. * Paying church tithes to help poor people: deductible. So the new tax law incentivizes religious aid to the poor over public aid to the poor. It's basically using the tax code to push everyone towards "Republican" values.
- smileysteve 8y agoIt's interesting that you use "Republican" as this is one of the rare cases where you can actually use conservative.
- defertoreptar 8y agoEven if the tax is progressive and not related to consumption, why should the federal government foot the bill? That state-provided mental health service wasn't the federal government's idea to build.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Even if the tax is progressive and not related to consumption, why should the federal government foot the bill? The federal government is no more footing the bill through deductibility than it is footing the cost of capital acquisition by taxing net gains rather than gross revenue of capital sales; it just isn't taxing the investments state taxpayers make in common facilities which enable their earnings. Mm which is actually the only reason for the SALT deduction, which still exists. It just now had a nonsensical limit that has no basis besides punishing political revenues and promoting low tax policy regardless of efficiency.
- defertoreptar 8y ago> The federal government is no more footing the bill through deductibility than it is footing the cost of capital acquisition by taxing net gains rather than gross revenue of capital sales; it just isn't taxing the investments state taxpayers make in common facilities which enable their earnings. There's a difference. In the case of taxing net gains rather than gross revenue on capital sales, every citizen is represented in this decision. Not to mention, the consequential incentive is to increase investment in businesses that create taxable earnings. In the case of the SALT deduction, the consequential incentive is to increase state and local taxes to fund social programs over which only that state's citizens have representation.
- thegayngler 8y agoThe fact that this is skewed a bit to favor those who paid in based on their state of origin I am certainly ok with. The state had a strong hand in creating the business environment for people to thrive in such a way that they could become wealthy to begin with. So I'm okay if some federal dollars have to be shaved off so states can take care of themselves. I do not believe there is an endless incentive for states to raise taxes at the expense of the federal government.