3 ms·
I thought everyone wanted the rich to pay their fair share? This change mostly affects the rich, it's even in the title of TFA. It's where the richest in the
by tracker1 8y ago
I thought everyone wanted the rich to pay their fair share? This change mostly affects the rich, it's even in the title of TFA. It's where the richest in the country live that is most affected.
Personally, I'd like to see income taxes removed entirely in favor of sales/import/export taxes.
- conanbatt 8y agoI never went deep into this idea: why would sales/import export taxes be any better? Sales are regressive taxes, and import/export are distortive af.
- tracker1 8y agoMainly that it is a simpler system that is easier to control with less bureaucracy. Today it would probably also hold to money transfers out of the country. I'm mostly a proponent of a minimalist government, pragmatically speaking. I'm a proponent of laws and systems that increase personal liberty and minimize bureaucracy. I accept that there may be some distortion and it isn't exactly fair. But the deductions in the current system aren't exactly fair either.
- conanbatt 8y agoLand taxes are the best for that. They are impossible to avoid, very easy and predictable to levvy, and are way more representational, fair and non-distortive taxes.
- tracker1 8y agoI'm also not a fan of property taxes for individuals... It may be impractical, but if someone is able to live on their own, purchased land with no interaction with the outside world, they shouldn't be at risk of losing property for simply continuing to live.
- conanbatt 8y agoThere is no land without interaction with the outside world. Land with no interaction is land to be claimed by any military in the world.
- moate 8y ago>>I'm a proponent of laws and systems that increase personal liberty and minimize bureaucracy. Bureaucracy is a cornerstone of American democracy. When you have 2 strong parties and a push for greater and greater political distance, the bureaucracy is what keeps one party from shackling the other with some policy that leads to the end of the Union. Personally I feel it's never been more important.
- tracker1 8y agoA minimal government can still have rules. It just doesn't have to be how it is today. There were very differing political ideologies from the founding of the US... the government didn't even resemble today's size until we were in the 1900's.
- moate 8y agoOh sure. Small nimble government is a choice, and there are people like yourself who feel agile is best. I personally prefer a big ponderous government at the national level. It's a preference. When you have 300 million people, I appreciate the government working more like an Ent-moot.
- defertoreptar 8y agoThey're not any better. For an example of an alternative, Milton Friedman once remarked that he believed Georgism (land value tax) to be the least bad tax. The idea is to only tax land, which is a very progressive tax. The tax can't be evaded, since you can't hide land. It also creates a consequence for land speculators who sit on unused real estate. As a result, it stimulates the economy with the upsurge in business opportunities.
- conanbatt 8y agoI am a full blown georgist :), want to hear more about why sales/ i-e taxes are appealing to some.
- standardUser 8y ago"I thought everyone wanted the rich to pay their fair share?" There is a growing consensus that those with vast and rapidly increasing accumulations of wealth should pay more taxes. Not upper-middle income families in expensive metros.
- refurb 8y agoJust like the old adage "An alcoholic is someone who has one more drink than I do", being rich is always "someone who makes more than I do."
- standardUser 8y ago"being rich is always "someone who makes more than I do." In recent American discourse, the metric is usually the top 1% or a fraction of the top 1% (in terms of wealth and /or income). These aren't our well off neighbors, these are families that are astronomically wealthy. The top 1% of wealthiest households in the US possess more wealth than the bottom 90%. There are plenty of people with more money then me who are nowhere near that top 1%, but few people are clamoring for them to pay more in taxes.
- tracker1 8y agoIsn't most of the U.S. in the top 1-5% of the world? Again, I'm against the tax structure to begin with... I'd rather see most exceptions eliminated. The fact is the states are relying on that deduction to shift things... this just puts a cap on it.
- refurb 8y agoTop 1% in the US is a household income over $450k. That’s easily exceeded in a couple who both work in tech. We’re not talking about the super wealthy at all.
- spaced-out 8y agoNo, there's a pretty clear difference between people who have to get up and work every day or they'll end up homeless, and those that don't.