2 ms·
"As with all aromas, the origins can be traced back to a number of chemical constituents, so we can examine the processes and compounds that can contribute to b
by pmoriarty 8y ago
"As with all aromas, the origins can be traced back to a number of chemical constituents, so we can examine the processes and compounds that can contribute to both."
There's also the hard question of why something smells a particular way to you. This is a question arguably beyond chemistry, and (more contentiously) perhaps even beyond biology.
It's like why something that has the color red appears as red to you, while the same object might appear as blue to someone else, but since you're both referring to the same thing and using the same words for it, you normally assume you're having the same experience but there's really no way to know that you are. There's no way to inspect anyone else's experience to see if it matches your own (and even if you could, those would still be your experiences of their experiences).
With that in mind, one could ask why the smell of a rose (or of whatever chemicals make up that smell) smell the way they do (ie. why you experience them as you do). It's difficult to see how an answer based in biology or chemistry could ever answer that question.