19 ms·
Amazon stops selling Dash buttons
- new_guy 8y agoI think they would have been more successful if you could have actually gotten them for the products you wanted, not just a random selection of stuff you probably never ordered.
- capdeck 8y ago... and just add that to the shopping cart (don't make an actual purchase) so I can review and click order next time I am buying stuff. May be there was such an option - don't know - never used the buttons.
- KingMachiavelli 8y agoExactly, why not sell a generic version? You could limit it to products where the vendor has uploaded the appropriate logo/image that will be displayed on the Dash button but that would shift determining what products consumers would use a Dash button for onto the Vendors. Then again, I agree that most people willing to use a Dash button are also the kind of people willing to use an Echo, save the uber privacy concious minority.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoWell, they did have a generic version. The “Enterpris” button is designed to work with AWS IoT, you press it and it publishes an MQTT message to your IoT Core ARN. What you do from there is up to you - usually you would invoke a lambda to go do something.
- kalleboo 8y agoIn my case even for the products they had, they didn't include the packaging size I usually order
- iceninenines 8y agoThey did make them more generic later. I remember because I almost accidentally bought one. :)
- michaelt 8y agoI'm pretty certain the Dash button was what, in the grocery industry, is known as a "supplier-funded promotion", i.e. the buttons were subsidised by the supplier whose logo was printed on them. So when you buy a $5 Dash button for Tide Pods™, Amazon spends $11 to make it and ship it to you, of which you pay $5, Amazon pays $2, and Procter & Gamble pays $4. Amazon and P&G both gamble they'll make up the loss on the button with profit on your extra purchases. This explains a bunch of weird features: * The reason Dash buttons were only available for some brands is because only some brands had agreed to pay the subsidy. * The reason they ship with the logo sticker already in place, instead of a single item with a big sheet of stickers? Because the sticker is for the company that paid the subsidy. * The reason non-Prime customers couldn't buy them? Because if you don't have free shipping, they think you won't press the button enough to make up their loss. * The reason the AWS button costs more? Because nobody's subsidising it (plus the fact they charge what the market will bear, obviously) * Why would they discontinue them? Because it turns out the gamble on extra sales doesn't pay off.
- fxfan 8y agoCan you 'root' them to do your bidding? For 5usd they don't sound bad.
- isoskeles 8y agoI think so. Ex: https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-world/with-push-of-button-complaint-on-airplane-noise-is-filed/ https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-world/with-push-of-butto... > Airnoise is the brainchild of California resident Chris McCann, who repurposed the same plastic Dash Button that Amazon customers use to order toilet paper and detergent.
- gmu3 8y agoWho knows what that person used but they also sell a developer friendly version (although the battery isn't replaceable) https://www.amazon.com/1st-Generation-AWS-IoT-Button/dp/B01C7WE5WM/ https://www.amazon.com/1st-Generation-AWS-IoT-Button/dp/B01C...
- blackfawn 8y agoYou can reprogram the STM32 microcontroller in them[0]. It's a fairly decent Cortex-M3 processor and it additionally has WiFi and a few other features. Some people went an easier route and just watched for the ARP request the dash button would send[1]. $5 isn't bad but when you could buy them from Amazon, you'd get a $5 credit when you used it the first time, essentially making it "free" if you needed the purchased item anyway. [0]: https://learn.adafruit.com/dash-hacking-bare-metal-stm32-programming https://learn.adafruit.com/dash-hacking-bare-metal-stm32-pro... [1]: https://github.com/hortinstein/node-dash-button https://github.com/hortinstein/node-dash-button
- Hortinstein 8y agoauthor here of node-dash-button...i have let support lapse a little bit, but it still should work. Might be time to go in for a maintenance release. Glad people are still finding a use for it!
- homero 8y ago
- gumby 8y agoThey sell a much more expensive one ($18) for use with AWS btw.
- misingnoglic 8y agoAmazon wants to make people avoid checking prices on items with features like this, and that seriously scares me.
- expertentipp 8y agoThe optimal price will be calculated accordingly (considering "temporary local monopolies", personal profile, and purchase history), no need for the customer to deal with pesky numbers. /s
- wavefunction 8y agoI note your /s but it seems reasonable, as long as you consider the optimal to be figured on behalf of Amazon.
- gkoberger 8y agoEh, sure, they want to lower the cost of friction. But I don't think their goal is to ramp up prices. For many things (toilet paper, detergent, etc), it's really nice to not have to think about it.
- m12k 8y agoReminds me of an anecdote I heard about the response from a billionaire when some startup founders were pitching their sports tracking app to him: "I don't really get why the business case needs to be so fancy - I made my first million selling toilet paper". Never underestimate the value of selling something that people need to buy on a weekly or daily basis.
- xref 8y agoAmazon prices fluctuate wildly depending on myriad things: user/IP (can jump on tor and see prices change), stock levels, time of day, A/B price testing etc etc. viewing the price graphs at camelcamelcamel.com are really eye opening Basically I’d never be able to trust I was getting a fair price at the instant I pushed the button.
- tapland 8y agoYeah. Alexa makes ordering items like this much easier and flexible (different products, sizes, adding to cart). It was always a pretty cool thing though. Something to remember about the start of IoT
- whoisjuan 8y agoI have one that I use to re-order Soylent and I love it. It's a super simple experience that ties two micro-moments. The realization that I run out of something and the intention to restock that item. That being said, I can see why they stop selling them. An Echo Device can do the same. But I still think nothing beats the simplicity of just pressing a button. It's seamless. I hope they keep supporting them.
- imwally 8y ago> Existing Dash buttons will continue to function “so long as the public keeps using them,” CNET says. via https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/28/18245315/amazon-dash-buttons-discontinued https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/28/18245315/amazon-dash-butt...
- zaarn 8y agoI think another reason they are stopping is that in Germany, they lost a court battle and the court forbid them from selling the dash button to order products unless significant changes were made.
- acct1771 8y agohttps://www.reuters.com/article/us-amazon-com-germany-court/court-says-amazon-dash-buttons-violate-german-law-idUSKCN1P42HW https://www.reuters.com/article/us-amazon-com-germany-court/... Wonder if they'd have been okay with it if you had to select the item at the pricepoint - or if whatever speaker had Alexa asking you if $2.XX is an okay price?
- zaarn 8y agoPrice alone wasn't the only issue IIRC they also lacked information such as final checkout price (including how much tax paid) as well as Terms of Service information. The consumer group also claimed it wasn't evident that you would be ordering something for money by pressing the button, though I'm unsure if the court also waved that through.
- djhworld 8y agoMy issue with them is you couldn't set an Amazon locker as your delivery location, so I never bothered using it. Instead my dash buttons have been repurposed as a control switch for my lamp that sits across the other side of the room
- tanilama 8y agoWith Alexa devices, Dash button does feel redundant.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- purplezooey 8y agoThey were fun to hack around with, that's all I heard anyone using them for.
- setquk 8y agoOne less IoT destination landfill product off the market. Can’t be a bad thing.
- busterarm 8y agoTwo years ago I met some guys with an Icelandic startup to help autoshops manage their parts inventory. One cool thing they were doing was using these Dash buttons to let the shops reorder parts like filters, etc. I can't remember the name but I wonder if they're impacted at all...Then again, two years is an eternity in early-stage startup time.
- tfolbrecht 8y agoAmazon still sells the developer Dash Button as AWS IoT button. Thats probably what your friends are using. They're going to be alright anyway, because if that gets discontinued you can build your own around the ESP8266. Its just a button that makes a curl request.
- dpwm 8y ago> you can build your own around the ESP8266. Having just done this with something that required an element of reliability, I can confirm that this is quite easy. Micropython is great, but I did have some reliability issues – it's quite unfortunate that the hardware watchdog timer isn't implemented yet for the ESP8266. In the end I switched to using the Arduino port and platformIO, and it's quite literally the simplest code that might work.
- ddeokbokki 8y agoThe AWS IoT button is 22GBP, I got 6 dash buttons for 99p each (on Amazon). :(
- joshstrange 8y agoYes and while you can do some wifi tricks to make a dash button work similarly to an IoT button it's not easy nor reliable. That said, the price is ridiculous, If they had made the IoT button rechargeable or have a removable battery then I wouldn't have a problem.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- johnnycab 8y agoI bought a few of these (JK29LP) to use as IoT buttons when they were on an offer. I found that not associating them with a product, the credit could be used for normal Amazon purchases. I am now using a couple of these to control Yeelights via Node-Red, the latency is similar to a IFTTT recipe. https://www.youtube.com/watch?reload=9&v=65G7ApQYlmA https://www.youtube.com/watch?reload=9&v=65G7ApQYlmA https://ifttt.com/yeelight https://ifttt.com/yeelight
- pjc50 8y agoThere is probably a multi-billion dollar opportunity in home inventory management. This wasn't it. I can see two big reasons why nobody's taken this opportunity yet: - data entry. The button simplified this in one axis, but people in this thread are listing the problems: access control, ordering more than one kind of thing, acceptability of substitutions. - adversarial relationship. Nobody sensible is going to surrender their inventory management to a retailer, unless convenience really trumps cost. See also HP "infinite ink". If you were willing to cover your store cupboards with cameras (!), you could track potentially track everything in and out. Maybe scan receipts as well. But this amounts to a lot of information about your home life and domestic economics, and I don't want to just turn that over to a company who'll exploit it. Perhaps what I want is "YNAB, but for food". Edit: see this comment on "supplier-funded promotion": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19300292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19300292 ; the inherent tension of the Dash button is that it's convenience through disempowerment, it only "works" for the supplier if you buy more, or more expensive brands, than otherwise. That's what I mean by adversarial relationship.
- koboll 8y agoI don't really think people ultimately care that much about turning over information about their domestic economics, if convenience trumps cost. (Have they stopped using Facebook and Google?) It simply did not in this instance. Buying something on Amazon is easy. If I know what I want, and all my info is stored on Amazon, it takes 30 seconds tops. Shortening it to 10 seconds isn't worth it. Now, if Amazon offered, say, a RFID scanner that could automatically reorder toilet paper or diapers or toothpaste if the number of units within 3 feet fell below a certain threshold... I would absolutely consider getting it. Delegating that decision completely so I never have to make it again sounds great. Yes, I know they could still screw me over on price, so I'd check periodically to make sure they weren't ramping it up on me over the normal cost of the products. But even if they didn't, they'd still make more money by ensuring they sold the next units the instant they were needed, rather than whenever I remembered to reorder. Sometimes that's too late -- say, when there's a couple sheets on the last toilet paper roll and I have a near-crisis that involves crab-walking with pants down to the paper towels. Accumulated over a lifetime, those extra early days or weeks will really add up.
- 2_listerine_pls 8y agoAlexa made it worthless
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoThe richest man in the world is worthless? I don't get it.
- PascLeRasc 8y agoregarding "should have called it Bezos", I think there's some subconscious sexism in home assistants that they're all female voices. We like thinking of our Google Home or Alexa as a secretary/homemaker, which have traditionally been female roles.
- belorn 8y agoIt is sexist that in apple, microsoft and googles user tests, both women and men prefer the female voice over the male voice. There is also a lot of sexis found by the Stanford University study which revealed that preferences for male or female voices depend on the subject matter. Both men and women prefer a woman voice when talking about people and how things relate to each other, but prefer a male voice for bare facts about objects. Additional there is also some racism in there as some nationalities go against this preference in user tests, leading to apple to have male as the default home assistants if you are British, French, Dutch or Arabic.
- Touche 8y agoI still use mine. Especially for laundry detergent, I'm going to miss this. Subscriptions are something I've tried a couple of times but have this problems for me: - I don't know how often I need a lot of products. I could keep a spreadsheet for 6 months and figure it out but I don't want to do that. - It's hard to remember "do I have a subscription for this?" so I wind up ordering anyways.
- jerf 8y agoThe key to subscription usage is actually to buy a bit more frequently than you need, and when too much of X piles up, you skip the next subscription delivery or two for that. Ideally you still have enough subscriptions in that delivery to receive the 15% off. I do it for a variety of vitamins that I need, so it's less of a big deal for me if I stack up a bit extra on one thing, because they're just pill-bottle sized. It's nowhere near as large as having 5 or 6 too many laundry detergent containers on hand or something. This is still non-zero maintenance, but it's less. I don't do it for the convenience anyhow, I do it for the discounts, especially for things that I can't get locally anyhow.
- ericcholis 8y ago100% this. I really want to take advantage of the subscriptions. But, I find it hard to "know" when I need to have something delivered. Plus, despite the very fast shipping for most things, I still need those baby wipes NOW.
- Touche 8y agoYeah this is something I should have mentioned. If you run out of something before your subscription redelivery date then the subscription is basically pointless. The entire point is to not have to think about buying something.
- josefresco 8y agoSilly question but do you feel "excited" when using it? The geek in me thinks I would, but after a few uses I can see it being boring and a non-event.
- GuillaumeBrdet 8y agoI have to say I always found it quite intriguing but never actually got one. I am quite positive this will eventually come back, in some way by Amazon or not. It could be interesting if it was direct with the merchant, on a Shopify kind of level or even from bigger suppliers. All while bypassing Amazon pretty much. The irony in this working would be wonderful.