3 ms·
I'm not sure that a cult of process would be desirable - even putting aside irrationality of investors in the first place (and there is plenty in that field bot
by Nasrudith 8y ago
I'm not sure that a cult of process would be desirable - even putting aside irrationality of investors in the first place (and there is plenty in that field both mostly with short-term but also with long-term).
Process dominated companies often have issues with failing to adapt to a changing world as the reasons behind the process no longer exist and yet they stick with it anyway only to wind up out-competed and irrelevant.
On another note CEOs are generally overcompensated - especially if they wind up getting paid well even if they run things into the ground but I'm not sure process is a good antidote - I suspect the true issue is the lack of good feedback mechanisms/incentives given how many times companies have engaged in utterly stupid moves to try to inflate stock prices or earnings temporarily.
Meanwhile higher paid entertainers actually makes sense and are rational - they actually need to command the value fundamentally to be able to sustainably receive that much pay and paying them a 'reasonable' wage that massively undervalues them gives a strong incentive to jump ship when the enterprise depends upon them. It may not speak well to people's priorities given more important jobs that are paid far less but that is the economic reality.
- 75dvtwin 8y agoThx for the note. So, I tend to separate a 'process' from a 'ritual'. Most organizations would have 'rituals', but not processes in the context I noted above. A 'ritual', is a process without clear goals, and without compliance and compensatory controls. So, when a company has a pow-wow annual product strategy meeting, driven by a new CEO... or a technology group holds bi-monthly Architecture board meeting, or a data governance meeting -- those are mostly rituals. Not processes. Rituals, masked as 'processes' are bad, of course. They take oxygen out of the cult-of-the-process and move it back, again, to the cult-of-personality. Which, then creates very similar 'profile' to the one of an organization that depends on a 'hero/mover and shaker/brilliant CEO'. I do challenge myself at times, to compare how my disdain for the culture-of-personality would work at a war time.. Do general win wars, or do the troops? I am going to say, at I need to learn quite a bit of more historical facts before, I can approach that subject. Which is also why, I believe, solid bias-free education in history is almost essential for the work in management consulting, large organization transformations, and even creative consumer-oriented product design. -- WRT my point on entertainers. Their talents today, are not fundamentally different than the same talents that were appreciated 3000 years ago. Because these are bound to physical human abilities (and I include comedian/actors there as well). This is in stark contrast to the professions that leverage scientific knowledge to achieve their expected outcomes (eg engineers, medical doctors, etc). There is no net-positive-to-society economic model, where we can justify an actor making more than 1000 science teachers or a 1000 soldiers. As I noted above, I think the entertainers benefited greatly from technologies, that allowed them to multiply and extend their performances in space and time. For non-sportsman entertainers , additionally the copyright system , put them on the same footing as engineers leveraging the patent system (both systems are now heavily abused to install mafia-like control over engineering or entertainment content). Lack of wars among the super-nations, and using entertainers as vehicles for political agenda, also gave them additional compensation leverage. Last 50 years, in western societies, have been exceptional for those professions. And I find their current compensations whether it is Messi or Bill Maher, or Tom Cruise -- just repulsive (and even more so, than of mediocre or even talented CEOs).