4 ms·
Thoughts and a crazy prediction on ipv6
- runjake 16y agoWe already have IPv6 deployed on our ~10,000 node network. It was pretty simple to set up (after learning the basics of IPv6), and since the latest versions of Windows and Mac OS X default to IPv6 over v4, most of our internal traffic is v6 (most of our servers are Windows, and they reg AAAA recs in DNS). DHCPv6 is still a bit of a mess (at least on the Cisco end), though. I'm sure there will be many operational issues, but I get this feeling the fear is a lot like it was for Y2K.
- pilif 16y agoWhile the article sounds really crazy, I can really see something like this happening, even though possibly over a longer time frame. For one, the time where ICANN can't hand out any more address blocks isn't the same time as when providers will be unable to hand out addresses. Many providers keep large unused pools and will just continue to sell addresses from those. Once these get scarce, public IP's for dialup customers are the first thing to go. Then follow public IP's for smaller server customers (you can in theory do reverse nat based on the Host:-header. Of course this really breaks SSL, but we don't need that anyways - see firesheep). Whatever happens, we won't see IPv6 adaptation. Scarcity of IP addresses is extremely beneficial to the current players who already have their addresses as it a) puts an end to unloved services as P2P, VoIP and some kinds of streaming or at least makes it incredibly hard (once you put your customers behind NATs) and b) gets rid of competition (by not handing them out IP addresses) The glorious time where everybody with a bit of time and skill could design and implement a working product are going to be over as you'll just not get the address you need while the existing big services have stockpiled their addresses. They will become the gatekeepers. If they like your service, they buy you and provide the needed addresses. If not, you are screwed. Or you get one of those IPv6 addresses which will be unreachable for a majority of internet users because it's totally not in the interest of ISPs to provide V6 connectivity. I'm telling you. This isn't going to end well. It'll take longer than what's predicted, but it'll end up badly. Please - give me arguments why I'm wrong and why we'll have large scale IPv6 deployments in the near future.
- btmorex 16y agoHere's what I predict: 1.) IPv4 addresses get harder and harder to obtain especially in large numbers. 2.) Some authoritarian country with a quickly growing internet population (China) mandates a switchover. 3.) Business everywhere scramble because they want to sell in China 4.) For all practical purposes, the transition is complete. Consumers in the rest of the world switch over in following few years.
- someone_here 16y agoBut will China forbit connections to IPv4 addresses? That seems pointless and harsh. If they still allow connections to IPv4, I don't see why people will bother to switch.
- fragmede 16y agoComcast is already running trials of IPv6 - http://www.comcast6.net/ http://www.comcast6.net/ After full exhaustion, they are eventually expecting to transition to IPv6 for customers, with IPv4 access tunneled over IPv6. http://www.comcast6.net/gateway-opensource-info-large.jpg http://www.comcast6.net/gateway-opensource-info-large.jpg
- drdaeman 16y ago"Already", "trials"... Oh, never mind, there's a whole year (or even more!) before RIRs will allocate last block from their assets!
- jerf 16y agoIPv6 gets adopted when the ever-dropping cost line meets the ever-rising cost line of IPv4, and not sooner. (And IPv4's cost line has only really twitched upwards; unfortunately due to the nature of this sort of rigid supply/growing demand situation with market forces being suppressed by the supplier ignoring them you tend to only see the price spike at the end of the supply. If we were being really rational about this we'd be raising the price on IPv4 blocks already.) Once that happens it becomes difficult to predict exactly what happens next, because as people marginally transition to IPv6, that causes the cost of IPv6 to further drop as people iron the problems out (making it easier), but the costs of IPv4 drop too as IPs become more available again. I suspect IPv6 will win if for no other reason than momentum, though; the perceived costs of not transitioning will become higher as it becomes the "in" thing to do. The hands have been wringing over the past decade as people have overestimated the costs of IPv4 and underestimated the costs of IPv6, by quite a lot. But I suspect this will not be the exception that breaks the simple principles of economics. Incidentally, some blame can be laid at the feet of those who designed IPv6 and took the opportunity to jam every wishlist item into it they could think of (to a first approximation), thus raising the price of IPv6 through the roof and causing the lines to fail to cross until quite late. Had IPv6 been an incremental improvement over IPv4, with a larger address space, the costs would have been much less (though still large and easy to underestimate) and the cross-over would have come much sooner. Perhaps it would not have come yet, but it would have been sooner and more graceful (since, after all, a global price curve is only an approximation, what matters are all the local ones). A lesson for next time we need to redesign one of the Internet's core protocols: KISS doesn't stop mattering just because the problem is big! (Quite the opposite, really.)
- smutticus 16y agoICANN is already preparing for secondary markets to appear where people can auction off unused IP space. It's inevitable and they know this. Eventually everyone will migrate to IPv6 simply because the addresses will be free. There will never be a day when you cannot get a new IPv4 address. But there will come a day when you don't feel like paying for one.
- rbranson 16y agoThey aren't QUITE free. ARIN charges yearly fee of $1,250 for a /40 of IPv6 space. Of course, that's theoretically 309 SEPTILLION addresses (2^88), as much as organization will currently need. $1,250 for up to a /20 of IPv4s, which is a paltry 4,096 addresses.
- kree10 16y ago"Week 8: Cloud proviers, thanks to CFO-profit-center drives, now start charging for public IP addresses." I don't think cloud providers will stop giving out public addresses 'for free'. I think their default will be public ipv6, and charge a premium if you want ipv4. Or maybe they'll frame it as a "discount" if you want to use ipv6 only.
- iwr 16y agoNot everyone needs public-facing IP addresses. It's also possible to write network/web applications that work through NAT, or that don't need routable clients. Considering the transition to IPv6 will take at least a decade, do your apps need clients with public routable IPs?
- lawfulfalafel 16y agoI have always been under the impression that the limited nature of ipv4 is very detrimental for creating infrastructure in poor parts of the world. This might actually make large corporations (and more so governments) interested in preventing competitors from rising in foreign lands. You can afford fiber and all of the hardware to get an isp working? Great. Too bad you still have to pay your tithing for the artificial scarcity of addressing.
- wmf 16y agoI have always been under the impression that the limited nature of ipv4 is very detrimental for creating infrastructure in poor parts of the world. It's not. IPv4 is approximately free today; it's the smallest part of the cost of running Internet infrastructure. This might actually make large corporations (and more so governments) interested in preventing competitors from rising in foreign lands. Yeah, the only thing stopping Africa from kicking the US's butt in technology is a lack of IP addresses...
- lawfulfalafel 16y agoWell, I was talking out of my ass then. I was under the impression that places that had a large set of ip's (such as a few universities and corporations) would make a bundle leasing those to other people when there was more contention for addresses.
- wmf 16y agoThat will happen after the free IPv4 addresses run out in the future, which is why ISPs in developing regions should get as many addresses as they can now while they're free and prepare to adopt IPv6 if it turns out to be cheaper than buying IPv4 addresses.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoAlternate future history: IPv4 forces most ISPs to put ordinary household subscribers behind NAT rather than give them internet addressable IPs. A few things stop working for some people, some folks grumble, the spread of internet worms slows down considerably.