3 ms·
High speed rail is beneficial over time; other parts of the world are doing it with success. It seems a very bad sign that a large project in the USA is so diff
by mistrial9 8y ago
High speed rail is beneficial over time; other parts of the world are doing it with success. It seems a very bad sign that a large project in the USA is so difficult, as mentioned elsewhere. Last quick comment is, don't discount the possibility that this is hardball from a new (attorney) Governor, and there are more chapters to this story coming.
- macinjosh 8y agoThe difference between America and Europe, Japan, etc. is that is so spread out. To get from place A to B in an airplane you essentially just need two runways. A train needs miles and miles of expensive track that wind around the landscape between the two places. It just doesn't make sense except in densely populated areas like the Northeast.
- londons_explore 8y agoThe track itself isn't the expensive bit. It's simply steel, concrete and gravel, and probably could cost <100k per mile. It's the compulsory land purchases and expensive consultants which are the main expense.
- dx034 8y agoTrack for high speed trains can be very expensive. Unless land is very flat, it's not uncommon for >50% of track to be on bridges/in tunnels.
- taobility 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beijing–Shanghai_high-speed_railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beijing–Shanghai_high-speed_ra... The HSR between Beijing and Shanghai has 87% length are elevated.
- acchow 8y ago> To get from place A to B in an airplane you essentially just need two runways This is definitely not true. SFO's Terminal 1 cost $2.4 billion. Let's not forget the huge amount of greenhouse gas emissions from airplane fuel.
- magduf 8y ago>It seems a very bad sign that a large project in the USA is so difficult It's not just this one project, it's all the infrastructure in the US. It's horrifically expensive to build (compared to countries like Germany and Japan, which themselves are not low-cost-of-living places), it takes forever to build, there's massive cost overruns, etc. America is really just politically broken and unable to build the infrastructure it needs to continue as a world-leading economy.
- yostrovs 8y agoSomehow America continues to be a world-leading economy, with a growth rate considerably better than that of Europe with its high speed rail. Can you name a large European company formed in the last decade or two that's dominating anything at all in this world? Something like Google or Facebook or Uber or Airbnb or Stripe?
- Fins 8y agoThe cynic in me says that all of these companies (maybe except Stripe, not familiar enough with them to know if they are embroiled in anything shady) are far to cavalier with privacy, legality, and generally common decency to fly anywhere else.
- acchow 8y agoTrue. The eastern section of the bay bridge was originally estimated to cost $250 million. It ended up costing $6.5 billion.