7 ms·
Wouldn’t it be more accurate to say that it’s correcting an imbalance? Google operates in France but is able to undercut France businesses for digital content
by r00fus 8y ago
Wouldn’t it be more accurate to say that it’s correcting an imbalance?
Google operates in France but is able to undercut France businesses for digital content sold to French people ( merchandise is traceable ) because it happens to have an Ireland operation?
- jsty 8y agoIIRC, under EU VAT regs Google Ireland will charge and remit French VAT rates to the French treasury for digital content sold to consumers in France, so there's no imbalance there. The big issue is that digital services, particularly advertising, are so insanely profitable that most governments would also like to get their hands on a proportion of the profits accruing from sales of digital services in their country. They see the fact that Ireland / Luxembourg are able to book all the profit in one jurisdiction as unfair. There's probably not a huge likelihood of that happening any time soon at an EU level, so France has gone with the next best option from their POV. (Tax avoidance strategies that allow a large multinational to not pay much tax to their host country is a different kettle of fish, since most of the benefit of tackling those would probably accrue to the country of incorporation not France - e.g. the Apple settlement)
- dfilppi 8y agoIOW, they see some loot to grab.
- sbacic 8y agoIf the imbalance is that an Irish company is more competitive than a French one, then no, not really.
- BartBoch 8y agoIn this case, this will be the race to the bottom and smallest countries will be able to charge 0% tax just for the sake of office space rented since their domestic market is small enough to not bring much of income tax (Luxembourg for example). The issue here is with omitting responsibilities. If a company makes hundreds of millions of income in a country, it should pay some taxes there. There is a huge push in Poland now, to introduce non-refundable revenue tax (of 1.5%) on larger companies in place of income tax. This would solve the issue entirely.
- iguy 8y agoThat's interesting. Are there large companies who would pay this 1.5%, who do not at present pay much Polish VAT? Or employ many people? Otherwise, why not tweak existing large taxes? You could do it on the employer's social security contribution (i.e. the part paid before not after the nominal salary) to make it sound better.
- BartBoch 8y agoCompanies like Google, Facebook etc. don't pay taxes in Poland by claiming expenses in Ireland/Holland. Thus they are "at loss" in Poland. The revenue tax would allow no tax avoidance due to that.
- iguy 8y agoI understand but disagree about the tax on profits, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19295683 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19295683 But my question about what Google et. al. actually do in Poland. Is it a sales office for a product made elsewhere? (Few employees, large cash flow.) An engineering office for a product sold elsewhere? (Little VAT, lots of income tax.) Etc.
- BartBoch 8y agoSales for a product made elsewhere. I know where you are going with this - the issue is that they don't pay pretty much any taxes due to avoidance, yet they drain the market from the revenue thus limiting the ability for local companies who cannot avoid taxes trying to develop in this space.
- briandear 8y agoIf a small country can afford a 0% tax, why shouldn’t they avail themselves to that competitive advantage? Unified tax rates amount to a tariff on more fiscally competitive countries.
- 8y ago
- marsokod 8y agoThe problem is not that Ireland is a country using its taxes more efficiently than another. The problem is that one country can offer a much lower rate that is only viable for them if companies make their entire EU business as if it was happening in this country. Let say you are Luxembourg, and the average tax is 30% of your profit in the EU. Luxembourg is roughly .1% of the EU population. Assuming an ideal world, a company would them make .1% of its profit in Luxembourg. Now, let say Luxembourg offers a deal with a company so that they can artificially put all the profit from its EU operations in Luxembourg: in order for the country to keep the same taxes, it would only need to have a tax rate of 0.03%. From the Luxembourg point of view, they have the same tax amount as before. And from the company perspective, they are now paying taxes as if they were only paying taxes in Luxembourg, which is peanuts for them. Now, the current situation is not as caricatural as this scenario, but that is what is happening. The end result is just lower taxes created artificially (but legally). And the big problem is that it is not easy to fix while being in a EU context: the easiest solution would be to have common tax rates, though that would create some other issues. At the very least, closer tax rates would help the matter as moving your profit from one country to another is not free for the companies.
- DomreiRoam 8y ago"so that they can artificially put all the profit from its EU operations in Luxembourg" That is illegal because your accounting and document are not supported by reality. But it is difficult to prove it.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThere are plenty of imbalances within the EU, Greece grows olives, Germany grows Volkswagens.