4 ms·
Pretty much answer to all of this is yes - terrorist blacklists powered by cameras and surveillance in public, Guantanamo Bay with prisoners without due process
by izacus 8y ago
Pretty much answer to all of this is yes - terrorist blacklists powered by cameras and surveillance in public, Guantanamo Bay with prisoners without due process and oversight, police killing black people without punishment and military industrial complex lobbying established government all exist.
From the outside, USA with its more noticably overbearing propaganda or China with its disregard for US set morality don't seem that hugely different. These moral arguments from US side are laughable for anyone who was sitting on the other side of diplomatic table.
Lesson here is that we (as in europeans) need to get rid of dependency on both of those nations for core services.
- leereeves 8y agoThe US isn't perfect, but the events you're talking about are in no way comparable to imprisoning a million Uighurs in camps. Or executing Falun Gong practitioners and harvesting their organs. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-45474279 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-45474279 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Gong_practitioners_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Go...
- iforgotpassword 8y agoAs it stands right now I actually feel the US has a much stronger influence on Europe, which is what I'm concerned with. Not anything those two countries do at home. Considering how there's a backdoor revealed in Cisco products every other day I already know who I don't want to supply our 5G infrastructure.
- leereeves 8y agoI'd support any country/region building its own tech infrastructure. Europe should really do that if it wants to be a global power. But if your choice is between being spied on by the US or by China, why would you prefer China?
- iforgotpassword 8y agoI wouldn't. I think they're both a bad choice. It's just that the media seems to exclusively focus on huawei. And I can somewhat understand the American media doing that, but it's no different here. We've had like what, three Cisco backdoors in the last couple weeks, but who besides tech gave a shit? Actually, there isn't anything published yet that would suggest huawei products contain any. Nothing besides "they're evil commies so it must be true" And I mean, we even do have European businesses in that sector but it seems we're not even trying.. Unfortunately.
- speedplane 8y agoThe big difference between U.S/Cisco and China/Huawei is that in the U.S., the government broke into Cisco's systems without their help or consent. In contrast, it is largely understood that Huawei freely assists and cooperates with the Chinese government. The combination of a major tech provider with a powerful government provides too much temptation for abuse.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoBoth methods succeed. At that point it's just choosing between plague and cholera.
- speedplane 8y agoThat's a ridiculous equivalence. It's like saying a government backed army and a guy with a gun are the same because they can both shoot people.
- iforgotpassword 8y ago> That's a ridiculous equivalence. No, it isn't. > It's like saying a government backed army and a guy with a gun are the same because they can both shoot people. This however qualifies for that title, since you're probably underestimating China if you're comparing them with a single person with a gun.
- izacus 8y agoIt's not, but putting up a moral argument based on "hey, we're SLIGHTLY less evil than China because the scale of same crimes are smaller!" is still a bit wierd. You can argue many other avenues (like having better quality of life if we stay aligned with US vs. China), but doing moral handwringing about Huawei after Snowden's leaks and failings of current US government is a bit hypocritical.
- threeseed 8y agoYou are either ignorant or disingenuous. 23m Chinese have been banned from buying plane or train tickets based on their social score. Show me anything in the US that is remotely equivalent. Show me a re-education camp in the US where tens of millions are being detained. Is Guantanomo Bay even remotely the same ?
- llukas 8y ago> 23m Chinese have been banned from buying plane or train tickets based on their social score. Show me anything in the US that is remotely equivalent. Try to rent apartment without or with low credit score...
- speedplane 8y agoIt happens to recent college grads every day, they buy renters insurance or get their parents to co-sign.
- izacus 8y agoYou're pretty much now relativizing based on scale. When I get locked up and harassed without any kind of due process by an American customs official (because economic ties require me to travel to US), I really don't care what China does. And based on my few last trips, the Americans have been significantly more hostile to me on the border than the Chinese. It seems that some European countries are already reacting to this needless hostility by slowly realigning themselves to China: https://www.economist.com/briefing/2018/10/04/chinese-investment-and-influence-in-europe-is-growing https://www.economist.com/briefing/2018/10/04/chinese-invest... We're in for some interesting times.
- monksy 8y ago> Pretty much answer to all of this is yes - terrorist blacklists powered by cameras and surveillance in public, UK!=US >Guantanamo Bay with prisoners without due process and oversight, It's been a lot more documented than people who "disappear". > police killing black people without punishment and military industrial complex lobbying established government all exist. This is an issue that our officials refuse to address.