3 ms·
Is continuing to use fossil fuels a bad thing, if it's in conjunction with sufficient cleanup systems? It sounds like in your example, the problem is the bait-a
by taneq 8y ago
Is continuing to use fossil fuels a bad thing, if it's in conjunction with sufficient cleanup systems? It sounds like in your example, the problem is the bait-and-switch from "clean CO2-neutral power plants" to "traditional coal power plants".
- saagarjha 8y agoThe question is how you're going to cleanup CO₂, which is almost always energy-negative.
- thatcat 8y agoCoal plant emissions contain toxic substances other than CO2. Also consider the fly ash disposal and the environmental disruption of mining. So, yes, aside from CO2, continued energy production using coal is an unsustainable strategy.
- hannob 8y agoStopping fossil fuel burning is always preferrable to carbon cleanup technologies. It's simply cheaper and easier. Also "CO2-neutral coal power plants" is a scam. You'll always have emissions left. Digging up coal causes emissions (the coal is not alone, there's e.g. always methane coming up with it that you can't capture). No Carbon removal tech can remove 100% of Carbon from emissions. (There was actually a lawsuite because Vattenfall called one of their CCS testing plants "carbon free". They lost.)
- lozenge 8y agoYou need about 1.5-2x the amount of coal to provide the energy for the clean-up systems. So you can expect politicians to "increase efficiency and reduce dependence on foreign coal" by turning them off. Also, I can't find figures easily but it still wouldn't be as clean as solar, nuclear or wind.
- ajross 8y ago> Is continuing to use fossil fuels a bad thing, if it's in conjunction with sufficient cleanup systems? You missed the point. The problem in the grandparent post isn't with the first clause, it's not even with the feasibility of the second clause. It's with the "if". The "if" won't happen in practice. So that makes the answer to your question "no".