2 ms·
Well, this cert is OV (IV?) so it's always going to be at least semi-manual because we know the structures to truly automate OV issuance are flaky at best. The
by tialaramex 8y ago
Well, this cert is OV (IV?) so it's always going to be at least semi-manual because we know the structures to truly automate OV issuance are flaky at best. The fact a DigiCert person looked at this application is unsurprising.
The problem starts when that person gets to do crazy things like pick a Public Suffix as the thing being validated and gets worse when the "proof of control" is only barely related to the thing claimed. I await more from DigiCert on what was supposed to be going on here and how they'll improve.
I don't buy the theory that DNS is worse than WHOIS. Even the WHOIS proponents generally try to fudge this by trying to compare RDAP, because the security considerations for WHOIS come down to "cross your fingers".
In theory RDAP becomes mandatory (for the gTLDs) later this year. In practice we know the pilot programme was not exactly a roaring success and the registries have decided they'd rather the entire mechanism went away.
But we'll see, I care mostly about Prevention of Future Harm, if we prevent Future Harm by going to RDAP successfully that's fine for me too.