3 ms·
Predictably, the title alone is crack to HNers. If only stakeholders and designers would ask our opinion first, we'd save them the trouble! Between the author
by hombre_fatal 8y ago
Predictably, the title alone is crack to HNers. If only stakeholders and designers would ask our opinion first, we'd save them the trouble!
Between the author patting himself on the back for coming up with "don't do things for no reason" and "don't make things worse," he provides this criteria:
> The only time a UI should be updated is if it impacts the ability of a user to actually use your application.
This criteria can be rewritten "only change to make improvements," but this is an eternal challenge with anything.
The previous UI wasn't handed down by god. It, too, was designed, and the only thing it has going for it compared to the global optimum is that it at least exists. And like any other system, it was built under different requirements with different unknowns. It accumulates debt and falls into the same traps of any other rewrite. Most importantly, it has to interface with actual humans.
I can sympathize with their rant over grating redesigns, but it's too easy to lambast things that go wrong and then plant your flag of "Yep, don't do this. You're welcome." It contributes to the toxic cynicism rife in our field.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoI think that's a deliberately uncharitable interpretation. If you're admitting there are problems in the previous redesign (and you are), then why not fix those pieces rather than redesigning the colors, icons, and entire rest of the interface? It's not so different from an engineer who rewrites a whole service because it has 3 bugs. Almost never worth.
- subjectsigma 8y agoCongratulations on writing the only reasonable comment in this dumpster-fire of a thread
- sinker 8y agoI expected to at least be entertained by the article but it's so full of faulty reasoning I stopped reading about three quarters of the way through. It's full of platitudes and has little critical reasoning to support such a broad statement as its title. >> "If you possess a good eye and steady hand, you should feel compelled to create something that looks pleasing" Okay.. Goes on to include a big picture of Michelangelo's "David" to suggest that designers should strive to create masterpieces in the same vein...? >> "People use applications because of their purpose, not because it is pleasing to the eye." Another baseless generality. The first part is obviously true, but it doesn't follow that people don't care about appearance. >> "The only time a UI should be updated is if it impacts the ability of a user to actually use your application." Another unsupported opinion phrased as an absolute. >> "It hurts retention" This would have been a natural point to include actual data. Nonetheless the article falls back on making generalizations about people's behavior. >> "Does it really add up, or are you just giving designers busywork that doesn't amount to anything in the end? Do we have concrete evidence that what we are doing will provide benefit to the company or users, or just feel that it would be better if the UI was redesigned? Take a minute, think about that one." There's not a single piece of concrete evidence in this entire article.