30 ms·
> This story angle(and its related links) is really about pundits who > NEVER DID ANYTHING HARD mocking nuclear engineers who are trying to > remanufacture
by pyre 16y ago
> This story angle(and its related links) is really about pundits who
> NEVER DID ANYTHING HARD mocking nuclear engineers who are trying to
> remanufacture something from the past, essentially from scratch.
Seems to me that the 'moral' of the story is that the government should
have kept better records (of the design, and the manufacture process). So that they didn't have to start from
scratch. $69M is the price tag for our lack of foresight/incompetance.
The only other smaller moral is that we need to find a way for
classified things to be found when they need to be found, rather than
ending up in a bottomless pit because no one that has classification
knows that it exists or how to find it.
- jws 16y agoThey learn that lesson periodically. At one point nearly 50% of the money they spent to have systems built by my people was spent on documentation no one ever read. ever.[1] If it only cost $70M to develop a process and replace them that is a bargain compared to the wasted documentation on the 9999[2] contemporary items that were never needed again. To be more concrete, the guys building the bigger sister system to ours probably blew through that $70M on write-only documentation every 12 months for years. [1] It piled up under desks until they asked us to "only" submit one paper copy because they didn't have enough desks at the program management office. We did eventually talk them down to a reasonable level of documentation, but it took years and the program level staff had to fight hard to get there. [2] I made this number up.
- mbyrne 16y agoActually, I am glad they didn't write a step-by-step "Making H Bombs for Dummies" guide like you suggest. Because NOTHING is ever kept secret if it can be passed along like papers or computer files. Witness the long and ongoing history of nuclear espionage breaches. Having the full recipe broken up and distributed in the brains of a trusted group of people is significantly more secure.
- pyre 16y agoThen they should at least have a plan for knowledge transfer rather than letting those people die/retire without passing on the knowledge, no?
- Dove 16y agoI'd be surprised if the specs were simply lost. More likely, they said, "Load <archaic file format> into <obsolete software> on the <ancient machine you'd have to get from a computing history museum> to control <manufacturing process nobody uses anymore>." And after fiddling with the design for a while, someone said, "Well, we can approximate that with <modern manufacturing process>, but the <technical characteristic> is going to be 10 instead of 5. Is that okay?" And there was nobody around who knew.