3 ms·
There are some that would say that a government should not be able to force you to inject things into your own or your children's bodies. They would call that
by freedomben 8y ago
There are some that would say that a government should not be able to force you to inject things into your own or your children's bodies. They would call that tyranny.
Much of the pro-choice argument regarding abortion is based on the idea that you own your own body.
My kids get vaccinated, but I sympathize with the anti-vaxxers arguments regarding governmental force.
- melling 8y agoIt's a bit of a public health nuisance when kids start dying because other people don't want their kids to get a measles shot It's hard to believe that tens of thousands of kids still die from the measles every year.
- turtlecloud 8y agoThe same argument could be said that kids born to unwilling mothers leads to social and moral decay. If you are pro abortion/ pro choice you must be pro choice for anti vaxx.
- belltaco 8y agoAbortions don't create negative externalities like the anti-vaxx crowd does.
- throwawaymath 8y agoNo it can't because there is no direct, empirical relationship between children born in neglectful or under-resourced households and medical illness in other children. You can mount an abstract argument that there are secondary or tertiary effects that increase e.g. crime, violence or what have you. But that kind of relationship is not nearly as tight nor as evident as the reduction in herd immunity effected by fewer children receiving vaccinations. It's a difference of category, not degree.
- freedomben 8y agoI don't disagree. I personally think it's irresponsible not to vaccinate your kids. I also support schools and such requiring vaccinations for attendance (although that gets murky when the government runs the school). But using the government to forcibly inject stuff into people's bodies seems wrong.
- krapp 8y agoWhy do you keep calling it "stuff?" and why "forcibly inject?" You say you support vaccination but you can't help but describe it without the necessary context, as if random Feds are strapping babies down against their will and pumping random fluids into them against their will for no particular reason. You can make your argument and avoid the pointlessly nefarious language.
- AnaniasAnanas 8y ago> as if random Feds are strapping babies down against their will and pumping random fluids into them against their will. That's not completely wrong. The kids in my mother's generation for example were force-vaccinated in school and a lot of them suffered through life-threatening kidney issues caused by said vaccine. This is certainly not the case right now, but I have heard of people advocating for mandatory vaccination in schools.
- melling 8y agoCan you be more specific? Which vaccines caused the problem, for example? What years? I got my shots in the early 1970's and I don't remember there being any problems, fears, etc. As far as I can tell, this all started about 10-15 years ago when the general public started jumping on the Internet in large numbers.
- AnaniasAnanas 8y agoIt happened around 1962-1964. It was a smallpox vaccine. My mother ended up with Nephritis and had to battle it for years while my uncle ended up with his hands and legs being paralyzed and had to get a surgery.
- adrr 8y agoVaccinating your child is basic medical care for your child. Your child has a right to life and my child has the right not to get whooping cough and possibly die from it. If you don't believe in vaccines, don't have kids.
- freedomben 8y ago> my child has the right not to get whooping cough and possibly die from it. Interesting, I've never heard that being disease free is a right. Where do you believe rights come from?
- SquishyPanda23 8y agoWhen you have an abortion it doesn't risk a disease outbreak that threatens the lives and health of large numbers of children. Even hardcore government-distrusting libertarians acknowledge some version of the harm principle.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI don't know, I'm pretty okay with the government forcing people to do things so they don't compromise herd immunity. I suppose it's cruel, but I find it hard to sympathize with people whose ignorant convictions are a disease vector.
- buttcoinslol 8y agoPeople are committed by the state (MN at least) for mental health reasons, and in certain cases, forced to take neuroleptic drugs, some of which are injected. Tyranny? In my opinion, promoting an anti-vaccination stance is akin to shouting fire in a crowded theater, or should be viewed as such. It's a public health risk.
- freedomben 8y agoIf you were committed by the state for mental health reasons, and in certain cases, forced to take neuroleptic drugs, some of which are injected, would you consider that tyranny? I definitely would ... But I concede that's a pretty hard problem to deal with. I don't have any answers. I personally know someone who is wrongfully convicted and serving a prison sentence. Maybe my mind is corrupted by movies but I've seen enough films where people are wrongly committed for political or revenge reasons that I would be hesitant to support that and give them the power to do it.
- buttcoinslol 8y agoWrongful conviction is an unfortunate part of our justice system. In some cases it is rectified, and others it is not. My point was that people who refuse vaccines and people with mental illness who refuse to comply with treatment potentially both pose a danger to others. If someone is harmed, whether by preventable disease or violence as a result of another's refusal to accept the recommendations of medical professionals, the party that refused vaccination/treatment causes harm to another without being held liable. Either someone else pays to make the party who suffered whole, or the party who suffered loses. I feel the state should intervene when people are unable to make the correct decision about medical treatment when there are negative externalities. It's unfair to those who comply.