3 ms·
I've recently been re-watching the show, and it stands up pretty well, especially the VFX. The two weaknesses I've noticed are the look (which is often dated to
by mcguire 8y ago
I've recently been re-watching the show, and it stands up pretty well, especially the VFX. The two weaknesses I've noticed are the look (which is often dated to the '90s) and (ahem) JMS' writing. The plots are good, and stand against ST-TOS as actual science fiction, unlike many other SF shows, but the actual writing...well, yeah.
Speaking of ST-TOS, B5 doesn't look too bad compared to the remastered (!) ST on Netflix.
- krapp 8y ago>The plots are good, and stand against ST-TOS as actual science fiction, unlike many other SF shows, but the actual writing...well, yeah. It seems like JMS never met a genre cliche or trope that he didn't like. Crusade, what there was of it, was even worse. The worldbuilding was much better than anything in Trek until (ironically) DS9 came along.
- tracker1 8y agoThe first season's acting was also very daytime soap opera... don't get me wrong, I loved the show as a whole, I just found the first season in particular sometimes hard to watch. Would LOVE to see a well crafted remaster, with some of the techniques that can improve images based on neighboring frames, and maybe a rework of all the CGI for higher detail. I'm have surprised there hasn't been a fan effort considering how far even desktop gaming tech has come since the series.
- Diederich 8y agoI actually generally enjoyed the writing. As stated elsewhere, most of the episodes in season 1 were weak. A minority of the episodes in season 2 were weak, and it just got better from there. If I may ask: what specifically didn't you like about the writing? Thanks for your reply.
- philwelch 8y agoThe dialogue in B5 seems like a dated screenwriting style because it is. Most of what's dated is the humor--the gags and character wisecracks fall into a set of 90's humorous screenwriting formulas, just as the wisecracks and gags in say, "Star Trek: Discovery" fall within today's set of humorous screenwriting formulas. (There are some humorous bits in B5 that are still funny, like the line where Londo calls Vir a "moon-faced assassin of joy", but most of these work because they sound like something the character would actually say and not just a cheap screenwriter joke formula.) But some of the writing still holds up.
- ethbro 8y agoI rewatch it every few years (except the last season). Most of the humor that still hits for me is because of the incredible comedic pairings. Andreas Katsulas and Peter Jurasik (I started listing the others, then realized there's a huge number of notable pairings, so instead: https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0105946/fullcredits/cast?ref_=m_tt_cl_sc https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0105946/fullcredits/cast?ref_=m_t... )