10 ms·
VFX, Amiga and Babylon 5 [video]
- apostacy 8y agoJMS, the creator of this show, was way ahead of his time, and did some amazing tricks to get this show produced. He drew heavily from technology culture, and found innovative ways to save money on production. He was able to get consultation from the NASA JPL (and credited them), and he pioneered early CGI; season 1 supposedly built a rendering cluster out of 486 computers. Another way this show was trailblazing was that it was the first network television show shot in 16:9. You can read more about it on the Lurker's Guide[1] (That is a usenet reference), which contains excerpts from the newsgroups where he gave feedback to fans after each episode. [1]: http://www.midwinter.com/lurk/ http://www.midwinter.com/lurk/
- AdamJacobMuller 8y agoThe original Babylon 5 script books are amazing as well. https://b5books.com/babylon-5-scripts-overview/ https://b5books.com/babylon-5-scripts-overview/ They contain all of the original scripts for every episode (in some cases multiple versions) as well as commentary written by JMS about both what is going on on-screen and off-screen. They have some really detailed information on the challenges he faced running this show in an exceedingly raw and real fashion. Sadly, they are only available in print and are very expensive. http://jmsnews.com http://jmsnews.com has complete archives of all of JMS's usenet postings, which span the entire period the show was on the air (as well as many years before/after). Again, some of this is very raw, like where he discusses the feature film due to be announced "in a few days" about the telepath war (which we never got :(). Anyway, revealed myself to be a huge B5 nerd here, but, I do believe it was in a number of ways one of the most visionary TV shows on air at the time, highly serialized plots 5 years before the sopranos and computer VFX that movies couldn't touch at the time.
- Diederich 8y agoHuge B5 fan here as well, watched them all (multiple times) as they came out. Honest question: does anyone know of any TV series that had a firm, 5 (or multi-year) arc planned out in detail years before any filming began? Babylon 5 got funded when JMS described, in detail, the last scene of the last episode in the last season. There were flash forward scenes in season 2 that took place in season 4. Two years later, they meshed together perfectly. Has any other show been like that? I'd love to know. (:
- mcguire 8y agoCompare it with Lost.... :-)
- Diederich 8y agoI just did some very fast research about that, and apparently both Lost and Battlestar Galactica attributed their coherent story arcs to Babylon 5. I never watched Lost though. If I may ask, assuming you watched the show: did they ever film scenes from years in the future, seamlessly connecting them in the present and then later on? Thanks for your reference.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Lost [...] coherent story arcs No. Those things cannot be used together that way. And I'm pretty sure that's the comparison the grandparent was suggesting.
- philwelch 8y agoBSG borrowed the idea of having a coherent story arc, but they didn't plan it out ahead of time. Ronald D. Moore had a podcast of commentary tracks for each episode and openly admitted they were winging it the whole time. What BSG did right was to get all the small things right--get a bunch of really, really good actors, make everything look as naturalistic as possible, and let characterization rather than plotting or abstract concepts drive most of the storytelling.
- 8y ago
- mcguire 8y agoI've recently been re-watching the show, and it stands up pretty well, especially the VFX. The two weaknesses I've noticed are the look (which is often dated to the '90s) and (ahem) JMS' writing. The plots are good, and stand against ST-TOS as actual science fiction, unlike many other SF shows, but the actual writing...well, yeah. Speaking of ST-TOS, B5 doesn't look too bad compared to the remastered (!) ST on Netflix.
- krapp 8y ago>The plots are good, and stand against ST-TOS as actual science fiction, unlike many other SF shows, but the actual writing...well, yeah. It seems like JMS never met a genre cliche or trope that he didn't like. Crusade, what there was of it, was even worse. The worldbuilding was much better than anything in Trek until (ironically) DS9 came along.
- tracker1 8y agoThe first season's acting was also very daytime soap opera... don't get me wrong, I loved the show as a whole, I just found the first season in particular sometimes hard to watch. Would LOVE to see a well crafted remaster, with some of the techniques that can improve images based on neighboring frames, and maybe a rework of all the CGI for higher detail. I'm have surprised there hasn't been a fan effort considering how far even desktop gaming tech has come since the series.
- Zardoz84 8y ago
- WorldMaker 8y agoMore than just being the first shot in 16:9, it was the first network show shot targeting HD television, before the networks fully agreed on what HD would be. It just never got the final HD treatment that it should have. It's still a huge shame that Warner Brothers supposedly lost all the digital originals for the special effects shots, because they should have easily had a chance to recompose the show for true DVD quality and then again for a decent Blu-Ray rerelease. Some alternate universe has amazing Babylon 5 remasters today on Blu-Ray versus the letterboxed no-worse-than-SD DVD copies ours is left with. (Another weird twist to the story here is that one tale has it that Warner Brothers blames French company Vivendi for losing the digital SFX archives, which WB loaned to Vivendi for a B5 game under development under the old Sierra games brand that was eventually cancelled. Which also isn't the only property that WB seems to have "lost" to Vivendi, as WB should probably be the owner of the No One Lives Forever videogame IP, by way of buying developer Monolith into WB Games, but Vivendi lost the publishing contract somewhere and no one seems to know in this timeline if WB actually does own it or not.)
- CharlesColeman 8y ago> because they should have easily had a chance to recompose the show for true DVD quality and then again for a decent Blu-Ray rerelease. IIRC, that was the actual plan from the beginning: render for SD TV in the 90s, then re-render when HD TV became common and computer power increased enough for it to be practical to render at those definitions.
- WorldMaker 8y agoIndeed. Which is a shame. Contrast it on the one side to DS9/Voyager as well which weren't even filmed on film and intentionally had no plans to preserve SFX work and will likely never see Blu-Ray releases. Contrast it on the other side to Star Trek TOS and TNG which were shot on film, and had a big enough audience to warrant rebuilding SFX almost from scratch to get a Blu-Ray release. B5 was primed to be right in the middle there and if not for the unfortunate losses of data, could have had a strong Blu-Ray release at a huge fraction of the cost CBS put into TOS and TNG remasters.
- 8y ago
- Rebelgecko 8y agoIs 486 the quantity or the type of CPU used?
- baldfat 8y agoMy church bought a Amiga 2000 and a Video Toaster because as a teenager they trusted me to get what they needed. It was there till 2004. :) I loved that machine.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoDid the church actually have a use for that system?
- trentlott 8y agoWell, he was apparently a member of the church - so, yes! And it was probably bordered on lust in the classical sense (and, more accurately, in the modern one).
- baldfat 8y agoYes they had a tv show on the local channel and we use it for adding to the video and credits. We then were one of the first video projectors and we used that for the projector.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoIt sounds like you're saying their trust was misplaced?
- baldfat 8y agoWe actually got a ton of use from it. We use to broadcast the Sunday morning service and it did all the graphics. Anything else would have cost $10,000 more.
- mcguire 8y agoThe narrator voice is synthetic?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSounds like he added some sort of filter on top of regular voice to sound like synthetic. It seems better than any synth I've heard. It's definitely not Amiga's translator library. :) Kinda weird and annoying.
- diggernet 8y agoIt's definitely synthetic. There are a few phrases which are clearly spoken other than how a human would. But yes, one of the best synths I've heard. And also very annoying.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoI do believe you're right. Some weird inflections in there.
- dmitrybrant 8y agoIt's a complete mystery to me why certain YouTubers do this. I'll take the worst human voice (even Fran Drescher or Rich Evans) over a synthesized one, particularly for expository narration. It reminds me of phishing phone calls, and instantly draws me away from the actual content.
- amiga-workbench 8y agoThere is nothing wrong with Rich Evans voice.
- bootcode 8y agoA guess would be quicker production process. If you adjust the script, just rerender it and done. Actually speaking and recording takes tons of time.
- cromwellian 8y agoWow, I'll have to add this to my set of "how can I show people, especially my Apple zealot friends who obsess about the original Mac 128k, just how advanced the Amiga was" videos. This video, is one of my favorites (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7rKj0DU8Xs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7rKj0DU8Xs), it shows just how advanced the Amiga was in 1985, let alone after 1987 when the 2000 was introduced. I learned to code on a Vic-20 and C64 (basic and assembly), but the Amiga was my first exposure to C, and LaTeX, and 3D modeling / video editing. I grew up relatively poor in Baltimore City, and this was an astonishing amount of capability for something so affordable. (I also learned soldering because I only had 512k of chip ram on my A500, and Commodore's official RAM upgrade was too expensive, so I bought my own RAM chips and soldered them directly to the mainboard) I have an unlimited amount of nostalgia for this machine (and Babylon-5!)
- jacobush 8y agoYou are my soulmate.
- spullara 8y agoLiterally the same progression as me.
- cromwellian 8y agoIf you're interested in C64 stuff, here's a video I made of some old C64 intros I wrote: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aViXXbUg_yU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aViXXbUg_yU
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoNice nostalgia trip you linked, only missing Super Hang On really - so close to the arcade, awful on every other platform. XCopy. whistles innocently
- cromwellian 8y agoI was addicted to Speedball 2: Brutal Deluxe for awhile. But truly, one of the greatest early games was Fairy Tale Adventure which came out in 1987. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E5_4DhXWdwo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E5_4DhXWdwo
- thinkingkong 8y agoI feel like we're still in the uncanny valley for voice synthesis for this type of narration. It's good but just bad enough for people to be unforgiving and have it feel creepy.
- mortenjorck 8y agoIt took me perhaps an entire minute before I realized something was strange about the voiceover and that it was synthesized, which, in my view, is quite impressive. Once I realized it was generated, though, I became much more attuned to the pitch-shifting artifacts, slight cadence irregularities, and cultural misses (like emphasizing the second syllable of "recall" in the title of the movie Total Recall). Still, a few more years of progress on neural nets (can GANs be applied to vocal cadence and intonation?) and I won't envy the position of mid-tier voiceover artists.
- jccalhoun 8y agoI couldn't watch the whole video because the audio was so bad. Of course I already knew most of what it was talking about so I don't think that helped.
- thinkingkong 8y agoFun Video Toaster fact: The founder of the company Tim Jenison[1] is the same guy that made the documentary 'Tims Vermeer' which if you haven't seen, is absolutely awesome. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NewTek#Tim_Jenison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NewTek#Tim_Jenison
- dreamcompiler 8y agoTrue. Another one: The engineer who built the first Toaster for NewTek was Brad Carvey, Dana Carvey's brother. The "Garth" character Dana plays on Wayne's World is Dana's impression of Brad.
- harel 8y agoI've posted this before, but this is my go-to Amiga story to demonstrate how amazing this was at the time where PC was the inferior alpha computer: My dad was a graphic designer/print shop and he was building the panels for an F-16 fighter jet simulator, built by a private company for the Israeli Air Force in the 90s. One saturday he took 14 year old Amiga fanatic me to the company HQ and I had a go flying an F-16 inside a real cockpit, 180 deg. screen, amazing out of this world 3D graphics. The whole shebang. That part was amazing as it is. However, what really blew me away was first getting a demo of the $250K SGI they had to run the whole thing, and then the real nuclear was the next room filled with tens of Amiga workstations they used to actually generate all the visuals and graphic models. Considering just around that time I tried those 90s first attempt virtual reality arcades, which were powered by Amigas but were quite shit because it was the 90s and not some oculus magic, seeing and flying that simulator was an out of body experience for 14 year old me. I can't express what the Amiga gave me in words. It showed me the future before i had to go back into the past and wait until it caught up.
- philwelch 8y agoBabylon 5 really opened the door to using this much CGI on a weekly show. Star Trek TNG and DS9 really didn't embrace it for a long time, even after B5 came out. It wasn't until the sixth season of DS9 that a major CGI effects sequence was used in Star Trek (though individual CGI assets were used prior to this): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VoIFUJxJwcQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VoIFUJxJwcQ
- yuchi 8y agoMy first exposure to computers was an A1200 — which my father bought in 1994. Now that I have a son, I’m desperately in search for something that could influence him as much as that Amiga did to me. Seriously, what is the Amiga of the current market? What is that product that fosters creativity and is so futurist?
- peterashford 8y agoThere isn't one. What made the Amiga great was that it was a technically amazing machine that hobbyists could actually use and do great things with. The equivalent today would be Sony allowing completely open use of the PS4 and letting anyone make anything for it that they wished. It wouldn't happen: companies today like their walled gardens. The Amiga flourished by being open.