3 ms·
Source: I have never been to the Moon, but I have played a lot of Kerbal Space Program. The problem was not landing. The problem was getting back into space, t
by vkou 8y ago
Source: I have never been to the Moon, but I have played a lot of Kerbal Space Program.
The problem was not landing. The problem was getting back into space, to rendezvous with the command module.
The reason this is difficult is because orbital plane changes (changes in your orbit's inclination) are expensive, and because astronauts can't sit on the lunar surface for weeks at a time.
Launching to rendezvous with a space space station (Or the command module) is, if you want to avoid very expensive plane changes, requires waiting for it to be a few minutes from passing directly overhead. Then, you launch into the same orbital plane as the space station, and, in the process of accelerating to orbital speeds, the space station catches up to you, and you dock to it.
If the command module is in an equatorial orbit, and you land on the equator, then rendezvous is as easy as taking off from the lunar surface, a few minutes before it is scheduled to pass overhead. This happens every ~2 hours.
If the comand module is in a polar orbit, and you land on the poles, then the same thing happens. The orbiter will be overhead every ~2 hours, so, again, rendezvous is very easy.
But if you land in the mid-latitudes, you suddenly have a problem.
The moon rotates. And it rotates slowly.
Imagine if the command module is in a polar orbit, and you land in the mid-latitudes. You spend two days driving golf carts on the moon. You want to get back to space, to meet up with the command module.
Except that the moon has rotated in this time. But the polar orbit hasn't. Instead of passing overhead, the command module is now one-tenth of the way around the moon from you. You can't launch into its orbital plane anymore.
You now have two options.
1. You can wait for a total of 13.5 days, when due to the moon's rotation, you will, again, be within the command module's orbital plane.
2. You can launch into an orbital plane that is ~30 degrees inclined to that of the command module. And then spend a tonne and a half of rocket fuel, to change your orbital inclination.
Both of these options, for obvious reasons, suck.
Now, option #1 gets a bit easier, if the command module is in a non-polar orbit - the launch window, instead of being every 13.5 days, may be every few days, or once a day.
However, if you need to, for whatever reason, perform an emergency launch, or if you miss the launch window, you may be screwed.
If the Apollo mission did not involve a command module (If the lunar lander was the craft that would come back to Earth), then all of this becomes irrelevant. You could then land at whatever latitude, and return to Earth, via a wide range of possible trajectories. (Except that, as another poster pointed out, you miss out on a part of, or all of the free-return trajectory boost, that you get from exiting the Moon's orbit in the opposite direction of its travel - which is ~1,000 m/s of delta-v saved.)
- ufmace 8y ago> If the Apollo mission did not involve a command module (If the lunar lander was the craft that would come back to Earth), then all of this becomes irrelevant. You could then land at whatever latitude, and return to Earth, via a wide range of possible trajectories. (Except that, as another poster pointed out, you miss out on a part of, or all of the free-return trajectory boost, that you get from exiting the Moon's orbit in the opposite direction of its travel - which is ~1,000 m/s of delta-v saved.) Yup. Another downside would be that the fuel needed to break lunar orbit and head back to Earth, enter Earth orbit, and then deorbit for Earth landing would have to be landed on the moon and lifted off from it again, requiring exponentially more fuel for lunar landing and liftoff. Do you have any idea what orbit the linked story was talking about and what the launch timing of that would be?
- ak217 8y agoThanks for the thorough explanation. This is the first and only one that I've seen that makes complete sense. Hopefully you can publish it somewhere!