6 ms·
I've never understood how those small parties persist. Either they're aligned permanently with one of the two dominant parties, where they can be given position
by jfengel 8y ago
I've never understood how those small parties persist. Either they're aligned permanently with one of the two dominant parties, where they can be given positions of trust and power, or they flop around (in which case nobody can make long-term deals with them). They strike me as the "ideas guys" of politics, carping about the way things are done without the risk of having to actually implement their own goals.
- mrkurt 8y agoThey only really persist if there aren't long term dominant parties. Or as opposition parties.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoPerhaps today. Particularly with our especially unrepresentative first past the post system that can only work for two parties. Going further back UK politics was much less whip-driven, or politics by pager as became the Blairite tendency. Minor parties were a more accepted part of politics, as was a far wider range of views within a party.
- 3pt14159 8y agoThey exist as a way of pulling people towards issues and as a release valve if the primary party gets too corrupt. Take the Green Party in Canada. Without it, the remaining left(ish) parties in Canada only have to go a little better than the Conservatives on the environment to get the environmental vote. With the Greens in, they have to at least meet them half-way or they risk further splitting the centre-left. They also sometimes hold the balance of power. This puts their issue front and centre.
- dbdjfjrjvebd 8y agoWhy has wanting clean air and water become a left right issue?
- tux1968 8y agoBecause it's not the goal that's in dispute, it's the difference of ideas about how to achieve it.
- whatislovecraft 8y ago> Because it's not the goal that's in dispute Yes, it is. Many Republicans in the USA specifically state that the environment is here for us to ravage and do whatever we want with. Adding pollution and choosing to not clean it up is part of Republican Party platform of short-term gains while not pricing in the real economics of the situation. > it's the difference of ideas about how to get achieve it. I've not heard a single idea from the Right in the last 20 years that would either 1) reduce pollution, ever, or 2) increase the safety of food and water supplies. They are always cutting the regulations with the obvious intent to dirty the water and air for cashmoney in the short term. Why is it like this? I don't know. But the 'left' is the group looking for capitalism to succeed out hundreds of years, and the 'right' is the group looking to get all the 'money' they can before the food is all poisoned and the water is too. -- This is not a partisan post of political opinions. I'm just stating facts here. The Republicans aren't trying to hide any of this! It's their platform - pretending it isn't, and downvoting me so nobody sees this post, is just going to make the problem worse in the future. Bad actors are hurting our environment and making it more difficult to get reliably clean water and air - and they are Republicans.
- iainmerrick 8y agoI think you’re correct. If people disagree, please post some counterexamples!
- travisoneill1 8y ago> I've not heard a single idea from the Right in the last 20 years that would either 1) reduce pollution, ever, or 2) increase the safety of food and water supplies 1) In the USA CO2 emissions are dropping mainly due to natural gas replacing coal. This was possible because of the development of fracking. Democrats are against this, Republicans for. 2) The best carbon-free technology that we currently have, and can deploy at scale, is nuclear power. Republicans for. Democrats against.
- scj 8y agoSmall parties provide opposition. They can change the national conversation on issues[0]. Sometimes they provide confidence in minority parliaments (remember, in our system of government, losing a confidence vote generally means an election). Small parties also provide a protest vote, and since voting occurs on a riding-by-riding basis, the desire and intent of the protest can vary. Sometimes protests can be so widespread that no government can form a majority. In Canada, we managed to elect three minority governments in a row over a period of seven years (2004 - 2011). In short, voters use small parties to send a message. [0] The NDP's first national leader, Tommy Douglas, was never Prime Minister, but is known as "father of Medicare" and is generally well regarded by Canadians decades after his death.
- lostlogin 8y agoThe flip side of this is the toxicity of first-past-the-post. You get a choice on once issue and have to take the rest that comes with it. It baffles me that people accept this.
- strken 8y agoTo elaborate on this, in America today it's possible to waste your vote, because you can't represent secondary political opinions, e.g. a vote for the Starbucks CEO doesn't flow down to your second choice. In some other systems, you can choose multiple options. This makes it possible to represent an opinion like "Starbucks CEO, then Democrats, then Libertarians, then Republicans", and so smaller parties can still get votes without compromising the election of larger aligned parties.
- scarejunba 8y agoThe SF mayoral elections work this way and it's quite cool.
- wolco 8y agoWhy not allow people to vote themselves on each issue? The purpose of a single person representing an area is less desirable than ever. Direct democracy would solve a lot and create different issues.
- HappySweeney 8y agoThis has been attempted, and generally leads to disaster. When a bill for increased spending is introduced (for say, better roads, more schools, etc), it receives widespread support from the voters, and easily passes. When another bill which raises taxes (in order to pay for the previous purchases) is introduced, it enjoys widespread condemnation, and is soundly defeated. Bankruptcy ensues.
- likeclockwork 8y agoMaking mistakes is a crucial part of learning.
- PeterisP 8y agoQuite the contrary, small parties focused on a niche goal can be very effective in attaining that goal - if the dominant parties need their support, they pretty much have to give in to the small party's pet peeve, and in return the small party gives them votes for the other issues. For example, at least a part of current Brexit hassle is because the DUP (with their 1.5% of total MP seats) are needed by May's government, and they got to veto one of possible options of solving the Ireland-North Ireland customs border issue. There are many other examples worldwide, where small parties focused on a particular domain of problems can get an oversized influence in that domain.
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoI never understood why in a democracy those votes for small parties are allowed to go to waste. They should be able to give there "dropped" votes to a bigger party for a legislative period, for negotiated terms. "If you promise to push opticfibre to all homes in these citys, you can have our voters voice for the next 4 years." This would solve the problem of unheard voices and- allow actual negotiating politicians to be trained and get busy.
- RugnirViking 8y agoRanked choice voting