5 ms·
While comparing Paypal banning a few people to China is hyperbole, you're not entirely wrong. With Facebook/Google in the role of data gathering, I think insura
by AlexandrB 8y ago
While comparing Paypal banning a few people to China is hyperbole, you're not entirely wrong. With Facebook/Google in the role of data gathering, I think insurance and credit companies will slowly move us towards a distributed version of social credit. Where doing something "bad" can affect your credit score and insurance premiums eventually making your life impossible if you do enough "bad" things.
- leereeves 8y agoWho will define "bad"? In China, "bad" means opposing government corruption. > When [reporter] Liu Hu recently tried to book a flight, he was told he was banned from flying because he was on the list of untrustworthy people. Liu is a journalist who was ordered by a court to apologize for a series of tweets he wrote and was then told his apology was insincere. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/china-social-credit-system-surveillance-cameras/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/china-social-credit-system-surv... > Liu had posted information about embezzlement by a local official, Ma Zhengqi, on his personal page on the Weibo social network because he knew that censorship would prevent its publication in the newspaper. https://rsf.org/en/hero/liu-hu https://rsf.org/en/hero/liu-hu
- Hydraulix989 8y agoIt depends. If you have more political power than the person you are reporting, then you will be fine.
- creaghpatr 8y agoTheir system is easier to execute, definitely more difficult to pull off in bipartisan US with public and private sectors.
- AlexandrB 8y ago> Who will define "bad"? That's why I put it in quotes. "Bad" in this case depends on what a company thinks makes you high-risk or otherwise undesirable as a customer. In the case of health insurance, it may be when Google or Facebook classifying you as having a sedentary lifestyle. In the case of banks it may be if you take too many trips to Vegas. In the case of the NSA, it may be posting negative things about the current administration. Because it's distributed among many actors, it will be like the existing credit score system - mostly opaque and unaccountable. Good luck convincing an insurance company that Google misclassified your behaviour.
- tombh 8y agoWithout wanting to unnecessarily stoke the hyperbole, I'm struck that the Facebook/Google beast is a level more powerful because the effects of its "scoring" are implicit and emergent, rather than China's being explicit and contrived. I assume the Chinese system could be dismantled relatively quickly without overturning the fabric of their society. Facebook/Google on the other hand is so engrained in the nature of Western society I find it difficult to imagine how we transition away from them. China's system is hand-cranked and top-down. The Facebook/Google system has a life of its own that pervades the very foundations of its host.
- spaced-out 8y agoI think the nature of the entities are very different. Facebook/Google/Paypal provide a new vector of boycotting/vigilantism. People with ideologies sufficiently unpopular with the mainstream get targeted for boycotts, which can spread to the rest of their financial and social network. This effect is impossible to separate from society because its an expression of something that's always been part of human society -- shaming and shunning. The Chinese system is top down, and designed to maintain the Communist Party's hold on power. Every aspect of the system is dictated from the top, so of course it could easily be dismantled or changed.
- creaghpatr 8y agoI don't think they are all the same. Anyone can live fine without Facebook. Being banned from Google services would be very inconvenient, but being banned from the credit card consortium would be a life-changing blow. Chase Sapphire has stepped into the arena in this regard, canceling credit for users with unsavory political beliefs.
- AlexandrB 8y ago> I don't think they are all the same. Anyone can live fine without Facebook. Being banned from Google services would be very inconvenient... You're not thinking big enough. Already, even details like mobile location information is leaking into the hands of bounty hunters[1], which means such information is probably easily available to less controversial operations like insurance companies. Wait until a "background check" for housing means asking Facebook if you've ever expressed an interest in smoking. [1] https://www.engadget.com/2019/01/08/companies-resell-us-carrier-data/ https://www.engadget.com/2019/01/08/companies-resell-us-carr...
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoThe difference to me is that in China, you can lose social credit by "spreading rumors online," and we all know what that's code for. More generally, there's a big difference between "we won't let you do X because we don't trust you" versus "we won't let you do X because we have moral objections to something you've done." China's social credit system takes the latter into account. Edit: Frankly, I'm getting pretty tired of this "the US is no better" discussion every time there's a news story about China's social credit system. The US has some major problems, but conflating the two is a false equivalence. When CNN reporters are banned from flying because the president thinks they're "fake news", we can have this discussion again.
- fixermark 8y agoIt gets a little muddy (there's definitely a train of thought that goes "We don't trust you because we have moral objections so something you've done," witness the boycott of Gillette for their toxic masculinity ad, or of Chik-fil-a for their support of "conversion therapy"), but to a first approximation I agree with your take.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoThere is a separate conversation to be had around how quick some people are to "blacklist" individuals and organizations they think did something objectionable. But at least in that case, it's a bunch of individuals voting with their wallets and/or time, as opposed to a central authority. Put another way, there's a reason free speech (as it's defined in the US) applies to the government and not private entities.