7 ms·
I know at one point w3schools.com was a bit out of date but they seemed to update it. As someone who has changed careers and moved into web development I found
by duxup 8y ago
I know at one point w3schools.com was a bit out of date but they seemed to update it.
As someone who has changed careers and moved into web development I found w3schools.com did a nice job of complementing MDN as if I was unfamiliar with the concept (or just forgot entirely) w3 was a good "layman's terms" stop just to start. And if I needed a more technical / granular detail, MDN.
I really wouldn't want to use one without the other.
Many years ago I took some C programming classes in college. It was in the early days of the internet and it was very much a "here's the book, a bit of lecture, now sit alone at your computer and do it". MDN can feel that way at times where it's example is ultra specific and while nothing is technically wrong.... it's like learning a language with a dictionary. w3schools.com fills that gap nicely.
At the same time if I need the dictionary to figure out more precisely how something works and all my options, it's MDN all the way.
- pluma 8y agoPart of w3schools' bad reputation comes from intentionally failing to disavow itself from the W3C (w3.org) while providing commercial certifications. The W3C asked them to clarify this non-affiliation several times and it seems the only thing that ever came from it is one sentence on the About page. Seeing that many developers (including experienced professionals) thought the two entities were related, it seems obvious that they directly benefited from that confusion. Luckily this seems less relevant now that WHAT WG exists separately from W3C and ECMA/TC39 is more prominent.
- duxup 8y agoI didn't know that thanks. I wonder how many folks using w3schools.com really know who w3.org really is ;)
- hans_castorp 8y agoPart of w3fools bad reputation stems from the fact the site is (or at least was) full of errors - especially their SQL part.
- andyjohnson0 8y agoW3Schools has been turning-up in my web searches for probably as long as it has existed [1] and I can't remember it ever occurring to me that it was affiliated with the w3c. Maybe this really was a concern to w3c but I seriously doubt many other people were mislead. [1] Just checked. Twenty years!
- nacs 8y agoI've been doing web dev work for over a decade now and always thought there was an affiliation with their w3schools and W3C. Fortunately I've only used them as a quick reference and not for any kind certification as OP mentioned they also provide. TIL
- ben509 8y agoI never did because I had seen sketchy brands trying to mimic popular brands before, so I was primed to be skeptical. But it is pretty natural in how language works for people to see similar names and assume an association. And you can't reconsider an unconscious association, since it's unconcious.
- kkarakk 8y agoit had such good SEO precisely because it was mistakenly assumed to be run by w3c by a LOT of devs who proceeded to click those links enough as to inform google that this is a "important site"
- teddyh 8y agoW3Schools also used to be quite bad and misleading; this is an old page with a huge list of problems with W3Schools: https://web.archive.org/web/20110117085131/http://w3fools.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20110117085131/http://w3fools.co...
- onli 8y agoUsed to is the important word here. They improved a lot. I like them. MDN is great, but w3schools is better in giving examples on how to use stuff.
- teddyh 8y agoI would rather use a site which started with correct documentation and added examples over time, than use a site which started full of bad documentation and examples, and slowly got corrections over time.
- onli 8y agoIf you use the site after it got corrected the difference is nil :)
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoI never use W3Schools but I have to say that I sort of feel bad about that because as a policy thing perhaps one should use something that has improved on bad behavior to become good in order to reward the improvement. Of course improvement without expectation of reward shows a higher moral stature, but it is a stature that is perhaps not to be expected, whereas improvement based on reward seems more likely to exist in our world - given studies of the matter.
- umanwizard 8y agoEDIT: It seems that Python lists are in fact arrays. Cool, so Python does in fact support arrays. Seems a pretty important fact to point out on a page called "Python Arrays". Original comment: There is still some complete nonsense on w3schools. For example, I wanted to know recently whether Python supports arrays. The first result on Google is this page: https://www.w3schools.com/python/python_arrays.asp https://www.w3schools.com/python/python_arrays.asp There is a small disclaimer at the top stating: "Note: Python does not have built-in support for Arrays, but Python Lists can be used instead." Why the fuck is your page called "Python Arrays" if you don't plan to talk about arrays? Then the rest of the page talks about lists, while erroneously calling them arrays, in complete defiance of the disclaimer. I imagine what happened is that someone who doesn't know what an array is wrote the page originally, then someone else came by later and realized it was wrong, but instead of actually fixing it, slapped that half-assed disclaimer on top. I still don't know whether stock Python actually supports arrays. I ended up just importing Numpy.
- kochthesecond 8y agoI am of the opposite experience. I find the w3schools site to be so terribly out of date, with such terrible approach to learning and documentation I found it did me more harm than good. If you actually read the docs on MDN, you can write stuff that actually work instead of copying random snippets of code until it does what you want to do.
- HGMIV 8y agoAs someone who is new to all of this, I like W3 schools as a complement as well. I like the MDN but a lot of it goes over my head. W3schools does a good job of breaking some stuff down and can be easier to read. But at the same time I find the MDN much more resourceful when I'm trying to get down to the nitty-gritty.
- duxup 8y agoYeah I certainly flow from one to the other a lot. If I need the finer details and understand what i'm looking up, straight to MDN. If I'm in over my head and want a bit more context, back up to w3. And then sometimes back to MDN ;)
- ohaideredevs 8y agoI feel the need to "me too" here. I use MDN almost exclusively now, but W3 schools helped me a TON before I could understand MDN.
- osrec 8y agoI find w3schools dumbs it down a bit too much in certain cases and sort of gets in the way of finding the info you want. Compare https://www.w3schools.com/jsref/jsref_substring.asp https://www.w3schools.com/jsref/jsref_substring.asp with https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Global_Objects/String/substring https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Refe... The MDN doc allows you to run the code there and then - no jumping around to a "Try it yourself" page. Also, MDN gets to the syntax quickly - with w3schools, I have to search for the syntax in amongst a bunch of other junk that I really don't care about at that moment (like browser compatibility). To a seasoned dev, MDN feels clear, w3s feels like a confusing mess. Maybe for early stage devs it's the other way round?
- onli 8y agoBoth of them seem to be equally useful to me. Both show the one thing I search the most at the top: The example.
- osrec 8y agoIn w3schools, "Definition and Usage" starts referring to "start" and "end" parameters before even mentioning them. It's really quite annoying to read that first and then see the syntax...
- fetbaffe 8y agoI stayed away from W3schools for a long time because the bad reputation, but I started to use it again recently and noticed that it had imropeved greatly. W3schools is better when it comes to HTML+CSS with JS sprinkled on top questions IMHO. MDN for the specifics.