3 ms·
I sympathize, but at the same time IMHO the verbal abuse must continue. You need to squeeze the TSA from all possible sides - passengers, their own employees, a
by potatolicious 16y ago
I sympathize, but at the same time IMHO the verbal abuse must continue. You need to squeeze the TSA from all possible sides - passengers, their own employees, and the airlines for any meaningful change to occur.
I also find it somewhat disheartening the number of comments that fall back on the "I am a professional, I don't decide policy" argument - which to me smells a little too close to "just following orders" to be comfortable.
Now that the Godwin wall has been broken, I found this tidbit interesting:
> "Do people know what a Nazi is? One can’t describe me as a Nazi because I am following a security procedure of designed to find prohibited items on a passenger’s body. A Nazi is someone with hatred and ignorance in their hearts, a person who carried out actions of execution and extermination of those based on their religion, origins or sexual preferences."
The problem with this statement is that the security procedure will not find prohibited items on a passenger's body.
Secondly, a "Nazi" in the average case is just a guy trying to survive in a nation gone completely mad. What, does anyone seriously believe that every German soldier in the war was filled with "hatred and ignorance" and gleefully executed Jews and gays? I'd argue most were not so much different than you and I - people just doing the only job available to them, morality be damned.
So, at the risk of being inflammatory, I'd say they are like Nazis, or rather that the situation is rather like what the Nazis faced: a lot of batshit insane policies instituted by megalomaniacs blindly being followed by an army of dutiful people, many of whom take pride in the fact that their professionalism prevents them from rebelling from a clearly immoral act. In fact, many German soldiers were able justify their participation by believing that they were protecting Germany, not the Nazis. Sound familiar to any of the comments on the page?
I realize that for many TSA screeners, their career prospects are not exactly widespread, and asking them to quit and starve just to appease their moral conscience is unrealistic. Nonetheless, this does not imply the inverse - which is that just because these people are human, have feelings, and are following unpopular policies, doesn't excuse them from criticism, even particularly harsh ones.
Yes, you have feelings. Yes, you are human like the rest of us. Yes, you are only doing your job. But despite your best intentions, you are still molesting me. Doing so with orders shifts the moral responsibility somewhat, but doesn't change what you're doing still.
- toast76 16y agoYou saved me the effort of typing it. I feel ANY person in ANY role has a duty to themselves and the people they work with (or for) to not comply with orders/instructions which go against their beliefs, values or morals. When I was younger I sold used cars. We were instructed that if a potential buyer asked us if a car had been involved in accident, we were to shrug and say "we don't know" even if it was clear to us that it had been. Whenever I was asked I told the truth...most of which then didn't buy the car. When I lost one too many "done deal" sales, I lost my job. I had to go find another one. but at least I never had to go home and cry myself to sleep for being a cheating, lying scumbag. These people aren't "drafted" to fight a cause they don't believe in, these are people voluntarily doing a job they signed up to do. I don't envy their position, as I am sure if they could get another job they would. It doesn't defend their complicity in acts which they know to be wrong. If they don't agree with what they're doing, they have the choice to not do it.