6 ms·
Link between health spending and life expectancy: US is an outlier (2017)
- dwighttk 8y agoI’ve always wanted to see this chart with the US broken down by state.
- jopsen 8y agoI would imagine that there is maybe a few small states that does well, but it's unlikely to be one outlier that draws the entire chart down.
- dwighttk 8y agothere could be a few large states where the expenditures are astronomical, pulling the whole US to the right... Who knows, since we always see the US vs Denmark vs Luxembourg vs Monaco vs Vatican City
- dwighttk 8y agoI'd also be interested in how Life Expectancy at Birth is calculated in advance.
- gumby 8y agoIt’s really just death rate at the time the newborn is born: if x% of the population died in 2016 and that never changed going forward, how long would the mean person born that year live (given that people born in earlier years would be dying at their rate, contributing to the formula. So technically not actually predicting an expected lifespan (thermonuclear war could happen after all) but allows longitudinal and secular analysis.
- dwighttk 8y agook, so infant mortality from that year doesn't effect the number? (any more specifically than those deaths adding to the overall death rate)
- gumby 8y agoYes it does
- dwighttk 8y agoHow?
- gumby 8y agoI described the approach in my first comment: for 2018 (now it's over) look at the death rate and then apply estimate it uniformly going forward for all recorded births during the year until the surviving population goes to nil. The death rate is all the people who died, whether 1 jan or 31 dec regardless of the age of the deceased. If you want greater resolution on a process like this you'll do better to search yourself than to reply on HN commenters like me.
- wil421 8y agoI’d like to see the E.U. as a whole vs US. It would also be interesting to see the States mapped against the countries in the article.
- petschge 8y agoGiven statistics that show that blue states tend to do much better on life expectancy I have the feeling that nobody wants to publish that break down as it will only result in a partisan shouting match and drown out the larger message that the US is really failing to provide health care (as opposed to a for-pay health system) to its citizens.
- cxseven 8y agoThe Bible Belt is running out of notches
- dwighttk 8y agowhat?
- kbutler 8y agoAn attempted pun on a belt running out of notches as you loosen it to accommodate increased girth, and the Bible Belt leading the obesity statistics. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3866220/figure/F1/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3866220/figure/...
- somberi 8y agoAsking to learn. What is this kind of graphing, the one that plots the trend over animated time, called?
- blaze33 8y agoTry looking at Hans Rosling's work, he made similar charts, has a company called gapminder and there's a nice ted talk with animated charts on world data.
- kbouck 8y agoGapminder's moving bubble charts seem to be called "moving bubbles" https://www.gapminder.org/tag/moving-bubbles/ https://www.gapminder.org/tag/moving-bubbles/
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 8y agoI thought that was Rosling's company, awesome!
- skookumchuck 8y ago> but also in child mortality Different countries have different definitions of infant mortality. When is it categorized as a miscarriage and when an infant death? The US tries very hard to save premature babies, and counts the failures as infant death rather than miscarriages.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoI think you'll find that the US is not alone in trying that and that other countries simply don't limit that kind of efforts to the well insured elite. When visiting a hospital is a potentially bankrupting event, a lot of young uninsured mothers might end up not going to a hospital or going too late. Also, prenatal checks are not optional. The attitude towards abortion combined with religious conservatism also pushes a lot of young women to look for solutions outside the traditional healthcare system; which has all sorts of risks for the mother. I find it ironic that the net result of pro-life policies is increased mortality rates for babies and mothers.
- skookumchuck 8y ago> I think you'll find that the US is not alone in trying that It's all over the map, there are even societies where the baby isn't considered a person until some time after birth. It's certainly enough to question the relevance of the statistics.
- chrismeller 8y agoHas anyone ever disputed this? Isn’t what we should be trying to prove whether or not that increased spending is actually providing innovation in drugs and procedures and thereby enabling other countries to put varying degrees of price controls in place without severely limiting the quality of care? Framed in the opposite direction: could the US put in any form of price control to equalize this metric without significant impact to the continued investment in the field?
- adrianN 8y agoIf the US managed to save money on healthcare, that extra money should go to universities so that the results of the research are not proprietary to pharma companies, but instead can be used by anyone.
- shaftoe 8y agoThat's not how it works. Commercialization of drugs from University research is what already feeds a multi billion dollar industry.
- adrianN 8y agoThat's how it could work.
- chrismeller 8y agoHow exactly do you see a system working that way? We establish a single payer plan and just start taxing everyone based on the current estimated healthcare expenditures and blindly shove money at universities?
- adrianN 8y agoYou shove money at universities and don't patent the drugs they come up with so that companies can compete on the price of manufacturing them.
- skookumchuck 8y agoUnfortunately, there are no free market health care countries to compare with.
- Uberphallus 8y agoFortunately or not, the US is far from having free market healthcare, especially considering its public health expenditure per capita alone beats most developed countries' public and private expenditures combined.
- skookumchuck 8y agoThat's right. And before the government got massively involved in it, health care price increases pretty much matched inflation. The big ramp up in prices, that have never slowed down, started in 1968 with Medicare.
- FartyMcFarter 8y agoThere is free market health care. It's called "veterinarians". Granted this won't do for comparing all metrics, but it's still an interesting reference point. Here's one article about this: https://hbr.org/2017/01/what-the-cost-of-a-trip-to-the-vet-tells-us-about-why-human-health-care-is-so-expensive https://hbr.org/2017/01/what-the-cost-of-a-trip-to-the-vet-t...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 8y agoIs that even true? Is there a definition of "free market healthcare" that only the US meets?
- maxxxxx 8y agoPricing is pretty much free market. It seems they can charge whatever they feel like.
- brianjoseff 8y agoWhat is going on with Greece in the first life expectancy chart? Large reversal in cost increase coupled with unperturbed steady increase in life expectancy. Also has impressive numbers in other charts.
- nicwilson 8y agoLikely to be a delayed time effect, people aren't born and live to 80 in the space of ~15 years.
- pjc50 8y ago2008 financial crisis forced drastic cost-cutting. The question is what the lag on health effects of that was. We know from things like smoking prevention and childhood diseases that the lag can be huge, anything up to half a century.
- rcdmd 8y agoA few things off the cuff as a physician-- the US has dangerously unequal access to care. I suspect most of the "drag" on life expectancy is from patients without access (this is conjecture but based on personal experience). Even patients eligible for medicaid don't necessarily go through the steps to get it. Often we see patients show up to the hospital who haven't seen docs in a many years until they've developed terrible sequelae like gangrene requiring an amputation. At that point, during admission, the hospital generally helps get them on medicaid. Also, obesity is becoming the new normal in US with all of its associated co-morbidities (a common morbidity/mortality sequence is obesity -> diabetes, hypertension -> coronary artery disease, end stage renal disease, general vascular disease -> death. More healthcare spending is required to treat patients, but the root cause for a growing part of the population's illnesses can't be cured by medicine yet. Also, economically speaking-- the US spends a lot more per capita on mostly everything-- its GDP per capita is higher than these other countries. But, mostly, I suspect the US's health mortality problem is access related. We're spending a lot of money on things that don't help people with poor access to care until their original diseases have done irreversible damage.
- quizotic 8y agoDo you have any insight into the reason for the unequal access? Is it that poorer or uninsured patients cannot afford non-emergency healthcare? Is it that they are too far away? Is it education/knowledge/social - belief that they shouldn't go to a doctor for "nothing". Are they "too busy". Also, are there any studies to show that populations in other countries use their medical systems more frequently across the board, or that they use more frequent preventative visits? You mention the problem with obesity and its co-morbidities. Are there any studies or plots that show health outcomes (lifespan, infant mortality, maternal mortality) as a function of % of population who are obese? I wonder if poor health is linearly correlated with obesity, without regard to healthcare spending...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bluedino 8y ago
- 11thEarlOfMar 8y agoIt would be interesting to see a chart normalized to Americans vs. Others with similar BMI ranges. For example, Americans with 18-25 BMI (I know you're out there!) vs. French with the same. By taking out those with a very general correlation for 'does not take care of their own health', we'd get a truer measure of the relative effectiveness of the respective health care systems.
- door5 8y agoBMI is a poor indicator of health and and even poorer indicator of whether one takes care of themselves. In the US, unhealthy food is abundant and strongly advertised. Much of the country is sprawl where the only way to really get around is by car. People are more stressed and work longer hours & don't have the time to cook for themselves or exercise. The US lacks universal healthcare, some people live in food deserts where healthy food is not accessible, etc. The United States has such terrible infrastructure and social programs that it's unfair to pin people's poor health entirely on their own decisions
- smileysteve 8y ago> BMI is a poor indicator of health But it's an available statistic. If we had doctors report on body fat % (even done with shotty capacitance) or hip/waist ratio we'd be better off.
- fulafel 8y ago"Taking care of your health" is in significant part an outcome of your health care system.
- calebm 8y agoSo in the last 25 years, the medical costs more than doubled in the US and maternal mortality actually went UP?