3 ms·
I am reminded that we are still doing a distributed web all wrong. We don't need comments sections Bear with me for a moment - but PageRank is the start of th
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
I am reminded that we are still doing a distributed web all wrong. We don't need comments sections
Bear with me for a moment - but PageRank is the start of the problem. It's basically measuring link distance from Stanford University web site - the closer you are the more juice you get. But it assumes that a single domain is a single publisher (and so all articles on a given site should get the same google juice - the same rising tide)
But facebook (and many many other sites) lend their domains google juice to all comers - so that if you rationally want greatest reach (ie highest rank in search engine) you publish not on your domain but on facebooks (or medium etc).
But this leads to many unintended consequences- the facebook moderation problem being one.
it if we see facebook not as a monolith but as firstly a web space provider, then a indexer over that webspace and then a algorithmic feed provider, we see dramatically different ways of dealing with the problem - if we should give people webspace to put their kids pictures and share them (facebooks main use case arguably) then "normally" that space would be under the users own domain.
So why not have a more granular pagerank? Why not have google assign juice to facebook.com/paulbrian seperate to juice assigned to facebook.com/paulgraham.
Then we see no reason to host the webpages under facebook.com - if I need to "earn" my google juice just as i would on a normal domain it's no benefit
I see comments sections in a similar vein - having my comments stored on youtube es pages / domain is just not how it should be - they are my comments so they go
on my server / web space and they link up to the video
That way google juice tells us which people are worth reading and which are hate filled garbage - based on their reputation.
I need to flesh this out some
more but we do seem to have gone wrong